Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.

SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading

The older definitions behind “edge feature”: what Chomsky 2000 and 2001 say about the EPP-feature, Match/Agree, activity and phases, and what that changes inside the Navajo verb word (T41e)

Working note. Kept as written (URL, data and status labels unchanged). Filed under Merge and Agree inside the word; the consolidated argument is the essay merge-agree. Rule IDs: rules index.

Verbs on this page → dictionary: yishxash ‘bite’ · yíghááh ‘join; with -tah ‘among’: go among’

Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). The framework is restated in §1: VPISH (arguments merged in the verb’s scope, subject in Spec,vP) with theta roles, and V→v→T with the subject raised to Spec,TP as the working default in tensed clauses; each pattern is what else moves, with an LF whose scope matches c-command. The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Position-class template statements below describe the order of prefixes; they are not the derivation (§3). Derivations below in which the verb or subject does not raise are labelled contrast; the working default raises V→v→T and the subject to Spec,TP. Status on the spine: see unified structure, §1. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.

2026-11-11 audit pass 1. MI/DbP conditions are source-theory claims, not premises of the current VPISH-plus-theta regime. The old expletive/phase and TP rules are conditional hypotheses; a word’s exponent order does not identify T or a phase boundary. Compare the primary V→v→T and separate subject raising with template/PF rivals. Full target-before-Move and LF re-derivations of the retained lists remain OPEN.

2026-11-11 audit pass 3. Local box file paths were removed from this page; files inside the repository are given by repo-relative path, and the source citation next to each removed path stays as the reference. See the pass 3 report.

2026-11-13 audit pass 7. An earlier dated note on this page treats V→v→T and subject raising as Grant’s conjecture or a comparator to test against PF/template rivals. Since 2026-11-13 they are the working default in tensed clauses: VPISH frames where the arguments start so that syntax and semantics line up; it is not a word-order account. PF/template accounts are kept only as labelled contrast, and the open question is what else has to move. The earlier note is kept as written. See the 2026-11-13 note and the pass 7 report.

Last night's page, the borrowed terms checked against their originals, opened Rudin 1988, Hiraiwa 2001 and Chomsky 2008. Two older works were still unopened: Chomsky 2000 (“Minimalist Inquiries”, MI) and Chomsky 2001 (“Derivation by Phase”, DbP). The wording in Grant's typology note comes from them (“whether a given head has an Edge Feature triggering Spec Merge”), and so do Hiraiwa's definitions of Match and Agree. This page opens both, sets their definitions beside the ones the site has been using, tightens the rules, and re-runs the derivations that change. The two operations stay apart throughout. Merge builds structure: it puts an element at a position, either a fresh element (“pure Merge” in MI's term, External Merge in 2008's) or a copy of one already in the structure (Move; Internal Merge). Agree values features such as person and number: a probe on a head finds the closest matching goal and copies its value, and nothing moves. MI's Move is the two together plus “pied-piping” (p. 101). Written 2026-10-20, 4:46am PT.

Ground rules (Grant's). No new Navajo form is introduced. Every form below is already on this site, from a named source with its example number, and the page links to where it was read. None is segmented beyond what its source prints. MI and DbP are general-syntax works, and neither mentions Navajo. Every mapping of a Navajo fact onto their terms is therefore ours, graded HYPOTHESIS at most. What the originals say is graded SOURCED, with the printed page number. Only contradicting data count against an analysis; a source's silence does not. No earlier analysis (Hale, Willie, HMP, Hiraiwa, Chomsky, or this site's own rules) is assumed to be fully right.

Notation (the site's own, as on the originals page). Σ = role-schema step (which slots the verb has and their roles in the action); A = word level (cycle D1, rule set A: the prefixal, left-headed functional spine); B = clause level (cycle D2, rule set B: right-headed clause syntax and noun linking). Spine (Hale 2003): Qual > M/S > v > V. Slots ρ = ⟨E, pos, φ, (δ)⟩ (SH-0): φ is person/number, δ the deictic value (fourth person, indefinite, areal). INCH = the ‘start to’ prefix ʼnii-; PINCH = its postposition-like requirement (IN-8); ρI = INCH's own ’ in the object position; ρC = the slot that satisfies PINCH; ρD = the role-less placeholder ’. New abbreviations from the originals: EPP-feature = a head's requirement that its specifier be filled (MI p. 102); Expl = expletive; MoM = “Merge over Move”: simpler operations preempt Move (MI pp. 101–104); PIC1 = MI's phase-impenetrability condition (21); PIC2 = DbP's revised version (11); activity = a goal can take part in Agree only while it still has an unvalued feature of its own (DbP (3a)).

Bottom line, in plain words

SOURCED Grant's wording is the 2000/2001 idea, faithfully stated. In MI and DbP, having an “EPP-feature” is something a head may or may not have. T's “might be universal”; for the phase heads v and C it “varies parametrically among languages and if available is optional” (MI p. 109). DbP p. 41: “Something distinguishes among heads H that require, allow, or disallow that H head an occurrence of K.” That is exactly the question in Grant's note. The 8:46pm page's verdict, “pre-2008 wording”, is now confirmed with page numbers. Only the name “Edge Feature” is 2008's. In 2008 every lexical item has one.

HYPOTHESIS The main change concerns the ‘start to’ placeholder. It must belong to a low, non-phase head, not to the top of the word. Both MI and DbP allow an expletive to be inserted only into the extra position of a head like T. A phase head (C, or a transitive v) may fill its extra position only by moving something up from inside its own phase: “If H is v/C, XP is not introduced by pure Merge” (MI (5a), p. 102); “pure Merge from outside Ph is barred” (p. 109). Last night's rule MA-2′(c) put the placeholder in the qualifier layer, which the site treats as the word's phase head, and said “no inheritance is needed”. Under both definitions that is exactly the excluded case. Hale, Munro & Platero print placeholder forms (‘the baby starts to cry’, ‘it started to snow’), so the data stand and the rule has to move. It moves back to where the site's own IN-8 first put it: to PINCH, the postposition-like piece at the top of the verb phrase. Two more facts fit a T-like head there. INCH's requirement is obligatory (HMP: it “must always be preceded by overt object agreement morphology”), as T's EPP may be, while a phase head's is optional. And the position it opens carries no role, which MI (6) requires for an expletive.

HYPOTHESIS Two of IN-9's stipulations now follow. First, why does the placeholder appear only when nothing below v can fill the slot? MI's “Merge preempts Move” would insert the placeholder whenever it is available. But in a verb with a low participant, that participant would then have nowhere to be pronounced, because INCH's own ’ already holds the object position. So only the bumping derivation survives (EP-3). Second, why is the subject of ‘cry’ never used to fill the slot? PINCH sits below v, and movement only goes up, so a participant that starts in Spec,v is out of its reach.

HYPOTHESIS The default third person in ‘I start to get cold’ now matches MI's own Icelandic case, with one cost. In MI, if the closest goal for T has already been agreed with and is “inactive”, it still blocks T from looking further, and T shows a default (“[3person] (the default choice)”, p. 128; “if such an associate is lacking, T is default”, p. 126). In shináʼniidlóóh, PINCH has already agreed with ‘I’, so Mode/Subject finds an inactive goal and shows the default. The cost: in MI and DbP, what keeps a goal active is structural Case (DbP p. 6: a noun “is active only when it has structural Case”). The site's slots have no Case. Using this mechanism means adding an abstract activating feature to every slot. The rival, “the postposition phrase is a phase”, is still our own extension, so the two remain OPEN (T41c).

HYPOTHESIS Phases: one reason changes, no string changes. In MI the object inside a transitive verb phrase is sealed off as soon as the phrase is complete. In DbP a T-like head can still reach it until the next C-like head arrives: “T in the domain of Z can agree with an element within its complement” (p. 14). On DbP's version, Mode/Subject never shows the object's person because the subject is closer, not because of a wall. Every form on the site comes out the same either way (T42a).

HYPOTHESIS Hiraiwa's citations check out, with two refinements. His Match (2) is MI (40), p. 122, word for word. But Chomsky himself narrows “feature identity” to “identity of the choice of feature, not of value” (MI p. 124), and DbP to “Non-distinctness: same feature, independently of value” (p. 5). MI p. 124 also says a head's person-and-number set is valued “as a unit”, and that “The φ-features of T do not agree with different NPs”. That strengthens last night's MA-6′ (the object prefix is not one probe agreeing with two goals). It also adds a commitment to MA-3a: the deictic δ must be a feature separate from person, as the site's slot notation already writes it.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's frame. MI p. 127 separates the two systems in so many words. Roles come from “pure Merge of XP to substantive LIs”, and agreement (“checking theory”) is a different system with different properties. On this page every position that ‘start to’ adds carries no role, and every participant keeps the role it got where it first merged. That fits STRATA's order (roles first, the event layer next, nouns last), and theta roles and event-structure roles stay compatible. It does not separate STRATA from its rivals.

On this page: 1 Sources · 2 Definitions side by side · 3 Hiraiwa's citations checked · 4 Rules EP-0 to EP-8 · 5 What changes, rule by rule · 6 Derivations EP1–EP8 · 7 Gets right / misses · 8 Grant's frame · 9 Tasks T42a–h and T41 statuses

1. Sources

SourceAccess this runUsed for
Chomsky, Noam. 2000. Minimalist inquiries: the framework. In R. Martin, D. Michaels & J. Uriagereka (eds.), Step by Step: Essays on Minimalist Syntax in Honor of Howard Lasnik, 89–155. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press (= MI)Opened: 71-page scan of an e-book printout of pp. 89–155 (document-delivery copy in a University of Arizona course folder). The scan has no text layer, so it was OCR'd on the box (tesseract 5.5). Page numbers come from the printed “Page N” headers. Printed p. 94 is missing from the scan. The quotations for pp. 102, 103 and 109 were checked against the page images; the rest are from the OCR, which is clean on these pages. Notes are not usedMerge, Agree, Move and the preference order (pp. 101–102); EPP-features (p. 102); (4)–(6), properties of CFCs (pp. 102–103); Merge over Move and subarrays (pp. 104, 106); phases (pp. 106–108); (17) inert phase head; PIC (21) (p. 108); (24) phase-head EPP, optional (p. 109); probe/goal, (40) Match, (41) equidistance (p. 122); activity, (42) defective intervention (p. 123); “one fell swoop” φ-deletion and value-free identity (p. 124); Expl = [person] only (p. 125); (45) EPP satisfaction and default T (p. 126); θ-theory vs checking theory (p. 127); Icelandic default [3person] (p. 128); (50) (pp. 129–130)
Chomsky, Noam. 2001. Derivation by phase. In M. Kenstowicz (ed.), Ken Hale: A Life in Language, 1–52. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press (= DbP)Opened: 28-page scan, two book pages per sheet, pp. 1–52 including notes (Georgetown faculty page). No text layer, so OCR'd on the box. Page numbers from the printed running heads; the quotation on p. 14 was checked against the page image(2) three kinds of uninterpretable feature (p. 4); Match = identity, then non-distinctness (pp. 4–5); (3a) activity, (3b) φ-completeness, Case as the activating feature (pp. 5–6); Tdef, Expl = [person] (p. 7); (5)–(6), EPP and φ-completeness (pp. 8–9); EPP-feature defined, Move preempted (p. 10); strong vs weak phases (p. 12); PIC (7)–(11) (pp. 13–14); T can probe into the v*P complement (p. 14); (14) Maximize matching effects (p. 15); (43)–(46) equidistance and the phonological edge (pp. 27–28); (60)–(61) optional EPP on v* (p. 35); EPP as the property of heading an occurrence (pp. 40–41); n. 8 v* (p. 43)
Hiraiwa, Ken. 2001. Multiple Agree and the Defective Intervention Constraint in Japanese. MITWPL 40: 67–80Re-opened (the extraction from 2026-10-19, 8:46pm)His citations of Chomsky 2000/2001, (1)–(5), checked in §3
Chomsky, Noam. 2008. On phasesAs recorded on the originals page (not re-opened)pp. 139, 143, 144, 148, 155, 157, for comparison
Grant, “Typology of Merge/Agree Phenomena”As recorded on the originals page ([local working copy, not in the repository])The EPP/Edge Feature line compared in §2
This site's pagesRe-readHMP ms. (IN-5′, IN-7 (D), IN-8, IN-9; HD1–HD7); originals page (MA-0′–MA-6′; MA1′, MA4′, MA5′, MA7′, MA10′); Merge/Agree page
Not opened—Chomsky 2004 (“Beyond explanatory adequacy”), where the EPP-feature becomes the edge feature; Grewendorf 2001 (still paywalled, T41d); Young & Morgan. None is used as evidence

2. Definitions side by side

Left: what the site and Grant's note have been using. Middle: what MI and DbP say, with page. Right: what follows.

TermSite / Grant's note (with 2008 as recorded)MI 2000 and DbP 2001 SOURCEDVerdict and consequence
EPP-feature (later “edge feature”)Grant: “Whether a given head (T, v, C…) has an Edge Feature triggering Spec Merge.” 2008: every lexical item has EF (p. 139)MI p. 102: “Each CFC also allows an extra Spec beyond its s-selection: for C, a raised wh-phrase; for T, the surface subject; for v, the phrase raised by object shift (OS). For T, the property of allowing an extra Spec is the Extended Projection Principle (EPP). By analogy, we can call the corresponding properties of C and v EPP-features”. “EPP-features are uninterpretable (nonsemantic, hence the name)”. MI p. 109: “The EPP-feature of T might be universal. For the phase heads v/C, it varies parametrically among languages and if available is optional.” (24): “The head H of phase Ph may be assigned an EPP-feature.” DbP p. 10: “an uninterpretable selectional feature (by definition, an EPP-feature), which requires Merge in [Spec, LB(K)]”. DbP p. 41: “Something distinguishes among heads H that require, allow, or disallow that H head an occurrence of K.” DbP (61a), p. 35: “v* is assigned an EPP-feature only if that has an effect on outcome.”Grant's line is an accurate statement of the 2000/2001 notion, and the question “does this head have one?” only makes sense there. In 2008 the question becomes “can this head drive movement?” (phase heads, or by inheritance). For Navajo the useful 2000 distinction is obligatory (T-like) vs optional (phase heads)
Who may fill the extra position with an expletiveMA-2′(c): the placeholder ρD = “EM of an expletive that satisfies the EF of the Qual-layer INCH … Since Qual is D1's phase head …, this EF is the phase head's own: no inheritance.” 2008 p. 157: expletive EM satisfies “the inherited edge feature of T”MI (5a), p. 102: “If H is v/C, XP is not introduced by pure Merge.” p. 103: “Pure Merge is Merge that is not part of Move”; (6): “Pure Merge in θ-position is required of (and restricted to) arguments”, so pure Merge in [Spec, T] is restricted “to Expl”. p. 109: since the phase head is inert beyond its phase, “the EPP must be satisfied by raising within Ph: pure Merge from outside Ph is barred.” (45b), p. 126: “The EPP can be satisfied by i. Merge of expletive ii. Merge of associate iii. Merge of α closer to T than the associate”. DbP p. 7: “the EPP-feature of Tdef is satisfied by Merge of expletive” or “by raising”MA-2′(c) as written is excluded by both texts, and 2008's own case is T (non-phase, inherited) too. Since the placeholder forms are printed (HMP (7b), (16a)), the requirement must sit on a non-phase head. New EP-1, EP-2 (§4)
Merge over MoveNot used on the siteMI p. 101: Move is “more complex than its subcomponents Merge and Agree”; p. 102: “Merge or Agree (or their combination) preempts Move, which is a ‘last resort’”. p. 104: “Preference of Merge over Move selects the former”, and the choice “depends on whether or not an expletive is available in the initial lexical array”. p. 106: “If the subarray in active memory does not contain Expl, then Move can take place …; if it does, Merge of Expl preempts Move.” DbP p. 10: Move is “preempted where possible by the simpler operations Merge and Agree”Applied to INCH, this would insert the placeholder whenever it is available. Combined with “the object position is full” (HMP n. 2), it derives when the placeholder appears (EP-3)
MatchHiraiwa (2a): “Matching is feature identity” (cited to MI p. 122). MA-0′, MA-6′ use itMI (40), p. 122: “a. Matching is feature identity. b. D(P) is the sister of P. c. Locality reduces to ‘closest c-command.’” p. 124: “We therefore understand ‘feature identity’ in (40a) to be identity of the choice of feature, not of value.” DbP p. 5: “Accordingly, Match is not strictly speaking Identity, but Non-distinctness: same feature, independently of value.”Hiraiwa quotes (40) exactly. Chomsky's own refinement (same feature type, any value) changes no site verdict. The object prefix still reads two feature types (φ of the object, δ of the subject), so MA-6′ stands
Agree and the φ-set as a unitMA-3a: Qual passes [uφ] to M/S and keeps [uδ]. MA-6′: no probe-side agreement with two goals (Hiraiwa n. 12)MI p. 124: “We take deletion to be a ‘one fell swoop’ operation, dealing with the φ-set as a unit. Its features cannot selectively delete: either all delete, or none. The φ-features of T do not agree with different NPs”. MI p. 124 also: “verbs agree with nouns, not conversely”MA-6′ gains an earlier source than Hiraiwa n. 12. MA-3a survives only if δ is not part of the φ-set. The site's slot notation already separates them (ρ = ⟨E, pos, φ, δ⟩), but this is now a commitment, not a convenience (T42b)
Activity and defective interventionMA-5b: the object inside a PP is inactive after P's own Agree; Hiraiwa (3) DICMI p. 123: “uninterpretable features render the goal active … The operations Agree and Move require a goal that is both local and active.” (42): “α > β > γ … β and γ match the probe α, but β is inactive so that the effects of matching are blocked.” p. 127: after Case is deleted the phrase is still “‘visible’ to a probe, allowing defective intervention effects”. DbP (3a), p. 6: “Goal as well as probe must be active for Agree to apply.” “φ-features of N are interpretable; hence, N is active only when it has structural Case”; once valued it is “frozen in place”. DbP p. 27: “inactive nominals induce intervention effects”MA-5b now has its original mechanism. But in both texts the activating feature of a nominal goal is structural Case. Navajo slots carry none on this site, so MA-5b needs an added abstract feature (ours). A cost, not data (EP-5)
φ-completenessNot usedDbP (3b), p. 6: the probe “must have a complete set of φ-features (it must be φ-complete) to delete uninterpretable features of the paired matching element”. MI p. 124: “only a probe with a full complement of φ-features is capable of deleting the feature that activates the matched goal”For EP-5, PINCH's agreement must be φ-complete (person and number). Untested (T42f)
Default agreementIN-7 (D) (HMP: the position is empty “as it is regularly in persons other than first or second”); 2008 p. 157 “default morphology”; Hiraiwa pp. 78–79MI p. 126: with Merge of an α closer to T than the associate, if “such an associate is lacking, T is default.” p. 128: Icelandic remote nominative “allows number agreement but not first/second person agreement. That would follow if the [person] feature of T reduces to [3person] (the default choice) when it attracts quirky Case or Expl”The original of Hiraiwa's Icelandic default. The default is third person, which is what IN-7 (D) needs
ExpletiveρD = ⟨E none, φ 3, δ INDF⟩ (IN-9)MI p. 125: Expl's feature set “must be less than a full φ-set, hence optimally just [person]”. DbP p. 7: “pure expletives of the there-type should have no other formal features”. MI p. 128: “it-type Expl with a full complement of φ-features” also existsρD has δ = INDF beyond person, so it is not a pure there-type expletive. Whether it is it-type, or not an expletive at all, is OPEN (T42f)
PhasesMA-1′: CP and v*P (2008 p. 143); unaccusative v not phasalMI: “A phase is CP or vP, but not TP or a verbal phrase headed by H lacking φ-features and therefore not entering into Case/agreement checking: neither finite TP nor unaccusative/passive verbal phrase is a phase” (pp. 106–107). p. 108: “verbal phases being limited to transitive v with φ-features and EA”. DbP p. 12: “phases are CP and v*P”; “call the former strong phases and the latter weak. The strong phases are potential targets for movement: C and v* may have an EPP-feature”. n. 8, p. 43: “Call v with full argument structure v*: transitive v or experiencer.”The v/v* split the site took from 2008 is already in MI. Neither text says how to class an unergative. By MI's own criterion (φ-features and EA), a v with no object to agree with is not a phase (EP-8, T41h)
PICMA1′: “The v*P complement (VP) is behind the phase edge, so ρX is not a candidate” for M/SMI (21), p. 108: “In phase α with head H, the domain of H is not accessible to operations outside α, only H and its edge are accessible to such operations.” DbP (11), p. 14: “The domain of H is not accessible to operations at ZP; only H and its edge are accessible to such operations”, ZP the next strong phase. p. 14: “The probe T can access an element of the domain YP of HP: the PIC imposes no restriction on this. But with Σ = ZP (so that Z = C), the probe Z cannot access the domain YP.” “T in the domain of Z can agree with an element within its complement, for example, with the in-situ quirky nominative object of its v*P complement.”MA1′'s reason holds under PIC1 only. Under PIC2, M/S (T-like) can see ρX, and the closer ρA is what wins. Qual (C-like) cannot see it under either version, so MA10′ is unchanged (EP-6)
Equidistance / phonological edgeHiraiwa (4), (5)MI (41), p. 122: “Terms of the same minimal domain are ‘equidistant’ to probes.” DbP (43)–(44), p. 27: “(44) Terms of the edge of HP are equidistant from probe P”; (46), p. 28: “The phonological edge of HP is accessible to probe P”, with intervention evaluated at the next strong phaseNo site rule uses equidistance. Recorded for §3 only
Roles vs agreementSTRATA (Grant); 2008 p. 140 pairs EM with θ-structureMI p. 127: “θ-structure and similar semantic roles are based on pure Merge of XP to substantive LIs or their projections. Checking theory, in contrast, involves uninterpretable features of functional categories”; “The two theories differ in nature and implementation”. MI (6), p. 103 (above)Two separate systems already in 2000. Used in §8

3. Hiraiwa's citations checked

Hiraiwa 2001Cited asIn the originalVerdict
(1) AGREE: “uninterpretable features of α and β are checked/deleted”“cf. Chomsky 2000”MI p. 122: “The erasure of uninterpretable features of probe and goal is the operation we called Agree.” DbP p. 5 replaces erasure-only with valuation: unvalued features get values, then deleteA fair paraphrase of MI (marked “cf.”). DbP's valuation version is the one the site's rules assume (a probe copies a value)
(2) Match a–c“Chomsky 2000:122”MI (40), p. 122, identicalExact. Chomsky narrows (a) on p. 124 and in DbP p. 5 (§2)
(3) DIC: “β is inactive due to a prior Agree with some other probe”“cf. Chomsky 2000:123”MI (42), p. 123: “β is inactive so that the effects of matching are blocked”. Inactivity = the goal's Case already deleted (pp. 123, 127)“Due to a prior Agree” is Hiraiwa's gloss, and it is accurate for MI: Case is deleted under Agree
(4) “[Only (K.H.)] the phonological edge of HP is accessible to probe P”“Chomsky 2001”DbP (46), p. 28: “The phonological edge of HP is accessible to probe P.”Exact, and Hiraiwa marks his own addition “[Only (K.H.)]”
(5) Equidistance: “Terms of the edge of HP are equidistant from probe P”“Chomsky 2000:122 & footnote 77”MI (41), p. 122 is worded “Terms of the same minimal domain are ‘equidistant’ to probes”. Hiraiwa's wording is DbP's restatement (44), p. 27Content right; the wording he quotes is DbP's, not MI's
Icelandic default, (30)“Chomsky 2000:130”MI pp. 128–130 (default [3person], p. 128; (51), p. 130)Consistent

4. Rules EP-0 to EP-8 (ours; all HYPOTHESIS unless marked)

EP-0 THREE-FEATURES  A head may carry (i) a phi-probe (drives Agree), (ii) an EPP-feature
                 (requires its Spec to be filled: drives Merge), or both; a goal takes part
                 in Agree or Move only while ACTIVE (it still has an unvalued feature of its
                 own).  (SOURCED: DbP (2a-c), p. 4; MI p. 121-122; DbP (3a), p. 6.)
                 Refines MA-0': an exponent at H is Agree-morphology if it spells what H's
                 phi-probe copied; it is a Merge site if it fills H's EPP position.
EP-1 WHO-FILLS   (SOURCED: MI (5a), (6), (24), pp. 102-103, 109; (45b), p. 126; DbP p. 7.)
                 (a) Phase head (C, v*): its EPP-feature is optional and can be satisfied
                     only by raising from inside its own phase. No pure Merge, so no
                     expletive.
                 (b) Non-phase head (T-like): its EPP-feature may be obligatory and can be
                     satisfied by raising OR by pure Merge of an expletive.
                 (c) Pure Merge into a theta-position is for arguments only, so an
                     expletive goes only into a non-theta position.
EP-2 INCH-EPP    (revises MA-2'(c); restores IN-8's location)  INCH's requirement IN-8 is
                 an obligatory EPP-feature on P_INCH, a NON-PHASE head merged at the top of
                 the V-level (below v, above the disjuncts such as na).  The position it
                 opens (written on the site as the PP's object rho_C) is a non-theta
                 position.  It is filled by
                   IM (Move) of the closest slot below P_INCH (= IN-5' BUMP), or
                   pure Merge of rho_D (= IN-9's placeholder; EP-1 (b), (c)).
                 NOT the Qual-layer phase head: that would make the placeholder pure Merge
                 into a phase head's EPP position, which EP-1 (a) excludes, while HMP
                 print placeholder forms ((7b), (16a)).
                 Restated structure (ours): [P_INCH-P rho_C [P_INCH' P_INCH [VP ... na ... V]]];
                 C2 still spells rho_C first, as IN-5' requires.
EP-3 MOM-FILL    (derives IN-9's two stipulations)
                 (a) If rho_D is in the active subarray, Merge of rho_D preempts Move
                     (MI p. 106).  If a slot rho_L is first-merged below P_INCH, rho_L then
                     has no position: the object position is held by rho_I (IN-1; HMP
                     n. 2), and nothing adjoins to an occupant (MA-4').  -> crash.
                     Unless rho_L can fuse with rho_I (' + ' -> ', HMP n. 4, only for an
                     indefinite ').  So rho_D converges only when nothing is below P_INCH.
                 (b) Move goes only to a c-commanding position.  A slot in Spec,v is merged
                     ABOVE P_INCH, so it can never satisfy P_INCH ("never the Spec,v
                     participant").  Areal ho- (a subject delta at the top, SH-4) likewise.
                 (c) If two slots are below P_INCH, the CLOSEST one is moved (MI (5b-iii):
                     "if there is no closer candidate"; (40c)).  Schematic prediction:
                     Spec,V before Comp,V (T42e).
EP-4 OBLIGATORY  P_INCH's EPP is obligatory (HMP: "must always be preceded"), like T's
                 ("might be universal", MI p. 109), not like a phase head's ("optional").
                 With nothing below and no rho_D available: crash.  Agrees with EP-2.
EP-5 DEFAULT-DI  (gives IN-7 (D) a sourced mechanism; one of two)  P_INCH Agrees with the
                 slot it attracts (its "object agreement morphology", HMP) and, being
                 phi-complete, deactivates it (DbP (3b); MI p. 124).  M/S then probes; in
                 an unaccusative (v not phasal) its closest matching goal is that inactive
                 slot -> defective intervention (MI (42)) -> M/S default [3person]
                 (MI pp. 126, 128).
                 COST: activity needs an activating feature on rho (MI/DbP: structural
                 Case).  The site's slots have none, so we must add an abstract [uK] to
                 rho (ours).  Rival: MA-5a, PP (or P_INCH-P) as a phase (our extension).
                 OPEN between them (T41c, T42c).
EP-6 PIC-CHOICE  M/S never takes the object's phi.  Two reasons, same strings:
                 PIC1 (MI (21)): VP is sealed once v*P is complete.
                 PIC2 (DbP (11)): M/S (T-like, inside the C-like D1) can see into VP until
                 Qual is merged; rho_A at the v*P edge is the closer goal (MI (40c)).
                 Qual (C-like = Z) cannot see VP under either.  They differ only for a
                 transitive whose Spec,v* slot is not a matching goal (T42a).
EP-7 PHI-UNIT    (SOURCED: MI p. 124.)  A phi-set is valued and deleted as a unit; one probe
                 does not agree with two goals.  MA-6' stands.  MA-3a (Qual keeps [udelta],
                 passes [uphi]) is consistent only if delta is NOT a phi-feature; MA-3b has
                 no such condition (T42b).
EP-8 PHASAL-v    A verbal phrase is a (strong) phase only if its v has phi-features (an
                 object to agree with) and an external argument (MI pp. 106-108), i.e.
                 v* = "transitive v or experiencer" (DbP n. 8).  Unergatives: neither text
                 says; by MI's criterion, no.
RuleRests onStatus
EP-0DbP (2), (3a); MI pp. 121–123SOURCED definitions; the restatement of MA-0′ is HYPOTHESIS
EP-1MI (5a), (6), (24), (45b); DbP p. 7SOURCED (as a statement of MI/DbP)
EP-2EP-1 + HMP (7b), (16a) printed placeholders + IN-8HYPOTHESIS. It follows from SOURCED definitions plus SOURCED forms, but the mapping of INCH onto “head with an EPP-feature” is ours
EP-3MI pp. 104, 106; HMP n. 2, n. 4; MA-4′; IN-5′HYPOTHESIS. It turns IN-9's “otherwise” and “never Spec,v” clauses into theorems. Every printed HMP form fits
EP-4HMP §2; MI p. 109HYPOTHESIS, a second, independent fit for EP-2
EP-5MI (42), pp. 124, 126, 128; DbP (3); HD2HYPOTHESIS; needs an added feature on ρ; OPEN vs MA-5a
EP-6MI (21); DbP (11), p. 14OPEN between PIC1 and PIC2; no string separates them
EP-7MI p. 124SOURCED principle; the consequence for MA-3a is HYPOTHESIS
EP-8MI pp. 106–108; DbP n. 8SOURCED criterion; its application to Navajo ‘go’ is HYPOTHESIS

5. What changes, rule by rule

RuleBefore (2026-10-19)AfterWhy
MA-2′(c)Placeholder = EM of an expletive satisfying the EF of the Qual-layer INCH, the phase head's ownMA-2″(c) = EP-2: pure Merge of an expletive into the EPP position of PINCH, a non-phase head at the top of the V-level. Still a Merge siteMI (5a), p. 109; DbP p. 7; 2008 p. 157 (T, inherited) all put expletive Merge on a non-phase head. HMP's printed placeholders force the move
MA-2′(a)Bump = EM of the PP high, or IM by the Qual-layer EFIM (Move) to PINCH's EPP position (EP-2). The participant is first-merged in its role position (MI (6)), so the bump has to be MoveMI (6): roles come only from first (pure) Merge; MI p. 109
IN-8INCH has a P-like requirement; Pnull carries itUnchanged, now supported over MA-2′(c)'s Qual locationEP-1, EP-4
IN-9Stipulates the placeholder “otherwise” and “a slot in Spec,v is never ρC”Both clauses derived (EP-3 (a), (b)). One new schematic prediction (EP-3 (c))MoM; c-command
IN-7 (D), MA-5′Default when no eligible slot; MA-5a (phase) vs MA-5b (inactive)MA-5b = EP-5, with MI's own Icelandic mechanism, at the cost of an abstract activating feature. Still OPEN against MA-5aMI (42), pp. 126, 128; DbP (3)
MA-1′M/S reaches only the v*P edge (phase)Two versions, PIC1 and PIC2 (EP-6). Same stringsDbP (11), p. 14
MA-3′MA-3a vs MA-3b OPENStill OPEN. MA-3a now requires δ ∉ φ (EP-7)MI p. 124
MA-6′Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree excluded (n. 12)Excluded with an earlier source too (MI p. 124)EP-7
MA-0′Three-way exponent test (Agree / IM / EM)Same test, now stated through feature types (EP-0)DbP (2)

HYPOTHESIS MA-3′'s selection condition is untouched. With the placeholder moved down to PINCH, the Qual layer keeps its role as D1's phase head. Its Agree feature still goes to the head it selects, and M/S still agrees with the subject in a ‘start to’ transitive (HMP (2b) -sh-, 1sg). Had the placeholder stayed in the Qual layer, the qualifier heads of INCH (n, ii, directly above M/S) would have had to be both the phase head and a T-like head at once. MI does not allow that combination, which is the clash this page removes.

6. Derivations EP1–EP8

Steps are labelled by rule set: Σ role schema, A word (D1), B clause (D2). Each step names its operation: pure Merge (EM), Move (IM), Agree or Spell-out. All forms are already on the site with their sources. No new segmentation is introduced.

EP1. HMP (7b) ʼawééʼ ʼináʼniichah ‘the baby starts to cry’: an expletive at a non-phase head (as HD3, MA7′)

  1. Σ Σ(√CRY) = {ρA} (sentient, no endpoint → Spec,v by LINK-1); the complement is the conflated noun cha, not a slot (H&P/HMP). φ(ρA) = 3.
  2. A pure Merge: [V N cha V]; REP ná; INCH's ρI in the object position (IN-1); PINCH with its obligatory EPP-feature (EP-2, EP-4).
  3. A EPP of PINCH: no slot below PINCH (EP-3 (a)), and ρA is not merged yet and will sit above it (EP-3 (b)), so Move is impossible → pure Merge of ρD ⟨E none, φ 3, δ INDF⟩ into the non-θ position (EP-1 (b), (c)). This is MI's “Merge of expletive” (45b-i), at a non-phase head as MI (5a) requires.
  4. A pure Merge: v; ρA in Spec,v (VPISH); M/S; Qual [n ii]. Agree: M/S's closest goal is ρA (above PINCH-P) → 3rd, Ø.
  5. A Spell-out D1 (as HD3): ’ ⌢ ná ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ … ⌢ chah → ʼináʼniichah ✓ (unsegmented by HMP; alignment the site's).
  6. B ʼawééʼ links to ρA. ρD has no role in the action, so no noun can link to it.
  7. Change from MA7′: same string; the expletive's head is PINCH, not the Qual phase head.

EP2. HMP (16a) ʼiʼniichííl ‘it started to snow’: the same, with no participant at all (as HD7)

  1. Σ Σ(√SNOW) = ∅.
  2. A pure Merge: V; ρI; PINCH. Nothing to Move → pure Merge ρD (EP-3 (a), EP-4). v (no specifier; not a phase, EP-8); M/S; Qual.
  3. A Agree: M/S's only candidate is ρD. If ρD is inactive after PINCH's Agree, M/S shows the default (EP-5); if it is hidden by a phase (MA-5a), likewise. Third person either way.
  4. A Spell-out: ’ ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ chííl ✓ (as HD7).

EP3. HMP (2b) bi-ná-ʼnii-sh-dl[į́į́]h ‘start to drink it’: Move, and why the placeholder cannot be used (as HD1)

  1. Σ {ρA (drinker; Proto-Agent) = 1sg, Spec,v; ρX (what is drunk; Proto-Patient) = 3, Comp,V}. Both roles come from first Merge (MI (6)).
  2. A pure Merge: V dlį́į́h + ρX; REP ná; ρI takes the object position; PINCH.
  3. A Derivation (i), ρD not in the subarray: PINCH's EPP → Move ρX (the closest slot below, EP-3 (c)) to its position; Agree PINCH ⟶ ρX (its object agreement; ρX then inactive, EP-5).
  4. A pure Merge: v* d; ρA in Spec,v*; M/S; Qual. Agree: M/S ⟶ ρA, 1sg → sh. Under PIC2, ρX would be visible, but ρA is closer (and ρX is inactive anyway).
  5. A Spell-out (as HD1): bi ⌢ ná ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ sh ⌢ d ⌢ dlį́į́h ✓ (HMP's segmentation; bi overt because oblique).
  6. A Derivation (ii), ρD in the subarray: pure Merge ρD preempts Move (MI p. 106). ρX stays in Comp,V. Its exponent position is the object position, which ρI holds, and it cannot adjoin there (MA-4′). Fusion is not available, since ρX is not an indefinite ’. ρX is left with no position → crash. So *’ ⌢ ná ⌢ … (placeholder plus a definite object) is predicted not to exist. This is schematic. The printed form is (i).

EP4. HMP (10a) shináʼniidlóóh ‘I start to get cold (about dawn)’: Move, then a default from an inactive goal (as HD2, MA5′)

  1. Σ {ρ1} (change of state; Proto-Patient) first-merged in Spec,V; φ = 1sg.
  2. A pure Merge: V dlóóh, ρ1; REP ná; ρI; PINCH. Move ρ1 to PINCH's position (EP-2); Agree PINCH ⟶ ρ1 (1sg). ρ1 is now inactive (EP-5, if ρ carries [uK]).
  3. A pure Merge: v d (unaccusative: not a phase, MI pp. 106–107, EP-8); M/S; Qual.
  4. A Agree: M/S probes. Its closest matching goal is ρ1, which is inactive. By MI (42) it blocks the search, and nothing else is in range anyway. → default, MI's “[3person] (the default choice)” (p. 128) = IN-7 (D). MA-5a gives the same result by making the phrase a phase.
  5. A Spell-out (as HD2): shi ⌢ ná ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ (M Ø) ⌢ d ⌢ dlóóh ✓ (alignment the site's; HMP do not segment (10a)).
  6. A Failed alternative with ρD in the subarray: ρD preempts Move; ρ1 stays in Spec,V. ρD (closer, inactive) blocks M/S → default, so ρ1's 1sg is spelled nowhere: the object position is held, and M/S is not available → crash (schematic). The prediction is that no ‘start to’ unaccusative pairs a placeholder ’ with the participant spelled somewhere else (T42d). HMP's 5 + 8 unaccusatives all shift (u10), which fits.

EP5. HMP n. 4 sodiʼniiszin ‘I started to pray’: the fusion escape (as HD6)

  1. Σ theme so=d-l-zin; ρA = 1sg in Spec,v; nothing below v (HMP's “cf. (7b)”).
  2. A PINCH's EPP: nothing to Move → pure Merge ρD (EP-3 (a)). IN-5′'s blocking clause: Position I is held by so, so ρD is pronounced in the object position and fuses with ρI (’ + ’ → ’).
  3. A Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (1sg). Spell-out (as HD6): so ⌢ di ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ … ⌢ zin ✓.
  4. EP-2 adds nothing to why so blocks the left edge (T39c stays open). The relation between PINCH's EPP position and where its filler is pronounced is a spell-out matter (C2), not a syntactic one. HYPOTHESIS.

EP6. Hale 2001 (24a) shidoołhosh ‘He/She will tickle me’: PIC1 vs PIC2 (as MA1′)

  1. Σ {ρA = 3, Spec,v*; ρX = 1sg, Comp,V}.
  2. A pure Merge: V ghosh + ρX; v* ł; ρA; M/S; Qual d.
  3. A Agree, PIC1: VP is sealed once v*P is complete, so M/S sees only ρA → 3. PIC2: M/S can see ρX (DbP p. 14), but ρA c-commands it and matches, so ρA is closest (MI (40c)) → 3.
  4. A Spell-out: sh ⌢ d ⌢ w ⌢ ł ⌢ ghosh ✓ (Hale's segment line).
  5. Result: both give the string. They come apart only if Spec,v* held a slot that does not match M/S's probe. No such form is on the site (T42a).

EP7. Willie (31f) hojishxash ‘That person bit that person’: the top head and the φ-unit (as MA10′)

  1. Σ ρA = ⟨3 (zero), δ = 4⟩; ρX = ⟨3 (zero), δ = 4⟩.
  2. A pure Merge through Qual. Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (φ = 3, zero). Under PIC2, M/S could see ρX, but ρA is closer.
  3. A Qual (C-like) cannot see VP under PIC1 or PIC2 (DbP p. 14: “with Σ = ZP (so that Z = C), the probe Z cannot access the domain YP”). So δ at the top can only be ρA's (MA-3a or MA-3b), as before.
  4. A MA-3a as written splits ρA's features: φ to M/S, δ to Qual. By MI p. 124 a φ-set is valued as a unit. So MA-3a is coherent only if δ (the fourth person) is not a φ-feature. The site's notation already writes it apart. If the fourth person were a person value, M/S would have to spell it, and here M/S is the plain third-person zero (Willie gives no segmentation; alignment the site's, as SD7).
  5. A Spell-out: ho ⌢ ji ⌢ … shxash ✓.
  6. Result: MA10′ unchanged. MA-3a vs MA-3b now turns partly on whether the fourth person is a person value (T42b).

EP8. W&J (50b) dibé łį́į́ʼ bitah yíghááh ‘The horse went among the sheep’: is ‘go’ a phase? (T41h; as MA4′)

  1. Σ ρA (the one who goes) in Spec,v; ρX = the postposition's object; both 3; inverse: ρX [top].
  2. A pure Merge P -tah + ρX; Agree inside PP → bi (IA-3).
  3. A v: is it v*? MI p. 108 limits verbal phases to “transitive v with φ-features and EA”, and DbP n. 8 to “transitive v or experiencer”. ‘Go’ has an external argument but no object for v to agree with (ρX is P's). So by both criteria v is not a strong phase and has no EPP-feature of a phase head (EP-8).
  4. A Consequence for IA-1*: if the topic slot moves at all, the mover must be Qual (the C-like phase head). Under MI (24), Qual's EPP can be met only by raising from inside its phase, and ρX is inside. That is allowed if the PP is not itself a phase (MA-5b) and blocked if it is (MA-5a). IA-3 (no movement) remains cheaper.
  5. A Spell-out D1: bitah ⌢ yíghááh; B łį́į́ʼ → ρA, dibé → ρX ✓ (as MA4′).
  6. Result: T41h is partly answered. By the definitions, ‘go’ is not v*. Whether Navajo's v for ‘go’ has any φ-features of its own is a data question.
SideGets rightMisses or costs
Grant's typology noteThe EPP/Edge Feature line is a faithful one-line statement of MI/DbP: heads differ in whether they “require, allow, or disallow” a specifier (DbP p. 41)It uses 2008's name for a 2000/2001 notion. It does not mention the phase-head/T split (MI (5a), p. 109), which turned out to be the part that matters most for Navajo
Hiraiwa 2001(2) is MI (40) verbatim; (3) is a fair gloss of MI (42); (4) is DbP (46) with his addition marked(5) quotes DbP's wording under an MI citation. (2a) “identity” is the version Chomsky himself narrows on p. 124
The originals page (2026-10-19, 8:46pm)The v/v* split, inheritance, and the placeholder as an expletive. MA-6′'s exclusion, now also supported by MI p. 124MA-2′(c) placed the expletive at a phase head, which MI/DbP exclude. Its own “mismatch noted” line (Chomsky's T is not a phase head) was the symptom. MA1′'s reason was PIC1 only
HMP / IN-8 (2026-10-19, 12:46pm)Locating the requirement on a postposition-like piece (“behaves like an ‘incorporated’ postposition”), which is the location MI/DbP allowIN-9 stated the placeholder's distribution as a list; EP-3 derives it
MI/DbP applied to NavajoEPP-type distinctions (obligatory vs optional; who may insert an expletive) organize the ‘start to’ facts. Defective intervention gives the default. MI's θ vs checking split matches the site's slot-and-role designActivity depends on structural Case, which Navajo slots do not show. Neither text classes unergatives. Neither says anything about structure inside a word, so every application here is an extension

8. Grant's frame

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Word-internal Merge or Agree sites. After this check, one of the two certain word-internal Merge sites, the placeholder, has a sharper address. It is at PINCH, low in the word, not at the top. The bump is Move to the same position. Both are Merge (they build structure), and they sit at the edge of the verb phrase, not at the word's outer edge. The Agree sites are unchanged (M/S, P's own pronoun, and now PINCH's object agreement). Merge builds structure; Agree values features such as person and number. Nothing on this page contradicts the conjecture.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Feature bundles and the weak thesis. MI's and DbP's goals are feature sets (“the φ-set of N”), not words. Every Agree on this page is with a slot bundle ρ in D1, before any noun arrives. The placeholder is a bundle with features and no role, and nothing in MI or DbP requires it to be a noun. That supports the weak thesis (roles live on slots, nouns link later) and says nothing about the strong one. One new point: if EP-5 is right, Navajo slots need an activating feature that plays the part Case plays for MI's nouns. If Grant's bundles are the arguments, that feature belongs in the bundle (ours, HYPOTHESIS).

HYPOTHESIS Dowty, and theta vs event structure. No participant's role in the action changes. Roles come from first Merge (MI (6): pure Merge in a θ-position is for arguments only), and INCH's position is non-θ. The ‘start to’ layer adds an onset to the event and a position, but no role. MI p. 127 already treats θ-structure and agreement as separate systems, so the theta roles and the event-structure layer stay compatible descriptions of the same participants.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE STRATA (theta roles first, event-structure roles as another layer, noun selection later). On this page the order is forced. Roles by first Merge come first; PINCH can only Move a slot that is already there (EP-3); and nouns link in D2. MI's MoM adds a fit: the event layer's own element (ρD) is preferred over moving a participant whenever the result converges. As before, STRATA is not separated from the adjunct and inside-the-clause views, because none of them predicts a different string here.

HYPOTHESIS The changeover from rule set A to rule set B. DbP pp. 13–14: a strong phase's domain is spelled out at the phase, and its head and edge “are spelled out if they remain in situ. Otherwise, their status is determined … at the next strong phase”; (10): a phase “is interpreted/evaluated at” the next one. If D1 is a C-like phase, the word's interior is handed to rule set A's spell-out at D1, and what stays at the word's edge is evaluated again at D2 by rule set B. That matches “residuals read at D2” on the Merge/Agree page §11.2. This is a fit, not a test. Where the word ends is still open (Hale 2003 n. 12).

9. Tasks T42a–h and T41 statuses

TaskWhat it needs
T42aPIC1 vs PIC2 (EP-6): a transitive whose Spec,v* slot is not a matching goal for M/S. Does M/S then ever spell the object's person? (Young & Morgan paradigms)
T42bIs the fourth person a person (φ) value or a separate deictic feature? Any form where M/S itself spells a fourth-person subject differently from third would make δ part of φ and rule out MA-3a (EP-7)
T42cEP-5 vs MA-5a: is there any evidence that Navajo slots carry an activating feature (any case-like distinction), or a form where a slot already agreed with by a P is still found by M/S? (joins T41c)
T42dEP-3 (a) / EP4 prediction: no ‘start to’ unaccusative with a placeholder ’ and the participant spelled elsewhere; no transitive with a placeholder and a definite object (schematic). Check HMP 2000 (printed) and Young & Morgan 1980G:320–321
T42eEP-3 (c): a ‘start to’ form of a verb with two slots below v (e.g. a ditransitive or a verb with Spec,V and Comp,V). Which one is bumped? Prediction: the closer (higher) one
T42fIs PINCH's agreement φ-complete (does the bumped prefix show number, e.g. a plural participant)? EP-5 needs it to be. Is ρD a there-type expletive ([person] only) or it-type? Does a placeholder ever show anything but the indefinite ’?
T42gIs INCH's requirement obligatory in every mode (EP-4)? HMP's (2) shows five modes, all with the prefix; check the remaining modes and aspects in Young & Morgan
T42hChomsky 2004 “Beyond explanatory adequacy”: the step from the EPP-feature to the edge feature, and whether the phase-head/T split on expletives survives it (2008 p. 157 suggests it does)

T41 statuses after this page: T41e answered (this page). T41h partly answered (EP8: not v* by the definitions; the data question remains). T41c sharpened: MA-5b now has its sourced mechanism (EP-5) at the cost of an activating feature (→ T42c). T41a unchanged; MA-3′'s selection condition is untouched by EP-2. T41b unchanged, but MA-3a now depends on T42b. T41d, T41f and T41g are unchanged.

What else changed on the site

Update notes on the borrowed terms checked against their originals (lede, MA-2′(c), MA-1′, MA-5′, §9), ‘Start to’ in HMP's own words (rules IN-8, IN-9) and Merge and Agree inside the word (lede). There is a new row on open questions (T42a–h), a sources section (added 2026-10-20, 4:46am), and a home-page entry. No verb-dictionary entries changed and no new Navajo forms were added.