When Plains Cree's impersonal actor X acts on a third person, the verb looks direct but cannot take an actor at all, so X>3 is not a transitive direct (T78a, T70e)
Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). The indefinites (ʼa-, ʼadi-, areal ho-) are restated as personless pronouns in ordinary argument positions (H60): ʼadi- as the silent indefinite agent in Spec,vP that raises to Spec,TP by the default (H10b), ʼa- in VP. The 3i data on this page have not yet been individually restated. Position-class template statements below describe the order of prefixes; they are not the derivation (§3). The “roles not words” theory, where it appears below, is dropped. Status on the spine: see unified structure, §4, indefinite and passive rows. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.
T78a asked whether an Algonquian X→3 form ('someone sees him/her') is direct or inverse. The last run could not tell, because Oxford 2022 gives only X→1/2 forms. This run opened Wolvengrey 2011, a Plains Cree grammar-length dissertation the site had not used before, which gives the full X paradigm. The answer has three parts. (1) In the independent order, X→3 has the direct theme -ā and endings "formally identical" to 1→3 and 2→3 direct forms (Table 2.65, (112c)) SOURCED. (2) In the conjunct it has -iht, which is neither the direct nor the inverse theme (Table 2.66) SOURCED. (3) No actor can ever be expressed with an X form, and the same meaning with an overt 'someone' uses the ordinary inverse ((105)–(106), (113)–(114)) SOURCED (Wolvengrey's judgments). So X→3 is direct in form only, and Wolvengrey treats it as syntactically intransitive SOURCED (his analysis). Two things follow. The warning against EI-8 on ergative-indefinite loses its basis (T70e) HYPOTHESIS. And the X>3 rank turns out to be a summary of this same split, not separate evidence (AX-12 dissolved) HYPOTHESIS. The strong roles-not-words thesis stays OPEN.
On this page: 1 Question · 2 Sources · 3 Rules first · 4 The data · 5 Answer to T78a · 6 Oxford's probe applied to X→3 · 7 What this does to EI-8 (T70e) · 8 No doubling, and a control test (T78c, T78d) · 9 Rulesets A and B · 10 Derivations · 11 The role schema (Focus 2) · 12 Fidelity notes · 13 Open questions
Notation is the same as on impersonal-x. No Syntax · Semantics · Interface conventions file is in the repo or the context folder. A = the word level (prefixal, left-headed in Navajo). B = the clause level (right-headed). Σ = the role schema, with Dowty's proto-roles as the baseline. INDF = Navajo ʼadi-. X = the Algonquian impersonal or "unspecified" actor. Wolvengrey's glosses are kept as he writes them (for example "X-3s" = X acts on 3s, "1/2" = local-person ending, IPV = preverb, CNJ = conjunct). A Leipzig line is added under each; it only changes his labels and keeps his segmentation. Plains Cree forms are in plain italics, not tagged as Navajo. Merge builds structure (puts two pieces together). Agree copies feature values such as person and number from a goal onto a probe. Oxford's Agree splits a probe's conditions into interaction (which goals it may copy from) and satisfaction (which goal stops the search).
1. Question
Oxford's Routledge chapter gives the independent theme-sign hierarchy as 1/2>X>3>3’>0 (PDF p. 17), which predicts that X→3 is direct. Oxford 2022, though, gives X fewer features than an animate third person ([ϕ, AN], no [PERS]; AX-1), and in the conjunct an X agent makes a verb go inverse more readily than an animate one (AX-4). impersonal-x §7 left this as AX-12 and T78a: what does an actual X→3 form look like? The answer also decides T70e (ergative-indefinite), which warned that a direct X>3 would count, by analogy, against EI-8 (Willie's inverse reading of biʼdistał).
2. Sources
SOURCED Wolvengrey, Arok Elessar 2011. Semantic and Pragmatic Functions in Plains Cree Syntax. PhD dissertation, University of Amsterdam. Utrecht: LOT (dissertation series 268). Free PDF from LOT (lotpublications.nl, Documents/268_fulltext.pdf). The PDF is born-digital (made from Word), and printed page = PDF page − 22. Read this run from the text layer, and checked against page images for the forms used here: pp. 158–159 ((105), (106)), pp. 163–164 ((111), Tables 2.65 and 2.66), pp. 165–167 ((112)–(115)), pp. 185–190 (§3.2, (18), (21), (23)–(29)), pp. 191–192 (Figures 3.1, 3.2).
SOURCED Oxford, Will 2022. lingbuzz 006486 (as on impersonal-x). Re-read this run for the mechanism only: pp. 9–10 (VoiceERG), p. 15 ((20) and "featureless Voice is realized as the elsewhere form -iko"), pp. 24–26 ((24), (25), the definition of the inverse pattern on p. 25, C3, C5).
Already on the site and not re-opened: Oxford's Routledge chapter PDF pp. 17–18 (ergative-indefinite, impersonal-x); Willie 1991 p. 152 (1f) biʼdistał=yę́ę and p. 37 (21) niʼdilzhééh (from page images on earlier pages).
Cited by Wolvengrey but not opened: Dahlstrom 1991, Jolley 1982, Déchaine & Reinholtz 1998, Ellis 1970, Hockett 1996. Still not opened: Goddard 1979, Nichols 1980, Valentine 2001.
3. Rules first
XT-1 Plains Cree independent X→3 = Ø (no person prefix) + stem + -ā + -w / -wak / SOURCED (Wolvengrey Table 2.65 p. 164,
-ýiwa. These suffixes "are formally identical to those which occur in the VTA (112c) p. 165)
Direct Mixed Set with first or second person actors and third person patients."
XT-2 Independent and conjunct X→SAP = stem + -ikawi + local ending (with the person SOURCED (Table 2.65–2.66 p. 164)
prefix in the independent). -ikawi is Oxford's INV.IMP.
XT-3 Conjunct X→3 = ē- + stem + -iht (3s), -ihcik (3p), -im-iht (3’). This is neither SOURCED (Table 2.66 p. 164)
the direct theme -ā nor the inverse -iko. Wolvengrey: the 3rd-person conjunct
forms are "truly exceptional" (p. 167).
XT-4 No X form allows an overt actor: (*awiyak) in (106), (*awiya) in (114). With an SOURCED (pp. 158–159, 165–166;
overt 'someone' the same meaning uses the ordinary inverse -ikw: 3s→1s (105), Wolvengrey's judgments)
3’→3s (113), where awiya 'someone' is itself glossed obviative (PR.3’).
XT-5 The hierarchy 2>1>X>3>3’>0 is "suggested" to analysts by exactly the split in SOURCED (pp. 163, 185–186;
XT-1 vs XT-2 (local forms ≈ inverse, third-person forms ≈ direct). after Jolley 1982, Déchaine &
Reinholtz 1998)
XT-6 With kakwē- 'try', the one who tries may be the patient ((23)–(25)) or the SOURCED (pp. 188–190)
unspecified actor ((26)–(28)), by context; one form, (29), has both readings.
"The actor is unspecified, but not pragmatically absent."
XT-7 Wolvengrey's analysis: the X construction does not remove the semantic argument SOURCED as his analysis
but makes it "obligatorily unspecified and unindexed"; X forms are (pp. 158, 165–167, 190)
syntactically intransitive, with no grammaticalized subject or object.
XT-8 Answer to T78a: X→3 is DIRECT IN FORM in the independent (XT-1), NEITHER in the SOURCED (forms and judgments) /
conjunct (XT-3), and not a transitive direct in either, because no actor can be the summary is ours
expressed (XT-4).
XT-9 Oxford's C5 Infl [int: PERS, sat: PART,PL], run on a TRANSITIVE X→3 structure HYPOTHESIS (our application;
(X in Spec,VoiceP), copies only the patient's features via Voice, so Infl and Oxford's paper covers 3→SAP only)
Voice match, Voice is impoverished, and the elsewhere -iko is predicted. The
attested forms have -ā or -iht. So either the model does not carry over to X→3,
or X→3 has no X argument in Spec,VoiceP (XT-7).
XT-10 AX-12 dissolved: the X>3 rank restates the XT-1/XT-2 split (XT-5). Under XT-7, HYPOTHESIS
an X→3 form contains no second argument to be ranked against the 3, so the rank
is not evidence about X's features, and it does not conflict with AX-1.
XT-11 T70e: the Algonquian argument against EI-8 by analogy loses its basis. X→3 is not HYPOTHESIS
a transitive direct (XT-8). The nearest transitive analogue of Navajo bi'distał,
an overt indefinite 'someone' acting on a 3rd person, is inverse in Plains Cree (113).
This is consistent with EI-8′ but does not decide it.
XT-12 T78c, Algonquian half: X cannot be doubled by a nominal (XT-4). Parallel with SOURCED (XT-4) / HYPOTHESIS (the parallel)
PX-11 (a Navajo noun links only to a slot with a person value). The overt
'someone' is a person-bearing obviative 3rd and enters the ordinary
direct/inverse system. X does not (cf. AX-7).
XT-13 T78d, Algonquian half: XT-6 is a test that tells a present but unindexed agent SOURCED (the test) / OPEN (Navajo)
from no agent (the actor can be the one who tries). A Navajo version needs an
INDF form under a 'try'-type predicate; none has been opened.
4. The data
Plains Cree forms are copied from Wolvengrey's examples and tables, with his segmentation and glosses, and checked against the page images. The Leipzig line is ours. It changes only his labels.
| (105), p. 159 | awiyak nikī-wāpamik. |
| awiyak ni- kī- wāpam -ikw -Ø · W: PR.3s 1 IPV VTA INV 3s / someone PST see 3s-1s | |
| Leipzig: someone 1-PST-see-INV-3SG | |
| 'Someone saw me.' (overt 'someone', ordinary inverse) | |
| (106), p. 159 | (*awiyak) nikī-wāpamikawin. |
| (awiyak) ni- kī- wāpam -ikawi -n · W: PR.3s 1 IPV VTA X 1/2 / someone PST see | |
| Leipzig: (someone) 1-PST-see-X-LOC | |
| 'I was seen.' *'Someone saw me.' (X form; an overt actor is ungrammatical) | |
| (112a), p. 165 | niwāpamāw. |
| ni- wāpam -ā -w · W: 1 VTA DIR 3s / see 1s-3s | |
| Leipzig: 1-see-DIR-3SG | |
| 'I see him/her.' | |
| (112c), p. 165 | wāpamāw. |
| Ø- wāpam -ā -w · W: X VTA DIR 3s / see X-3s | |
| Leipzig: Ø-see-DIR-3SG | |
| '(Someone) sees him/her.' / 'S/he is seen (by someone).' | |
| (113), p. 166 | awiya kī-wāpamik cān. |
| awiya kī- wāpam -ikw -Ø cān · W: PR.3’ IPV VTA INV 3s NA.3s / someone PST see 3’-3s John | |
| Leipzig: someone.OBV PST-see-INV-3SG John | |
| 'Someone saw John.' / 'John was seen by someone.' | |
| (114), p. 166 | (*awiya) kī-wāpamāw cān. |
| (awiya) Ø- kī- wāpam -ā -w cān · W: (PR.3’) X IPV VTA DIR 3s NA.3s / (someone) PST see X-3s John | |
| Leipzig: (someone.OBV) Ø-PST-see-DIR-3SG John | |
| 'John was seen.' *'Someone saw John.' *'John was seen by someone.' | |
| T2.66, p. 164 | ē-wāpamiht · ē-wāpāmihcik · ē-wāpamimiht |
| W: ē- + stem + -iht (3s) / -ihcik (3p) / -im-iht (3’) | |
| Leipzig: CNJ-see-X.3SG · CNJ-see-X.3PL · CNJ-see-OBV-X.3SG | |
| '(as) s/he is seen' · '(as) they are seen' · '(as) (the other(s)) is/are seen' | |
| (29), p. 190 | nikī-kakwē-wāpamikawin. |
| ni- kī- kakwē- wāpam -ikawi -n · W: 1 IPV IPV VTA XAct 1/2 / PST try see (X-)1s | |
| Leipzig: 1-PST-try-see-X-LOC | |
| 'Someone tried to see me.' / 'I tried to be seen.' | |
Table 2.66 prints the 3p form as ē-wāpāmihcik, with a long ā in the stem, unlike every other cell. It is copied as printed. Glossing -iht as "X.3SG" is our label. Wolvengrey's table leaves the X column empty for these rows and puts -iht under "endings" spanning both columns. Navajo comparison forms, not re-opened: biʼdistał=yę́ę (Willie p. 152 (1f), source gloss "PASS 3.3.kicked", 'the one who was kicked') and niʼdilzhééh (p. 37 (21), 'You are being shaved'), both as transcribed from page images on ergative-indefinite and passive-rank.
5. Answer to T78a
In the independent, (112c) wāpamāw is built exactly like (112a) niwāpamāw 'I see him/her' minus the person prefix: same -ā, same -w SOURCED. So the 1/2>X>3 prediction ("X→3 is direct") is met in form. In the conjunct it is not met: ē-wāpamiht has neither -ā nor -iko SOURCED. And in neither order does the form act like a transitive. An overt actor is starred in (114), while the inverse (113) with an overt 'someone' is fine SOURCED. Wolvengrey's conclusion is that the X→3 form is "formally identical" to a direct (p. 165) but is intransitive: his analysis is "a bit of a cross-breed" between the traditional true-actor analysis and a syntax in which "the third person is the sole participant allowed" (p. 166), and the form is "equivalent to a VAI form" (p. 167) SOURCED (his analysis). He adds that the independent form is homophonous with VAI forms, and that this homophony gave rise to a new VAI stem, ayamihā- 'pray' ((115), p. 167). So the answer is: direct in form only (XT-8).
6. Oxford's probe applied to X→3
Oxford's paper derives only 3→SAP forms. The extension below is ours HYPOTHESIS. In his model the inverse pattern is the case where "Infl agrees only with the patient's features on Voice" (p. 25). When that happens, Infl and Voice carry identical features, Voice's copy is deleted, and "featureless Voice is realized as the elsewhere form -iko" (p. 15) SOURCED. Plains Cree is C5: Infl [int: PERS, sat: PART,PL] (p. 26) SOURCED. Suppose X→3 were transitive, with X in Spec,VoiceP. Infl could not interact with X, which lacks [PERS] (AX-1), so it would copy only the 3AN patient's features from Voice. The identity condition would then hold, and the model predicts -iko. The language has -ā (independent) and -iht (conjunct) instead (XT-9). There are two ways out, and the sources opened do not choose between them OPEN:
- (i) No X argument. Wolvengrey's analysis: Voice has no external argument. It still agrees with the patient (-ā = 3AN object, which is Rhodes's reading of -aa cited in the Routledge chapter fn. 4). Infl then has a single goal, and Oxford's inverse is defined only for a transitive Voice. Nothing is mispredicted.
- (ii) A different probe in 3-patient forms. Oxford derives the third-person inverse with a distinct head, VoiceERG (ergative alignment, an [EPP] that attracts the patient; pp. 9–10). If X gets no such case, X→3 might never enter that system at all. This would need Oxford's own treatment of X→3, which has not been found.
Either way, the X>3 rank does no work. Wolvengrey reports that the extended hierarchy (111)/(18) was "suggested" to analysts by the very split under discussion, local -ikawi ≈ inverse versus third-person -ā ≈ direct (p. 163) SOURCED. So the rank restates the morphology and is not separate evidence that X has more features than a 3. That removes the tension in AX-12 (XT-10) HYPOTHESIS.
7. What this does to EI-8 (T70e)
ergative-indefinite §7 warned: if Algonquian X>3 is direct, then by analogy Navajo INDF>3 (biʼdistał) should not be an inverse, against EI-8. The warning assumed a transitive direct. Plains Cree X→3 is not one (XT-8), so the analogy no longer goes through HYPOTHESIS. The closer transitive analogue is (113). There an overt indefinite 'someone', inflected obviative, acts on a proximate 'John', and the verb is inverse SOURCED. In Willie's account biʼdistał is an inverse-type form with an indefinite agent and a 3rd-person patient that becomes the "subject of agentive passive" (p. 152). The two look alike: an indefinite agent ranked below a 3rd-person patient, with inverse morphology HYPOTHESIS. They also differ. Plains Cree (113) is still transitive (it allows the overt agent), while third-voice VC-14 made the Navajo agentive passive intransitive (EI-8′). The Plains Cree X form (114) is the intransitive one, and it is direct-looking. So Algonquian splits the two properties that EI-8′ puts together, inverse marking and intransitivity, across two constructions. The analogy is consistent with EI-8′ but cannot confirm it OPEN. T70e is answered in the sense that the Algonquian fact is now known (XT-8). What it means for Navajo stays a HYPOTHESIS (XT-11).
8. No doubling, and a control test (T78c, T78d)
Doubling. X can never be doubled by a nominal, not even by the indefinite pronoun awiyak/awiya 'someone' ((106), (114)) SOURCED. The pronoun is a full 3rd person: it is glossed PR.3s or PR.3’ (obviative), and it takes the ordinary inverse ((105), (113)). So Plains Cree has two 'someones'. One is lexical, carries person and obviation, and lives in clause syntax. The other is X: personless, unindexed, and never a noun. That fits AX-7 (X "do[es] not participate in or trigger obviation", Oxford 2018 fn. 13) and PX-11 for Navajo (a noun links only to a slot with a person value) HYPOTHESIS (the parallel). The Navajo half of T78c, whether INDF also stays out of the 3rd/4th-person system, needs Willie ch. 9 and stays OPEN (T79b).
Control. Wolvengrey's kakwē- 'try' data give a test that tells a present but unindexed agent apart from no agent at all. In (26)–(28) the unspecified actor is the one who tries ('someone's always trying to see me'). In (23)–(25) the patient is ('try to be seen!'). (29) is ambiguous SOURCED. If X were simply absent, the (26)–(28) readings should be impossible. Wolvengrey takes the choice to be pragmatic, not grammatical (p. 190) SOURCED (his analysis). For Navajo, T78d can now be stated as a schema with no Navajo forms: [V TRY [V INDF-V]]. Can the unexpressed INDF agent be the one who tries? No sourced Navajo INDF form under a 'try'-type predicate has been opened. The Navajo half of T78d is OPEN (T79c).
9. Rulesets A and B
| Step | Plains Cree X→3 (Wolvengrey) | Plains Cree overt 'someone' (113) | Navajo INDF (Willie, via earlier pages) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the agent is decided | in the word: the X form makes the actor unspecified and unindexed (Wolvengrey says -ikawi "essentially mirrors" -ikātē, which derives stems, and weighs treating it "as stem derivation", p. 165) A | in the clause: awiya Merges as an argument noun B | in the word: ʼadi- in the prefix array A |
| What clause syntax receives | a one-participant verb; no actor noun can Merge B (XT-4) | a two-participant verb; obviation and topicality pick the inverse B | a verb whose agent slot has no π; no noun links to it (PX-11) B |
| Agree | Voice ↔ 3AN patient (-ā); Infl has only the patient as a goal | Infl ↔ patient only → inverse -ikw (Oxford's pattern) | object slot ← patient's π; agent slot gets no π A |
| Spell-out | wāpam-ā-w, ē-wāpam-iht (suffixes) | kī-wāpam-ikw-Ø | prefix array, e.g. ni-ʼadi-l-zheeh A |
This is the site's Focus 1 point in a second language: the word is where "an agent without a noun" is decided, and the clause only sees the result. A clause-level indefinite (the noun awiya) behaves like any 3rd person. A word-level one (X, INDF) is invisible to clause-level linking HYPOTHESIS. Algonquian exponents are suffixes, so A = "prefixal, left-headed" is a Navajo label. In the Cree columns A only marks "inside the word".
10. Derivations
D1 (112c) wāpamāw '(someone) sees him/her', reading (i): no X argument (Wolvengrey)
1 Merge [VP see 3AN] B (clause syntax)
2 Merge Voice, no specifier (X form: actor unspecified) A decision (word level), XT-7
3 Agree Voice ↔ 3AN patient → -ā Rhodes's 3AN-object reading of -ā
4 Merge Infl; its only goal is the patient B
(no second goal, so no "agrees only with the patient"
contrast and no impoverishment)
5 Spell Ø- + wāpam + -ā + -w word: suffixes
6 Output wāpamāw matches (112c)
An overt actor at step 2 would need a specifier the
X form does not have → *(114) with awiya matches XT-4
D2 The same form, reading (ii'): X in Spec,VoiceP with Oxford's C5 Infl (our test)
1 Merge [VP see 3AN] B
2 Merge Voice; Agree Voice ↔ 3AN B
3 Merge X [ϕ, AN] in Spec,VoiceP B
4 Agree Infl [int: PERS]: X lacks PERS → no interaction AX-1, AX-5
Infl copies the patient's [ϕ, AN, PERS] from Voice
5 Rule Infl = Voice → delete Voice's copy Oxford p. 15
6 Spell featureless Voice → elsewhere -iko predicted: an -iko form (not attested)
7 Output does NOT match (112c) -ā or Table 2.66 -iht XT-9: the model as extended mispredicts.
(The shape of the predicted form is schematic; no such form is in the sources.)
D3 (113) awiya kī-wāpamik cān 'Someone saw John.'
1 Merge [VP see cān(3, PROX)] B
2 Merge Voice; Merge awiya(3’, OBV) in Spec,VoiceP B; a full 3rd person noun
3 Rank PROX patient outranks OBV agent → inverse B (obviation; Oxford's VoiceERG, pp. 9–10)
4 Agree Infl ↔ patient only B
5 Spell kī- + wāpam + -ikw + -Ø (3s) word
6 Output kī-wāpamik cān matches (113)
D4 Navajo (6) bi'distał=yę́ę 'the one who was kicked' (Willie p. 152 (1f)), set beside D1 and D3
1 Merge [VP 3rd patient kick] B; head-right VP
2 Merge [vP INDF[hum, −def, no π] [VP …] v] A decision (prefix 'adi-), VPISH
3 Agree object slot ← 3rd patient (bi-); INDF gets no π A
4 Rank EI-8′ (Willie): inverse-type bi-, patient = "subject of agentive passive"
HYPOTHESIS (as on ergative-indefinite)
5 Spell bi- + 'a(di)- + d- + stem, =yę́ę A, then enclitic
Like D1 in step 2 (an agent decided in the word, with no noun).
Like D3 in step 4 (inverse-type marking with a 3rd-person patient on top).
Plains Cree keeps these two apart (D1 ≠ D3); Navajo, under EI-8′, has both
in one form. HYPOTHESIS. No new Navajo data.
D1 and D3 put Wolvengrey's forms into the site's step format. The step labels are ours. D2 applies Oxford's C5 settings to a configuration his paper does not treat. D4 repeats ergative-indefinite D1 in outline. Merge builds each layer. Agree copies person values. The question in every case is which head gets features from which goal.
11. The role schema (Focus 2)
X is the clearest case so far of a theta role that is present without any argument item. Wolvengrey says the construction "does not remove the semantic argument from the understanding of the state of affairs, but it does render it obligatorily unspecified and unindexed on the verb" (p. 158) SOURCED. The control data show that this role can still be active: it can be the one who tries (XT-6) SOURCED. In site terms, Σ contains a proto-agent, while the syntax and agreement contain nothing for it. So the role schema and the argument list come apart HYPOTHESIS. On its face this is the closest thing yet to Grant's original picture, a verb that takes a role rather than a lexical item. But it is a special construction marked in the word (X, like INDF), and Wolvengrey argues the control is pragmatic, not syntactic. So it shows that roles can exist without items. It does not show that ordinary verbs select roles instead of items. The weak thesis gains a second, cleaner case. The strong thesis stays OPEN. Grant's revised view (the claim "does not hold cleanly") stays GRANT'S CONJECTURE.
One more point. The overt 'someone' awiya has the same role as X in (113) vs (114): proto-agent of 'see'. The grammar still treats the two completely differently (inverse and transitive vs direct-looking and intransitive). As on impersonal-x §10, what the agreement reads is the item's features (person, obviation), not the role SOURCED (the contrast) HYPOTHESIS (the reading).
12. Fidelity notes
All Plains Cree forms were copied from the text layer of Wolvengrey's born-digital PDF and checked against page images of PDF pp. 181, 186, 187 and 188 (printed pp. 159, 164, 165 and 166). The macrons (ā, ē, ī) and the ý in -ýiwa are as printed. On p. 190 Wolvengrey writes "(as in (36)-(38))" for the actor-control examples. In context these are (26)–(28), and they are cited that way here. Wolvengrey's own gloss labels (VTA, IPV, PR, NA) are kept in the source lines. No Navajo form, segmentation or judgment on this page is new. The Navajo forms are copied from earlier pages that transcribed them from Willie's page images.
13. Open questions
| ID | Question | What would settle it |
|---|---|---|
| T79a | Does Oxford (or anyone using his probe model) treat X→3? Does reading (i) (no X argument) or (ii) (no VoiceERG for X) rescue the model (XT-9)? Is independent X→3 in Ojibwe (the Routledge chapter's other main template source, Nichols 1980) also built on -aa? | Oxford 2017/2019 on impoverishment; Nichols 1980; Valentine 2001. OPEN |
| T79b | (= T78c, Navajo half) Does Navajo INDF ʼadi- stay outside the 3rd/4th-person system, as X stays out of obviation and only the overt 'someone' enters it (XT-12)? | Willie ch. 9 on images. OPEN |
| T79c | (= T78d, Navajo half) Is there a sourced Navajo INDF form under a 'try'-type or other control predicate, and can the unexpressed agent be the one who tries (XT-13)? | Young & Morgan 1987; Willie pp. 36–38 and ch. 6 on images. OPEN |
| T79d | Is the conjunct X→3 -iht segmentable? Does it contain a cognate of Kickapoo/PA -en IMP (Oxford Tables 3–4), which would make the conjunct X a real morpheme in the word and not just a missing actor? | Wolfart 1973; Dahlstrom 1991; Goddard 1979. OPEN |
T78a answered: direct in form only (XT-8; forms SOURCED, the summary ours). AX-12 is dissolved as HYPOTHESIS (XT-10). T70e: the Algonquian fact is now known, and the analogy against EI-8 loses its basis (XT-11, HYPOTHESIS). The Algonquian halves of T78c and T78d are answered (XT-12, XT-13). Their Navajo halves continue as T79b and T79c. Still open: T78b, T76b, T76c, T77a–d, T75b, T75c, T73b–e, T74a–c, T74e. Sources: Wolvengrey 2011 pp. 158–167, 185–192; Oxford 2022 pp. 9–10, 15, 24–26. See also impersonal-x, ergative-indefinite, third-voice, passive-rank, The inverse.
