Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.
SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading
Working notes
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. Page titles only: Navajo glottal stops in titles now print as ʼ (U+02BC), and titles that called a structure a “VPISH spine” now say vP/TP (VPISH is a hypothesis, never a node). No claim changed.
Every page written run by run since 2026-10-06, kept at its original URL with its data, rule IDs and status labels unchanged. Each topic has a consolidated essay; start there, then come here for the full derivations.
His under bi-: Who can "his" point back to under bi-? A possessor test for the deep inverse (T53a)
Where the owner's name sits: Where the owner's name sits: Aissen 1997 read first-hand, and a Navajo sentence the ranking rule gets wrong (T57d, T57a)
One his, two 3rd persons: One "his", two third persons: Horseherder 1998 on the owner prefix yi-, and a plural doer that breaks it (T58f, T58a)
What comes first decides: What comes first decides: Platero 1978 on who "his" can mean, and a no-movement route to W&J (70b) (T59a)
Two ways object-first: Two ways to put the object first: Saxon 2001 on bi- inversion vs Focus Movement, and whether the fronted patient sits in an A-position (T60c)
Possessor raising: Whose neck? Possessor raising: the noun goes into the verb, the person becomes the object
Rule set A vs B: Headedness on the spine: which heads are final, and what else moves to give verb-final order
A/B as spell-out: Rule sets A and B as spell-out statements: one ordering rule, two cycles? Hale 2003's hierarchy against an antisymmetric alternative (T27j)
Clause spine: Where the verb word, the nouns, the =go clause and topic/focus sit: a vP/TP spine for Willie & Jelinek's S-trees, and parallel processing split into grammar and parsing (T27l)
Yes/no -ísh & word edge: Where the yes/no enclitic -ísh can go, and what it shows about where the Navajo word ends (T41f)
=sh vs -ísh: Two question endings compared: content-question =sh and yes/no -ísh. First word or first phrase, and what the inverse forbids (T43f)
Reflexive vs reciprocal: Why the reflexive comes before plural da- and the reciprocal after it: a two-piece reflexive and a one-piece reciprocal (T35b)
Subject on the head: Why ordinary subject prefixes sit on the tense-aspect head and the fourth-person, indefinite and areal subjects do not: one feature bundle, two places to pronounce it (T35c, T36g)
Subject d: hypotheses: Where might subject d sit? Template-based alternatives and the unresolved movement test (2026-11-11 audit pass 1)
Two deictic d's in one word: Two deictic d's in one word: with a 3i object and a 4th-person subject, Young & Morgan's p. 123 table puts the object first ('aji-), as option (c) predicts; the one reversed cell (dazh'doo-) follows a sound rule, since no glottal stop stands right before zh in 387 tables (T93c in part)
The space d ho-: The space d ho-: the 3s/3a object prefix comes before the 4th-person subject in 150 of 150 table cells (hoji-, hozhdoo-), and Young & Morgan say hashbį' 'build a hogan' cannot take a noun object, a ban that belongs to the verb root (T95b in part; T85a, T85b)
zh after thematic di in hodii- futures: Where 4th-person zh sits relative to thematic di: in six hodii- future cells it follows di, so subject d above every Qualifier needs a finer spell-out rule (T96d in part)
Distributive future missing di: Distributive future and the missing di: p. 454 dahozhdiyoo- keeps zh before diyoo because that cell has only one di-piece, while singular hodizhdiyoo- has two (T97a, T97c)
Future Qualifier d in doo: Hale’s future Qualifier d is the onset of doo: pp. 72 and 541 flip between thematic di and doo though 3rd shows one visible di (T98b)
Voice allomorphy: Voice and perfective allomorphy: an in-place hypothesis, not a proof against movement (2026-11-11 audit pass 1)
Attached vs separate P: Attached or separate? Procliticized vs detached postpositions, where the word ends, and which verb + postposition pairs are idioms (T43e)
-ił travel pattern: ‘With me it went’: is the -ił “transportation” pattern a productive pattern or an idiom, and who is the subject when you travel? (T45f)
Noun between P and verb: Can a noun stand between a postposition and its verb? bee dibé síníloh, Willie's uninterruptible verb complex, and where a postpositional phrase is merged (T49)
Postpositions by verb: Willie's grammatical postpositions checked verb by verb: which postpositional phrases belong to the verb complex (the voice decides, not the verb alone), and the spell-out rule rewritten with the word as its first domain (T49f, T49h)
Instrument and voice: Does the yi-/bi- voice reach the instrument? Every third-person sentence in four NLA postposition lists: -ł alternates yił/bił, the instrument is only bee, and the postposition of a verb + P unit stands next to the verb (T50a, T49b–d)
Postposition units: What is a Navajo postposition (P, functional, T, C?), and are verb + postposition units phrasal verbs? Sources, derivations, phrase-level lexicalization (T32)
One-place verb + P: Can a one-participant verb have a grammatical postposition and an inverse? Willie 1991 p. 97 vs p. 94, five licensing conditions tested, phrase-level lexicalization (T32e)
P objects never silent: Postpositions never go silent: 'him/her/it' on a postposition under 'I' and 'you' (T65e)
Causee bi- under 'I': Why 'I make the baby laugh' keeps bi-: the causee's prefix belongs to the postposition (T64f)
Merge/Agree in the word: Merge and Agree inside the Navajo verb word: Merge sites, Agree sites, phases, and whether anything is [+MFS]-like (T40)
Merge/Agree: originals: The borrowed terms checked against their originals: what Rudin 1988, Hiraiwa 2001 and Chomsky 2008 actually define, and what that changes inside the Navajo verb word (T40b)
Merge/Agree: 2000/2001: The older definitions behind “edge feature”: what Chomsky 2000 and 2001 say about the EPP-feature, Match/Agree, activity and phases, and what that changes inside the Navajo verb word (T41e)
The ‘start to’ test: Who stays the subject when you add ‘start to’? The Navajo inchoative as a test of where a one-participant verb's participant starts out (T37b)
‘Start to’: HMP ms.: ‘Start to’ in Hale, Munro & Platero's own words: the participant's prefix goes first, the ’ is an object, and verbs with nobody low get a placeholder (T38a, T38b, T38d–g)
Plain ł-causer: Which intransitive verbs take a plain ł-causer?
Distance as measure: ‘We ran about two miles’: is the distance the incremental theme? Distance phrases in Navajo motion sentences, the vehicle, and the ‘but didn't get there’ test (T47)
Pleonastic ho- & psych: Who likes it? Pleonastic ho-, psych verbs, and the experiencer inside a postposition
Fourth person: Fourth person: escape from the animacy scale
4th person compared: Three things called fourth person: Navajo, Algonquian, Inuit
4th across clauses: Two clauses, one cast: =go chains and the fourth person
4th in speech & focus: Same person or someone else? The fourth person in reported speech and person focus
4th in relatives: The one who: relative clauses, nominalized clauses and the fourth person
4th: five uses: One fourth person, five uses: respect, reportative, story, impersonal, wish
Relative as CP: The relative clause as a clause under a ‘the one’ head: raised or matched? Platero 1973's island and enclitic-phrase data (T27m)
Hale & Platero 1974: Hale & Platero 1974: relatives, missing nouns, and the yi-/bi- parser
External-patient relative head: An inverse relative headed by its external patient: Willie's absolutive rule (16) covers only relatives without nouns (T71b; T71e in part)
Person picks the relative head: With a first, second or fourth person in the relative, the head is the third-person argument whatever its role; the noun-count grid holds only for two third persons (T72d)
External agent in the relative: A Navajo relative is an independent clause plus an enclitic, so the third-person agent of 'the one who kissed me' stays external; restrictiveness cannot tell, and Willie's commas are no test (T73a, T72a partly).
Newest (not yet filed)
4th doer, P object: When 'that person' (ji-) is the doer: the verb's object goes silent and a postposition's object takes bi- (T67b)
'Someone' as doer: bi-: When 'someone' is the doer the object is bi-, when 'that person' is the doer it is silent: the agentive passive splits Hale's deictic subjects (T68b)
Two "ergatives" for 'someone': Two "ergatives" for the 'someone' doer: Willie vs Hale, the animacy ranking, Algonquian X (T69e, T69c, T69g)
A third voice: the passive: A third voice: with a 1st/2nd-person patient the agentive passive is neither Direct nor Inverse, and its patient is an absolutive subject (T70b, T70c)
'Someone' is ranked as human: 'Someone' has no person but is still human: the animacy ranking reads [human], not person, and Willie's "PASS 3.3" is a paradigm label (T74d).
Indefinites have no person: Three indefinites outside the person paradigms: 'someone', 'something' and the areal ho- carry a sort feature but no person, and none of them takes a noun (T75a, T75d).
'Something' is absolutive: 'Something' is the indefinite absolutive: in every example Willie gives, 'a- stands for the inanimate thing affected, so the "animate subject" clause on p. 38 has no example behind it (T76a).
Algonquian X has no person: Algonquian's impersonal actor X has its own paradigm cells but no [PERS] feature, like Navajo 'adi-; but where Algonquian also denies person to inanimates, Navajo gives 'it' a person (T76d)
X on a third person: Plains Cree's impersonal actor X acting on a third person looks direct but cannot take an actor at all, so X>3 is not a transitive direct, and the Algonquian argument against EI-8 loses its basis (T78a, T70e)
3i subject 'a-: Young & Morgan's 3i subject 'a- is 'someone' as often as 'something': people go, work and dream with it, so the indefinite 'a- is not only an inanimate patient (T77a, T77c, T77b, T33e)
3i with a noun (gas movers): Smoke, cloud and rain take the 3i prefix with their nouns: in the *Øjooł family the verb picks 'a- or Ø by what kind of stuff moves, so PX-11 fails for one verb class (T80a)
3i for the sun, light, snow, lightning: The sun, sunlight, melting snow and lightning also take the 3i prefix, but without a noun: 3i-CL is not a gas class (T81b)
Rain, water, fire subjects: Rain, water and fire: the rainstorm takes the areal ho-, fire and flowing water take a plain third person, and the 3i appears only in drizzle and water-blister verbs, so the verb base picks the subject prefix (T82c)
Hanging smoke: 3i or Ø by stem: Hanging smoke, dust, cloud and fog: the same thing in the same role takes the 3i with two stems and a plain third person with three others, so the verb base, not the role and not the item, lists the subject prefix (T83c)
Listed 3i: in the base, not the person cell: Where Young & Morgan put the indefinite 'a-: in the listed prefix string of the base, not in the subject's person cell, at least for the 'e'e- verbs and the gas/wool pair on *Øjooł (T85e)
Two tables: 3i cell or listed 'a-: Two tables for one string: the 'e'e- verbs of gas and unnamed vehicles fit Y&M's 'away' table as 3i person forms as well as the 'e'e- table, so the listed-prefix argument is withdrawn; a named vehicle takes the plain third person, an unnamed one the 3i with no noun (T87b)
Named or unnamed vehicle: Named or unnamed: Y&M pair the 3i 'a- with an 'unspecified' vehicle and the plain verb with a 'named' one; the vehicle noun never fills the 3i's slot and appears only in a bee 'by means of it' phrase after the verb (T88c)
Driver verbs and the 3i: Driver verbs: the 3i 'a- is the vehicle in the object slot, and 49/15's car belongs to another clause (T89d)
Position labels and the 3i: Position labels: Y&M's Pos. IV on 'ahéé'a- belongs to the prefix entry, not the verb, so it does not show the passenger 3i is an object (T90b)
Verb as derivation: The spine: how every Navajo clause is built (Merge, theta roles, V→v→T, and what else moves)
Results on the spine: Results on the spine: first-principles reviews 1–13 restated as derivations on one clause structure
One structure for Navajo: One structure for Navajo: the clause, the noun phrase and the verb word on a single spine, with every phenomenon placed on it