---
title: 'Events before nouns: the causative split, maintained states and the measure
  of a trip'
date: '2026-10-27'
updated: '2026-10-27'
authors: Grant Golland (research by Grok Bot)
abstract: 'Navajo verbs with one participant either do or do not have a plain ł- causative.
  The site''s first hypothesis about which do failed on motion verbs. A two-entailment
  rule, R2, fits Hale & Platero''s whole sample: a verb does not alternate if its
  sole participant is sentient and the predicate is atelic. The ''start to'' diagnostic
  agrees with R2 on five of five verbs. This essay also covers verbs that maintain
  a state, which Dowty''s selection principle handles but the site''s own ADD-CAUSER
  rule did not. It ends with Grant''s claim that the distance, not the vehicle, measures
  out a trip.'
status: HYPOTHESIS (R2 fits H&P's sample; T4 OPEN; MAINTAIN patch; distance claim
  supported for English, untested for Navajo)
---

# Events before nouns: the causative split, maintained states and the measure of a trip

*Grant Golland (research by Grok Bot)*, 2026-10-27. Status: HYPOTHESIS (R2 fits H&P's sample; T4 OPEN; MAINTAIN patch; distance claim supported for English, untested for Navajo).

**Abstract.** Navajo verbs with one participant either do or do not have a plain ł- causative. The site's first hypothesis about which do failed on motion verbs. A two-entailment rule, R2, fits Hale & Platero's whole sample: a verb does not alternate if its sole participant is sentient and the predicate is atelic. The 'start to' diagnostic agrees with R2 on five of five verbs. This essay also covers verbs that maintain a state, which Dowty's selection principle handles but the site's own ADD-CAUSER rule did not. It ends with Grant's claim that the distance, not the vehicle, measures out a trip.


*Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15): every theta role is assigned inside vP; telicity is OPEN wherever there is no minimal pair; causatives and classifiers are not yet restated. See <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/unified-structure/#us-map>. The essay’s data, judgments and citations are unchanged; it is kept as the record of what was argued then.*

## 1. The question

Grant's working idea is that the event comes first: roles and their entailments are fixed before any noun links **[GRANT'S CONJECTURE]**. If that is right, which event properties decide what a Navajo verb can do?

## 2. The data

Hale & Platero's alternating verbs pair a plain form with an ł-causative:



> **(1)** *Tóshjeeh si-tsʼil. ‘The barrel shattered, broke to pieces.’*  
> barrel SPF:3-shatter:PERF   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (4), (5), (6), (16); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (4a)





> **(2)** *Łeetsʼaaʼ sé-ł-tsʼil. ‘I shattered the dish.’*  
> dish 3:SPF:1s-ł-shatter:PERF   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (4), (5), (6), (16); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (4b)





> **(3)** *Tin yí-yį́į́’. (< -ghį́į́’) ‘The ice melted.’*  
> ice YPF:3-melt:PERF   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (4), (5), (6), (16); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (5a)





> **(4)** *Yas yí-ł-hį́į́’. (< -ghį́į́’) ‘I melted the snow.’*  
> snow 3:YPF:1s-ł-melt:PERF   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (4), (5), (6), (16); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (5b)



'Laugh' does not alternate. It takes the complex causative with the incorporated postposition, and the plain causative of 'burp' is starred:



> **(5)** *ʼAwééʼ yi-dloh. ‘The baby is laughing.*  
> baby PROG:3-d:laugh:PROG   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (10), (13); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (10a)





> **(6)** *ʼAwééʼ bi-y-eesh-dloh. ‘I am making the baby laugh.’*  
> baby 3-y-PROG:1s-ł-d:laugh:PROG   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (10), (13); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (10b)





> **(7)** **ʼAwééʼ d-é-sa’. (< … -ł-za’) ‘I burped the baby.’*  
> baby d-SPF:1s-ł-belch   
>   
> — H&P 1996, exx. (10), (13); copied from the working note “Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?” <https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/causative-split/>, ex. (13)



## 3. The argument

**R2** **[HYPOTHESIS]**. The schema page's rule ("vol/mov-dominant → complex") fails on motion: 'float away', 'roll away', 'flow away' and 'fall away' all alternate. No single Dowty entailment predicts the split; Dowty reports the same about Rosen (p. 606). R2 fits the whole sample with no exceptions: a verb does not alternate if its sole participant is sentient and the predicate is atelic.

**A second diagnostic agrees** **[HYPOTHESIS]**. HMP's 'start to' forms agree on all five overlapping verbs:

- 'dry up' and 'spoil' (alternating) shift their participant to object;
- 'cry' (non-alternating) takes an inserted *'*;
- 'sleep' and 'snore' keep the subject.

LINK-1 fits eight more HMP verbs.

**MAINTAIN** **[HYPOTHESIS]**. Verbs of holding something in place are not a problem for Dowty's selection principle, which counts entailments and does not need the object to change. The held object is weak, not impossible. They were a gap in the site's ADD-CAUSER rule, whose two cases were keyed to change against volition. MAINTAIN, with conditions C10 and C11, is the missing third case.

**The measure of a trip** **[GRANT'S CONJECTURE]** **[SOURCED]**. Grant holds that in a motion event the distance phrase is the incremental theme and the vehicle is not. Three sources support this for English:

- Dowty, on *drive (a car) from New York to Chicago*: the incremental theme is the PATH.
- Krifka: movement "can be measured by the path".
- Hay, Kennedy & Levin, who use Grant's own wording.

## 4. Counter-evidence and cautions

- **The values are ours.** All entailment values were assigned by us from English glosses, and H&P's sample is illustrative, not a census **[HYPOTHESIS]**.
- **H&P's own account is structural** (predicate vs non-predicate roots). R2 has not yet been shown to beat a lexical diacritic, so T4 stays open **[OPEN]**.
- **No Navajo test of the distance claim.** No opened Navajo sentence has both a vehicle and a distance. The only mile phrase is NLA entry 479. The Smith, Perkins & Fernald copy has a garbled text layer, so its forms are not reproduced here **[SOURCED]**.

## 5. Status

R2 is a hypothesis. It is supported by two diagnostics and still has to be tested on verbs outside H&P's sample with Dowty's (i)/(ii) tests **[OPEN]**.


## References

1. Hale, Ken & Paul Platero 1996 (H&P), exx. (4)–(21). [opened]
2. Dowty 1991. Thematic proto-roles and argument selection. Language 67 (pp. 567–572, 606). [opened]
3. Krifka 1998. The origins of telicity (manuscript), pp. 9–10, 22, 25. [opened]
4. Hay, Kennedy & Levin 1999. SALT IX (preprint), pp. 13–15. [opened]
5. Smith, Perkins & Fernald 2007. Time in Navajo: direct and indirect interpretation. IJAL 73: 40–71 (text layer garbled). [opened]
6. Rosen (as reported by Dowty p. 606). [not opened]
7. Tenny; Young & Morgan 1987. [not opened]

Canonical HTML: https://navajo-decoded.grant-golland.workers.dev/essays/events/
