Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.

SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading

The borrowed terms checked against their originals: what Rudin 1988, Hiraiwa 2001 and Chomsky 2008 actually define, and what that changes inside the Navajo verb word (T40b)

Working note. Kept as written (URL, data and status labels unchanged). Filed under Merge and Agree inside the word; the consolidated argument is the essay merge-agree. Rule IDs: rules index.

Verbs on this page → dictionary: yishxash ‘bite’ · dabiiłtsą́ ‘see’ · yíghááh ‘join; with -tah ‘among’: go among’

Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). The framework is restated in §1: VPISH (arguments merged in the verb’s scope, subject in Spec,vP) with theta roles, and V→v→T with the subject raised to Spec,TP as the working default in tensed clauses; each pattern is what else moves, with an LF whose scope matches c-command. Light d, used below, is withdrawn (Grant, 2026-11-14); light n is an OPEN structural question. The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Derivations below in which the verb or subject does not raise are labelled contrast; the working default raises V→v→T and the subject to Spec,TP. Status on the spine: see unified structure, §1. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.

2026-11-11 audit pass 1. The source definitions of Merge/Agree/phase are brief contrasts, not axioms imposed on Navajo. The MA/EF rules, d identity, phase heads and placeholder attachment are hypotheses. Copying a definition does not establish a Navajo head or movement path. The primary vP→TP subject derivation and V→v→T head chain, including all LF/locality checks, remain to be compared explicitly with PF assembly in pass 2.

2026-11-11 audit pass 3. Status badges now use only the label set SOURCED, HYPOTHESIS, SPECULATIVE, OPEN, NONE and GRANT'S CONJECTURE; verdict or task words that had been styled as badges (for example Opened, PRE-VPISH, DONE, SUPPORTS, PARTLY ANSWERED) are now plain text or a label with a qualifier. Local box file paths were removed from this page; files inside the repository are given by repo-relative path, and the source citation next to each removed path stays as the reference. See the pass 3 report.

2026-11-13 audit pass 7. An earlier dated note on this page treats V→v→T and subject raising as Grant’s conjecture or a comparator to test against PF/template rivals. Since 2026-11-13 they are the working default in tensed clauses: VPISH frames where the arguments start so that syntax and semantics line up; it is not a word-order account. PF/template accounts are kept only as labelled contrast, and the open question is what else has to move. The earlier note is kept as written. See the 2026-11-13 note and the pass 7 report.

The page Merge and Agree inside the Navajo verb word sorted the site's word-internal findings using five mid-level terms from Grant's typology note: Rudin's [±MFS], Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree, Chomsky's feature inheritance, the Edge Feature, and phases. Its originals had not been opened. This page opens them, compares each definition with the wording used, tightens the formal rules MA-0 to MA-6, and re-runs the nine derivations, plus one more. The two operations stay apart throughout. Merge builds structure: it puts an element at a position, either a fresh element (External Merge, EM) or a copy of one already in the structure (Internal Merge, IM, which is movement). Agree values features such as person and number: a probe on a head finds the closest matching goal and copies its value. Nothing moves under Agree. Written 2026-10-19, 8:46pm PT.

Update 2026-10-20, 4:46am (T41e). Chomsky 2000 (“Minimalist Inquiries”) and 2001 (“Derivation by Phase”) have now been opened: the older definitions behind “edge feature”. Four changes to this page. (1) MA-2′(c) is revised. Both texts allow an expletive only in the extra position of a T-like, non-phase head; a phase head may fill its extra position only by raising (MI (5a), p. 102; p. 109). So the ‘start to’ placeholder cannot satisfy the Qual-layer phase head's own feature, as written below. It belongs to PINCH, the postposition-like piece at the top of the verb phrase (new EP-2; this was IN-8's original location). The bump is Move to that same position. (2) MA1′'s reason (the phase wall) is MI's version of the PIC; under DbP's version, M/S can see the object and the closer subject wins (EP-6). The strings are the same. (3) MA-5b gets its original mechanism (defective intervention and default [3person], MI pp. 123–128), but it needs an activating feature on Navajo slots, which MI/DbP tie to structural Case (EP-5). (4) MA-3a holds only if the deictic δ is not part of the person/number set, since MI p. 124 values that set “as a unit” (EP-7). Grant's EPP/Edge Feature wording is confirmed as the 2000/2001 notion (MI p. 109; DbP p. 41). The rules and derivations below are kept as written.

Update 2026-10-20, 12:46pm (T41f). Hale's n. 12 forms are now read (where the yes/no enclitic -ísh can go): ka naash[á] ‘I am sick’ and ka-[á]sh nanin[á] ‘are you sick?’. Hale gives ka as a preverb that can “appear as separate words”, so the enclitic split is between two words, not inside one. The bottom-line “[−MFS]-like” verdict below and the §6 clitic row therefore go back to OPEN. The enclitic does meet Rudin's condition (it attaches to the first constituent: NLA yes/no prose, (4), (6), (10a), (12)), but by EN-1′ it can never reach inside the verb word, so it cannot test the prefix zone (EN-6). The text below is kept as written.

Ground rules (Grant's). No new Navajo form is introduced. Every form below is already on this site, from a named source with its example number, and the page links to where it was read. None is segmented beyond what its source prints. The three originals are general-syntax works. None of them mentions Navajo. Every mapping of a Navajo fact onto their terms is therefore ours, graded HYPOTHESIS at most. What the originals say is graded SOURCED, with the page number. Only contradicting data count against an analysis; a source's silence does not. No earlier analysis (Hale, Willie, HMP, Kibrik, or this site's own rules) is assumed to be fully right.

Notation (the site's own, as on the Merge/Agree page). Σ = role-schema step (which slots the verb has and their roles in the action); A = word level (cycle D1, rule set A: the prefixal, left-headed functional spine); B = clause level (cycle D2, rule set B: right-headed clause syntax and noun linking). Spine (Hale 2003): Qual > M/S > v > V. Slots ρ = ⟨E, pos, φ, (δ)⟩ (SH-0), where φ is person/number and δ the deictic value (fourth person, indefinite, areal). CYC = the site's spell-out ordering (§3). VPISH: the subject slot is first-merged in Spec,v. New abbreviations from the originals: EF = edge feature (Chomsky 2008), v* = the v of a verb with full argument structure (transitive or experiencer), PIC = phase-impenetrability condition, DIC = defective intervention constraint (Hiraiwa 2001).

Bottom line, in plain words

HYPOTHESIS The Merge/Agree page's main picture survives the originals, but it is now smaller and sharper. Most of what happens inside the word is still Agree (copying person and number), and the places where something is really built or moved are still at edges. One of its three “Merge sites” has to be downgraded to OPEN. That is the fourth-person, indefinite or areal piece of a subject, which sits at the top of the word. Chomsky's own version of feature inheritance allows two readings of it, and they give the same strings. On one reading it is agreement morphology on the top head (Agree). On the other, the top head's edge feature moves it there (Merge).

HYPOTHESIS The ‘start to’ placeholder is the best match found anywhere on the site between a Navajo fact and a mid-level term. Chomsky (2008, p. 157) proposes that when an edge feature cannot be satisfied by moving anything, it “must be satisfied by EM, necessarily of an expletive since no argument role can be assigned”. In the same passage he adds that when no goal is accessible, the head shows “default morphology”. That is exactly what Hale, Munro & Platero describe. The role-less ’ appears with ‘cry’ and ‘snow’ because nothing else can fill the slot. In ‘I start to get cold’ the Mode/Subject head shows a default third person because its only candidate is inside the postposition-like piece.

HYPOTHESIS The “Multiple Agree” candidate is not Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree. Hiraiwa's operation is one probe valuing one kind of feature on several goals at once. The probe's own morphology then shows only the closer goal (p. 79 n. 12: “a closer goal feature determines agreement”; no language shows “multiple agreement on the side of probe/head”). The Navajo object prefix (yi- vs zero) reads two different things from two different slots: the object's person and the subject's deictic value. So either it is a context-sensitive spelling (the site's SH-6, now favoured), or it is a counterexample to Hiraiwa's generalization. It cannot be his operation as he defines it.

HYPOTHESIS [−MFS]-like still holds, but for a better reason. In Rudin's framework no ordinary position can take a second occupant, so “a full position refuses a second one” proves nothing by itself. [+MFS] is about extra elements adjoining to a filled specifier (pp. 480–481). Rudin's decisive diagnostic for the [−MFS] type is a clitic placed right after the first fronted element (pp. 461, 463, 466). Hale reports exactly that for the one disjunct case on the site: the polar enclitic can split the preverb ka off from the rest of the verb (2003 n. 12). The fixed order of disjunct prefixes does not count either way. Rudin's fixed order is subject before non-subject (p. 475), not an order by prefix class.

HYPOTHESIS Phases: Chomsky's own list gives one result for free. His phases are CP and v*P, and an unaccusative's v is not a phase (p. 143). Mode/Subject's probe therefore sees only the subject at the edge of a transitive vP, never the object. In a one-participant verb whose participant starts low, it reaches the participant directly, with no movement. That is the site's “closest slot” option U-2, and Chomsky lists exactly this case (“passive/unaccusative in situ”, p. 155). The movement option U-1, as the site wrote it, has no trigger in his system. A postposition phrase is not on Chomsky's list, so the site's “PP is a phase” is our own extension. The same texts offer a second explanation: the postposition's own agreement uses up its object, which then cannot agree with anything higher.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE “Navajo has word-internal Merge sites, or possibly Agree sites” is Grant's. After this check, the word-internal Agree sites are firmer than the Merge sites. Two Merge sites remain certain: the bumped object and the placeholder. The third is OPEN. Nothing here contradicts the conjecture.

On this page: 1 Sources · 2 Definitions side by side · 3 Rules MA-0′ to MA-6′ · 4 What changed, rule by rule · 5 Derivations re-run (MA1′–MA10′) · 6 Rudin's diagnostics applied · 7 Gets right / misses · 8 Grant's frame · 9 Tasks T41a–h

1. Sources

SourceAccess this runUsed for
Rudin, Catherine. 1988. On multiple questions and multiple WH fronting. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 6: 445–501Opened: full PDF (57 pp., scanned journal pages with a text layer) from a University of Chicago course-readings URL, read as extracted text; page numbers from the printed headers (PDF p. n = journal p. 444 + n)[±MFS] definition (70), structures (71), diagnostics table (69), clitic predictions (34), order facts, substitution vs adjunction in SpecCP (pp. 480–482)
Hiraiwa, Ken. 2001. Multiple Agree and the Defective Intervention Constraint in Japanese. MITWPL 40 (HUMIT 2000): 67–80Opened: full PDF (14 pp., born-digital) from web.mit.edu (a 24.956 course folder), extracted textAgree and Match (1), (2); DIC (3), (9); Multiple Agree (7), (8); Icelandic default agreement (31)–(33); n. 12 on probe-side morphology
Chomsky, Noam. 2008. On phases. In R. Freidin, C. P. Otero & M. L. Zubizarreta (eds.), Foundational Issues in Linguistic Theory, 133–166. MIT PressOpened: the chapter PDF (MIT Press eBook portion, hosted on a Caltech personal page), extracted text with printed page numbers. Only the chapter's own pages 133–166 and notes are used. The PDF also contains the start of the next chapter, which is not usedEF (p. 139); EM vs IM (p. 140); phases CP, v*P and the claim that only phase heads drive IM (p. 143); inheritance (pp. 143–144, 148–149); A′-position as EF-attracted (p. 150); EF is indiscriminate (p. 151); goal spelled out in situ or at the probe (p. 155); v vs v* (p. 156); EF inheritance, default morphology and expletive EM (p. 157)
Grewendorf, Günther. 2001. Multiple wh-fronting. Linguistic Inquiry 32: 87–122SOURCED (abstract only) Publisher abstract (MIT Press / DOI page) read through search results. The full text is behind a paywall and was not openedOnly the abstract's statement of the cluster mechanism
Grant, “Typology of Merge/Agree Phenomena” (2 pp.)Re-opened (text, [local working copy, not in the repository])The definitions checked in §2
This site's pagesRe-readMerge/Agree page (rules, MA1–MA9); subject on the head (SH-2–SH-6, SD7, SD8, Willie (31f)); HMP ms. (IN-0, IN-5′, IN-7 (D), IN-8, IN-9); inverse as Agree/EPP (IA-1*, IA-3); A/B as spell-out (Hale 2003 n. 12)
Not opened—Chomsky 2000, 2001, 2004 (cited in the originals); Bošković; Richards 1997; Miyagawa 2005 (known here only through Chomsky's summary on p. 156); Young & Morgan. None is used as evidence

2. Definitions side by side

Left: the wording in Grant's note (and on the Merge/Agree page). Middle: what the original says, with page. Right: the consequence.

TermGrant's note / the Merge/Agree pageThe original SOURCEDVerdict and consequence
[±MFS]“Multiply Filled Specifier”; “in [+MFS] languages an already-moved wh … can serve as a further landing site, so later whs Merge to it and form a cluster. In [–MFS] languages no such intermediate host is available.” Page: “a position that is already filled can host more”“MULTIPLY-FILLED SPECCP” (p. 448). (70): “SpecCP can contain multiple Wh-words at S-structure in Bulgarian and Romanian ([+MFS] languages), but only one in Serbo-Croatian, Polish, and Czech ([-MFS] languages)” (p. 478). (71b): [−MFS] still fronts every wh. The others sit “in or adjoined to IP” (pp. 447, 471). Mechanism (p. 480): “A. A single Wh-phrase is substituted into the SpecCP position … B. An additional Wh-phrase or phrases may be adjoined to SpecCP. C. The adjunction in (B) is to the right.” A flat multi-slot SpecCP is rejected because it “requires substitution into a node that already contains one or more Wh-phrases” (p. 481)Grant's note is right about the two types. Two refinements. (i) In Rudin, [−MFS] does not mean “no host”. The extra elements go to a different position (IP). (ii) In her framework a substitution position never takes two occupants. Only adjunction to a filled specifier can give [+MFS]. So the Navajo test must be about adjunction (rule MA-4′)
[+MFS] diagnostics“Superiority, no intervention, clitics after whole group, multiple extraction”; [−MFS]: “Freer order, intervention possible, clitics after first wh”Table (69), p. 478: multiple wh-extraction from a clause; wh-island violations; “clitics follow first Wh-word” ([−MFS] +); “parentheticals, adverbs, particles after first WH” ([−MFS] +); “free NOM/ACC Wh-word order” ([−MFS] +). Clitics: “In the [+MFS] languages, clitics are placed after the whole series” (p. 461). The prediction holds “in the case where clitic placement is by encliticization to the first constituent of the clause” ((34), p. 463), and the clitic evidence is “inconclusive for the [+MFS] languages” because their clitics are pre-verbal (p. 466). Order: “restricted at least to subject > nonsubject” in [+MFS] (p. 475), derived from the leftmost wh being the “head of SpecCP” (p. 482)Grant's list matches (69), except that it leaves out wh-islands. Two cautions apply. The clitic test needs an enclitic that attaches to the first constituent. And the fixed order Rudin means is an order by grammatical function. Both cautions matter for Navajo (§6)
“Superiority is Attract Closest”Grant's note: “Superiority is Attract Closest on the initial Agree step with C”Rudin derives the order from Comp-indexing by the head of SpecCP plus a split ECP and an LF binding condition ((65)–(68), pp. 477, 482–483), not from Attract ClosestA later restatement, not Rudin's. It is not used below
Wh-clustering (Grewendorf)“Whether a moved wh can itself host further whs”; “feature-based implementation of the [+MFS] cluster effect”Abstract only: multiple fronting “consists of moving a single wh-cluster to [Spec, CP]”; “wh-elements can act as landing sites for wh-movement due to morphological properties of wh-words”The Merge/Agree wording in Grant's note (“an already-moved wh … can serve as a further landing site”) is closer to Grewendorf's mechanism than to Rudin's. In Rudin, later whs adjoin to SpecCP and no cluster moves. Both are kept, under separate names
Multiple Agree“Whether one Probe can Agree with multiple Goals in a single step.” Page MA-6: one probe Agrees with ρA (δ, φ) and ρX (φ)(7), pp. 69–70: “MULTIPLE AGREE … with a single probe is a single simultaneous syntactic operation; AGREE applies to all the matched goals at the same derivational point.” The probe is “[+multiple]” and keeps matching “until the probe locates all the matching goals within an ‘accessible’ domain” (p. 70). Match: “Matching is feature identity”; “Locality reduces to ‘closest c-command’” ((2), p. 68). n. 12 (p. 79): “There exists no language that shows … multiple agreement on the side of probe/head”; “It is a universal fact that a closer goal feature determines agreement.” Icelandic: with a closer dative goal the agreement on T is “default 3rd person singular” (p. 79; (31)–(33), p. 78)Grant's one-line definition is right. The page's MA-6 candidate is not Hiraiwa's operation. It mixes two features (δ and φ), and its result shows on the probe side for both goals, which n. 12 says no language does. MA-6′ renames it
Feature inheritance“Whether φ-features on C are inherited by T.” Page MA-3: Qual “passes [uphi] to … M/S and keeps [udelta]”“Agree and Tense features are inherited from C, the phase head” (pp. 143–144). It goes to “the LI selected by C (namely T)” (p. 144). “C has two probes: the edge feature EF … and an Agree-feature (φ-features)” (p. 148); v* passes its Agree feature to V (p. 148). Obligatory or optional: “unsettled” (p. 149). When φ shows at T without tense, it is “just a morphological effect of agreement” (p. 144). EF may be inherited too (p. 157, tentative)Chomsky passes the Agree feature as a whole. What the phase head keeps is EF, which drives Merge, not an Agree probe. MA-3 as written (keep [uδ]) is an extension, not his model. MA-3′ states both versions. Inheritance goes only to the head the phase head selects, which gives a new prediction (T41a)
Edge Feature / EPP“Whether a given head (T, v, C…) has an Edge Feature triggering Spec Merge”Every lexical item has EF: “an LI has a feature that permits it to be merged. Call this the edge feature” (p. 139). “IM should be driven only by phase heads” (p. 143). Raising to Spec-T is “derivative, via inheritance” (p. 144). EF is “indiscriminate: it can seek any goal in its domain” (p. 151). A position reached by EF is an A′-position (p. 150). EPP restated: “If nothing is raised, then the inherited edge feature of T must be satisfied by EM, necessarily of an expletive since no argument role can be assigned”, and with “no accessible NOM, then T will have default morphology” (p. 157)In Chomsky 2008 what varies is not whether a head has EF, since every item has one. What varies is whether IM to it is possible (phase heads, or inherited). The wording in Grant's note matches the older EPP-feature idea (Chomsky 2000/2001, not opened). The p. 157 passage is a direct model for the ‘start to’ placeholder and default (MA7′, MA5′)
Phasehood“Which heads count as phases (barriers to Agree and movement)”. Page: D1 and the PP are phase-likePhases are “CP and v*P”; v* is “the functional head associated with full argument structure, transitive and experiencer constructions”, one of several choices for v (p. 143). TP is not a phase; DP might be, “put aside” (p. 143). “Probe into an earlier phase will almost always be blocked by intervention effects” and “It may be … that PIC holds only for the mappings to the interface” (p. 143). “v typically permits both long-distance agreement and raising, v* does not” (p. 156). “In a probe-goal relation, the goal can be spelled out only in situ (under long-distance Agree) or at the probe (under internal Merge)”, with “passive/unaccusative in situ or with movement” as the standard illustration (p. 155)Grant's wording is right. PP is not on Chomsky's list, so MA-5 is our extension, and MA-5′ adds a non-phase alternative. The v/v* split settles part of T40g (MA1′, MA9′)

3. Rules MA-0′ to MA-6′ (ours; all HYPOTHESIS unless marked)

MA-0' SEPARATE   Merge(X, Y) = {X, Y}. EM if Y is not part of X; IM (movement, a copy) if
                 Y is part of X (Chomsky 2008 p. 140). Agree(P, G): P's unvalued features
                 are valued by the closest matching G that P c-commands (Match = feature
                 identity, locality = closest c-command: Hiraiwa (1), (2)).
                 CLASSIFYING AN EXPONENT e AT HEAD H:
                  (i)  Agree   if e spells only features that H probes for (agreement
                               morphology: "a morphological effect of agreement", p. 144);
                  (ii) IM      if e spells features of a goal that H does not probe for,
                               or the goal's own category (the goal "spelled out ... at the
                               probe (under internal Merge)", p. 155);
                  (iii) EM     if e spells an element with no source in the structure
                               (a placeholder / expletive, p. 157).
                 Replaces MA-0's test "pronounced away from where its role puts it",
                 which would wrongly class PORT (subject phi on M/S) as Merge.
MA-1' AGREE-SITES Probes in D1: M/S (derivatively, by inheritance from Qual: MA-3'), P (its
                 own pronoun), and, only if a voice head exists, a voice probe (else the
                 yi-/bi-/0 choice is a spelling rule on rho_X: MA-6'). M/S's probe stops at
                 the edge of a phasal v*P, so in a transitive it reaches only Spec,v*.
                 In an unaccusative v is not phasal (p. 143), so M/S reaches the low slot
                 directly (= U-2, IN-4 PORT-CLOSEST = Hiraiwa's (2c) closest c-command).
                 IM in D1 is driven only by a phase head's EF (p. 143): Qual's EF, or v*'s
                 EF (IA-1*, which then lands in an A'-position, outer Spec,v*: p. 150).
MA-2' EDGE-SITES (a) The bumped PP (IN-5'): Merge, either EM of the PP high (IN-5' as
                 written) or IM by the EF of the Qual-layer INCH (IN-0: n, ii are Qual-layer
                 heads). Merge either way.
                 (b) The leftover delta (SH-4): Agree (MA-3a) or IM (MA-3b). OPEN.
                 (c) The placeholder rho_D (IN-9): EM of an expletive that satisfies the EF
                 of the Qual-layer INCH when nothing below v can (p. 157). Since Qual is
                 D1's phase head (MA-3'), this EF is the phase head's own: no inheritance.
MA-3' INHERIT    Qual = the phase head of D1. It passes its Agree feature [uphi] to the
                 head it SELECTS, M/S (p. 144: "the LI selected by C (namely T)").
                 MA-3a PARTIAL-AGREE: Qual keeps a [udelta] Agree probe; the delta exponent
                       is agreement morphology on Qual (Agree). Not in Chomsky (he passes
                       the Agree feature whole): an extension.
                 MA-3b EF-RAISE: Qual keeps EF (p. 148); EF raises the delta-bearing part of
                       rho_A from Spec,v* (the edge of v*P, accessible) to Qual (IM). The
                       landing site is an A'-position (p. 150). Needs delta to be a separate
                       syntactic object (SH-4 already pronounces it "as its own element").
                 Both: the phi-passing head must be the head that selects M/S. If DETR and a
                 separate Qual are both present (DETR > Qual > M/S), the phase head
                 that passes phi is Qual, not DETR (T41a).
MA-4' NO-ADJOIN  No word-internal position takes a second element ADJOINED to its occupant
                 (Rudin's [+MFS] needs adjunction to a filled specifier, pp. 480-481). A
                 second candidate goes to a different position (as Rudin's [-MFS] extras
                 go to IP, (71b)), here a HIGHER one (Position I, IN-5'), or fuses
                 (' + ' -> ', HMP n. 4). The one zone with several adjoined elements (the
                 disjuncts) shows Rudin's [-MFS] clitic pattern (Hale 2003 n. 12; §6).
MA-5' PP-OPAQUE  M/S's probe never values from a slot inside a PP (IN-3). Two sources:
                 MA-5a PHASE: PP is a phase (our extension; not on Chomsky's list, p. 143).
                 MA-5b INACTIVE: P has already Agreed with its object (P's own pronoun),
                       so the object is inactive (the inactivity condition as
                       restated on p. 150; Hiraiwa (3)); a closer inactive
                       goal also blocks lower goals (Hiraiwa (9)) and the probe shows
                       default morphology (Hiraiwa pp. 78-79; Chomsky p. 157).
                 They differ only if an active goal lies BELOW the PP (5a: reachable;
                 5b: blocked, default). No such form on the site (T41c).
MA-6' TWO-GOAL   (Narrowed.) Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree is excluded for the object
                 exponent: it needs one matched feature (Match = identity) and shows only
                 the closer goal on the probe (n. 12). The exponent reads rho_X's phi AND
                 rho_A's delta. So it is either (a) SH-6, a spelling rule on rho_X that
                 reads rho_A in D1 (favoured: under SH-4 rho_X is pronounced on itself, so
                 no probe is needed), or (b) a non-Hiraiwa two-goal mechanism (none opened),
                 which would also be a counterexample to n. 12.

Update 2026-10-20, 4:46am. MA-2′(c) is superseded by EP-2, which puts the placeholder at PINCH, a non-phase head; MA-2′(a)'s bump is Move to the same position. MA-1′ now has two versions (PIC1/PIC2, EP-6). MA-5b = EP-5, with a cost. MA-3a requires δ ∉ φ (EP-7). MA-3′'s selection condition, MA-4′ and MA-6′ are unchanged; MA-6′ also gains MI p. 124 as a source.

4. What changed, rule by rule

RuleBefore (1:52pm)AfterWhy
MA-0Merge = pronounced away from its role position, or role-lessMA-0′: three-way test on exponents (Agree / IM / EM)The old test would class PORT as Merge (Chomsky p. 144, p. 155)
MA-1Probes: M/S, P, the voice positionMA-1′: M/S derivative; the v*P edge limits it; unaccusative v not phasal; IM only by phase-head EFChomsky pp. 143, 148, 150, 156
MA-2Three Merge sites (a, b, c)MA-2′: (a), (c) Merge; (b) OPENMA-3′ has two Chomsky-compatible readings with the same strings
MA-3Qual keeps [uδ]MA-3a (extension) vs MA-3b (Chomsky's EF), plus a selection conditionChomsky passes the Agree feature whole and keeps EF (pp. 144, 148)
MA-4A position holds one exponent (two positions tested)MA-4′: no position takes an adjoined second element; the disjunct zone shows the [−MFS] clitic patternRudin pp. 461–466, 480–481
MA-5PP is a phaseMA-5a (phase, our extension) vs MA-5b (inactive goal)PP is not in Chomsky's list (p. 143); activity (p. 150; Hiraiwa (3), (9))
MA-6Multiple Agree vs contextual allomorphy, OPENMA-6′: Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree excluded; SH-6 favoured; OPEN only against a non-Hiraiwa mechanismHiraiwa (2), (7), n. 12

5. Derivations re-run (MA1′–MA10′)

Each derivation is the Merge/Agree page's derivation with the revised rules. Steps are labelled by rule set: Σ role schema, A word (D1), B clause (D2). Each step names its operation: EM, IM, Agree or Spell-out.

MA1′. Hale 2001 (24a) shidoołhosh ‘He/She will tickle me’ (as MA1, SD1)

  1. Σ Σ(√TICKLE) = {ρA, ρX}: ρA has Proto-Agent entailments in the action (causation, sentience), ρX Proto-Patient ones; φ(ρA) = 3, no δ; φ(ρX) = 1sg.
  2. A EM: V ghosh + ρX (Comp,V); v* ł (transitive, so a phase head, p. 143); ρA in Spec,v* (VPISH; EM to v*'s specifier satisfies v*'s EF, p. 144, n. 32).
  3. A EM: M/S; Qual d. Inheritance (MA-3′): Qual passes [uφ] to M/S, the head it selects.
  4. A Agree (MA-1′): M/S probes. The v*P complement (VP) is behind the phase edge, so ρX is not a candidate. ρA at the edge is the closest goal, so φ = 3 → w. No IM.
  5. A Spell-out D1: sh ⌢ d ⌢ w ⌢ ł ⌢ ghosh ✓ (Hale's segment line).
  6. Change from MA1: the reason M/S never takes the object's φ is now Chomsky's v*P phase, not a stipulation. Same string.

MA2′. Hale 2001 (22b) shiʼdooʼniid ‘I was told (lit. someone told me)’: two readings of the split subject (as MA2, SD4)

  1. Σ ρA = ⟨φ = 3 (zero), δ = INDF⟩; ρX = 1sg.
  2. A EM: V niid + ρX; v d; ρA in Spec,v; M/S (w); Qual d.
  3. A Inheritance: Qual → M/S [uφ]. Agree M/S ⟶ ρA: φ = 3 (zero).
  4. A Reading MA-3a: Qual's kept [uδ] probe Agrees with ρA (closest goal): δ = INDF, spelled ’ on Qual as agreement morphology. Reading MA-3b: Qual's EF IMs the δ-part of ρA from Spec,v (an edge, so accessible) to Qual, an A′-position.
  5. A Spell-out D1 (both readings): sh ⌢ ’ ⌢ d ⌢ w ⌢ d ⌢ niid ✓.
  6. Classification: Agree (3a) or IM (3b); OPEN. MA2 called this “a word-internal Merge site (MA-2b)”. That is now one of two readings.

MA3′. Willie (23b) jishxash ‘That person bit it’ vs p. 129 ʼashkii yishxash ‘The boy bit it’: Hiraiwa's test (as MA3, SD6)

  1. Σ {ρA, ρX}; φ(ρX) = 3. jishxash: ρA = ⟨3 (zero), δ = 4⟩; ʼashkii yishxash: ρA = ⟨3, no δ⟩.
  2. A EM, inheritance, Agree M/S ⟶ ρA as MA1′; for jishxash, MA2′ step 4 (δ = 4 at Qual, either reading).
  3. A Hiraiwa's Multiple Agree tried: a [+multiple] probe would match goals bearing one feature type ((2a) “feature identity”). The exponent depends on ρX's φ (only a third-person object alternates) and on ρA's δ (zero under δ = 4). Those are two different features. And on Hiraiwa's own account the probe's morphology should show only the closer goal (n. 12), which here is ρA in Spec,v. ✗ Not his operation.
  4. A MA-6′ (a), SH-6: ρX is pronounced on itself (a non-head, SH-4), and its third-person exponent is y- if a δ-less third person c-commands it in D1, zero if that slot has δ = 4. No probe is involved.
  5. A Spell-out D1: j ⌢ … ⌢ shxash; yi ⌢ … ⌢ shxash ✓ (not segmented further).
  6. B ʼashkii links to ρA in D2 and cannot change the D1 choice (WF-5).
  7. Result: MA-6 narrows. The yi-/zero choice is a spelling fact unless some mechanism other than Hiraiwa's is found. T40d's test (an object that is not third person whose exponent still varies with the subject's δ) now separates only SH-6 from that unnamed mechanism.

MA4′. W&J (50b) dibé łį́į́ʼ bitah yíghááh: P's own Agree, and IA-1* as v*'s edge feature (as MA4)

  1. Σ ρA (the one who goes), ρX = P's object; both 3; inverse: ρX [top], ρA [foc].
  2. A EM P -tah + ρX. Agree inside PP: P values its own pronoun from ρX. Under IA-3 ρX carries [top], so the exponent is b- → bitah. ρX is now inactive (MA-5b).
  3. A EM PP inside VP; v; ρA in Spec,v; M/S; Qual. Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (ρX is unavailable on either MA-5a or MA-5b).
  4. A IA-1* branch, restated: EF of a phase head is “indiscriminate” and lands its goal in an A′-position (pp. 150–151). If the topic slot moves, the mover is v*'s EF (if ‘go’ has a v*; Chomsky's v* is for transitive and experiencer verbs, p. 143, so a one-participant motion verb may have no phasal v at all) or Qual's EF. Chomsky adds that a raised phrase “is identified as a topic by the final position it reaches” (p. 151). That fits IA-1*'s topic slot. Inactivity (step 2) does not stop EF, because EF is not Agree. So IA-1* no longer needs the PP-edge step (i) of MA4.
  5. A Spell-out D1: bitah ⌢ yíghááh.
  6. B łį́į́ʼ → [foc] = ρA; dibé → [top] = ρX; D2: dibé ⌢ łį́į́ʼ ⌢ [bitah yíghááh] ✓.
  7. Result: IA-3 (no movement) is still cheaper. IA-1* is now a coherent EF movement in Chomsky's terms, but the strings are the same, so it is not supported over IA-3.

MA5′. HMP (10a) shináʼniidlóóh ‘I start to get cold (about dawn)’: default agreement from an inactive or hidden goal (as MA5, HD2)

  1. Σ {ρ1}, a change-of-state (Proto-Patient) participant, first-merged in Spec,V; φ = 1sg.
  2. A EM: V dlóóh, ρ1; REP ná; INCH's thematic ’ (ρI) in the object position; Qual-layer heads n, ii (IN-0).
  3. A MA-4′: ρ1 does not adjoin to the filled object position. Merge (MA-2′ a): [PP ρ1 PINCH] as the highest V-level non-head, above ná. P's own Agree values the PP's pronoun from ρ1 (1sg → shi).
  4. A EM v d (unaccusative, so not phasal), M/S; inheritance Qual → M/S. Agree: M/S finds no active goal. Spec,v is empty, ρ1 is inside the PP (MA-5a hidden / MA-5b inactive), and ρI is a thematic object. → default (IN-7 (D); HMP: the position is “entirely empty … as it is regularly in persons other than first or second”; Chomsky p. 157: “default morphology”; Hiraiwa's Icelandic default 3sg, pp. 78–79).
  5. A Spell-out D1: shi ⌢ ná ⌢ ʼnii ⌢ (M Ø) ⌢ d ⌢ dlóóh ✓ (alignment the site's; HMP do not segment (10a)).
  6. Change: the default now has the same shape as a sourced general mechanism (agreement failing on an inactive or hidden goal). Same string.

MA6′. HMP n. 4 sodiʼniiszin ‘I started to pray’: fusion is not adjunction (as MA6, HD6)

  1. Σ theme so=d-l-zin; ρA = 1sg in Spec,v; nothing below v → ρD (IN-9 (c)).
  2. A MA-4′: Position I is held by so. The candidate neither adjoins to it nor moves there. It stays and fuses with ρI: ’ + ’ → ’ (HMP: “hypothetically at least”).
  3. A Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (1sg). Spell-out: so ⌢ di ⌢ ’ ⌢ nii ⌢ … ⌢ zin ✓.
  4. Grewendorf's cluster (abstract): an element “act[s] as [a] landing site … due to morphological properties”. Here two identical ’ elements merge into one exponent instead of one hosting the other. That is the opposite of a cluster. HYPOTHESIS.

MA7′. HMP (16a) ʼiʼniichííl ‘it started to snow’ and (7b) ʼawééʼ ʼináʼniichah ‘the baby starts to cry’: Chomsky's expletive EM (as MA7, HD3, HD7)

  1. Σ ‘snow’: no participant. ‘cry’: ρA (sentient, atelic) in Spec,v only.
  2. A EM: V; v; (‘cry’) ρA in Spec,v; M/S; Qual-layer INCH (n, ii) with its requirement IN-8 (“must always be preceded by overt object agreement morphology”, HMP), read as INCH's EF.
  3. A Nothing below v can be raised to satisfy it (no slot there; ρA in Spec,v never satisfies INCH, HMP). → EM of an expletive: a fresh role-less ρD ⟨E none, φ 3, δ INDF⟩. Chomsky p. 157: EF “must be satisfied by EM, necessarily of an expletive since no argument role can be assigned”.
  4. A Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (‘cry’: 3rd, Ø). ‘snow’: no goal → default.
  5. A Spell-out: ‘cry’ ʼi ⌢ ná ⌢ ʼnii ⌢ … chah ✓; ‘snow’ ʼi ⌢ ʼnii ⌢ … chííl ✓ (not segmented further than HMP).
  6. B ʼawééʼ links to ρA, not to ρD (ρD has no role in the action to match).
  7. Result: SOURCED mechanism (Chomsky) + SOURCED pattern (HMP); the match between them is HYPOTHESIS. One mismatch: Chomsky's case is an inherited EF on T, a non-phase head. Here INCH is in the Qual layer, the phase head's own layer, so no inheritance is needed (MA-2′ c).

MA8′. Willie (64a) dabiiłtsą́ ‘They/he (was)were seen by them/*him’: da- is not covered by either original (as MA8, K5)

  1. Σ ρA plural (W&J gloss PL-3ACC-3NOM-saw); ρX 3; inverse.
  2. A EM; inheritance; Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (φ incl. plural).
  3. A Option e4 checked: da- copies number from M/S. In Chomsky, features pass only from a phase head to the head it selects (p. 144), and Agree targets a goal with features of its own. A disjunct copying an already-valued feature from M/S is neither. Option e2 (da- probes ρA directly): ρA in Spec,v* is at the phase edge and is the closest φ-goal, so Hiraiwa's locality (2c) allows it.
  4. A Spell-out D1: da ⌢ b ⌢ heads → dabiiłtsą́ ✓.
  5. Result: e2 needs nothing beyond standard Agree. e4 needs a head-to-head mechanism that neither original provides. That is a theory-internal lean to e2, not data (T41g).

MA9′. Hale 2001 (22c) hodildóóh ‘It (e.g., cloud) starts to drift’: U-1 loses its trigger (as MA9, SD5)

  1. Σ ρ1 = ⟨φ = 3 (zero), δ = AREAL⟩; start position unknown (SH-8).
  2. A U-1 (IM of ρ1 from Spec,V to Spec,v): in Chomsky only phase heads drive IM (p. 143), and the v of a one-participant verb whose participant starts low is not v*, so nothing triggers this step. Chomsky's own raising for unaccusatives goes to Spec-T by inheritance (p. 149, (11)), which here would be Spec,M/S, not Spec,v. So U-1 as written has no trigger.
  3. A U-2 (Agree only): M/S's probe reaches ρ1 directly because v is not phasal (“passive/unaccusative in situ”, p. 155; “v typically permits both long-distance agreement and raising”, p. 156). φ = 3 (zero).
  4. A δ = AREAL: MA-3a (Agree on Qual) or MA-3b (IM by Qual's EF). Either way it is pronounced on Qual: [hw + d]. Spell-out: hw ⌢ d ⌢ Ø ⌢ l ⌢ dóóh ✓.
  5. Result: U-2 is now favoured on two independent grounds, economy (as before) and Chomsky's architecture. It is still not favoured on data: no form separates U-1 from U-2 (T40e stays OPEN).

MA10′ (new). Willie (31f) hojishxash ‘That person bit that person’ (p. 129): two deictics, and only the subject's goes up (as SD7)

  1. Σ ρA = ⟨3 (zero), δ = 4⟩ (the biter); ρX = ⟨3 (zero), δ = 4⟩ (the one bitten).
  2. A EM: V + ρX (Comp,V); v*; ρA in Spec,v*; M/S; Qual; inheritance; Agree M/S ⟶ ρA (φ = 3, zero).
  3. A MA-3a: Qual's [uδ] Agrees with the closest δ-goal, which is ρA at the v*P edge. ρX is farther away and, in any case, inside the phase. MA-3b: Qual's EF is indiscriminate (p. 151) but can only see the v*P edge (PIC), so it reaches ρA's δ and not ρX's.
  4. A ρX's φ is taken by no head, so SH-5 keeps its whole bundle in one object exponent ho.
  5. A Spell-out D1: ho (object, a non-head, C1 first) ⌢ ji (subject δ at the top head) ⌢ … shxash ✓ (Willie gives no segmentation; the alignment is the site's, as in SD7).
  6. Result: both readings derive the order. The form shows why SH-5's “only a subject has a separate deictic position” follows from Chomsky's phase edge. It does not separate MA-3a from MA-3b.

The selection condition and Kibrik (8a) ʼá-zh-dí-l-zhééh (as SD8)

SOURCED Chomsky: inheritance is “by the LI selected by C (namely T)” (p. 144). HYPOTHESIS So the head that hands φ to M/S must be the head right above M/S. In Kibrik (8a) DETR dí is the only head above M/S (no separate qualifier in the segmentation), so DETR is both the top head and the selector: zh ⌢ dí ✓. SH-4 (“the highest nuclear head”) and MA-3′ (“the head that selects M/S”) agree on every form on the site. They come apart only in a word that has a DETR and a separate qualifier above M/S, together with a deictic subject. SH-4 predicts δ ⌢ DETR ⌢ Qual … and MA-3′ predicts DETR ⌢ δ ⌢ Qual … (schematic only; no such form has been opened: T41a). This answers T40c's “is the phase head DETR?” conditionally. Under Chomsky's selection condition it is DETR only when nothing intervenes between DETR and M/S.

6. Rudin's diagnostics applied to the word

Rudin's diagnostic ((69), p. 478; clitics pp. 461–466)Navajo word-internal analogueWhat the sources showReading
Can a filled specifier take an adjoined second element? (pp. 480–481)The object position under INCH; Position I with so-No. The object goes elsewhere (HMP n. 2; (10a)) or fuses (n. 4)HYPOTHESIS [−MFS]-like (MA-4′)
Where do the extra elements go? ([−MFS]: “in or adjoined to IP”, (71b))The bumped PPHigher, to Position I (HMP n. 2)HYPOTHESIS same logic (a different position), opposite direction (up, not down)
Clitic right after the first element ([−MFS] +, p. 461; needs “encliticization to the first constituent”, p. 463)Polar interrogative enclitic in a word with a disjunct preverbHale 2003 n. 12: the preverb ka “can be separated from the rest of the verb by the polar interrogative enclitic” (forms in a broken font, not reproduced)HYPOTHESIS [−MFS]-like on Rudin's decisive test. Two caveats. Whether ka was the first of several disjuncts cannot be seen. Whether the enclitic attaches to the first constituent in Rudin's sense is not shown (T41f)
Fixed order ([+MFS]: “restricted at least to subject > nonsubject”, p. 475)Fixed order of disjunct prefixes by class and height (C2)Fixed, but by morpheme class (preverb, iterative, plural), not by grammatical functionHYPOTHESIS not Rudin's kind of order: counts for neither type (changed from the 1:52pm table, which counted it as a property)
Parentheticals/adverbs after the first element ([−MFS] +)Material between disjunctsOnly the enclitic of n. 12 is knownOPEN
Multiple extraction; wh-island violations ([+MFS] +)—No word-internal analogue: prefixes are not extractedNot applicable

HYPOTHESIS Summary. On the diagnostics that can be applied, the Navajo word patterns with Rudin's [−MFS] type. The one point that once looked [+MFS]-like, the fixed order, turns out not to be the kind of order Rudin's diagnostic is about. The 1:52pm verdict on the disjunct zone (“OPEN, leaning not a cluster”) becomes “HYPOTHESIS: [−MFS]-like on the one applicable decisive test”, with T41f as the check.

Update 2026-10-20, 12:46pm (T41f). Caveat 2 of the clitic row is answered yes: -ísh is a first-constituent enclitic. Caveat 1 is moot, because ka is outside the verb word. The row's verdict is now OPEN (not testable with this enclitic if EN-1′ holds), and the summary's “[−MFS]-like on the one applicable decisive test” is withdrawn. See where the yes/no enclitic -ísh can go, §7.

SideGets rightMisses or costs
Grant's typology noteAll six definitions are accurate at the level of a one-line summary. The [±MFS] diagnostics match Rudin's table (69). It places Multiple Agree, inheritance, EF and phases at the right levelIt leaves out wh-islands. It states “clitics after the whole group” without Rudin's own caveat (inconclusive, p. 466). It describes [+MFS] in Grewendorf's terms (“a moved wh hosts further whs”), not Rudin's (adjunction to SpecCP). “Whether a head has an EF” is pre-2008 wording. The “Attract Closest” account of Superiority is not Rudin's
The Merge/Agree page (1:52pm)Agree inside, Merge at edges. The [−MFS]-like verdict. The EPP reading of the placeholder (now matched by Chomsky p. 157). Its decision to leave Multiple Agree OPEN, now narrowedMA-0's test misclassifies agreement. MA-3 is not Chomsky's version. The δ site was over-confidently called Merge. The voice exponent was called a Multiple Agree candidate, which Hiraiwa's definition excludes. The PP was called a phase without saying that this is our extension. The disjunct order was counted as a Rudin property
Chomsky 2008 applied to Navajov vs v* gives U-2 and SH-5 without stipulation. Phase-head EF gives the placeholder and the bump. Inheritance gives the split subjectIt says nothing about a phase inside a word, or about a P-phase. It does not decide MA-3a vs MA-3b. Its EF moves phrases, not single features, so MA-3b needs δ to be a separate object
Hiraiwa 2001 applied to NavajoClosest c-command states PORT-CLOSEST exactly. Default agreement under an inactive goal fits the ‘start to’ defaultMultiple Agree has no Navajo instance on the site

8. Grant's frame

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Word-internal Merge or Agree sites. After the check, Agree sites inside the word are firmer, since each now matches a definition in the originals (M/S by inheritance, P's own Agree, default under an inactive goal). Two Merge sites are certain: the bumped object (Merge in either reading) and the placeholder (EM of an expletive). The deictic is OPEN between the two operations. Merge builds structure; Agree values features. The deictic case is exactly where the strings cannot tell which one applied.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Feature bundles and the weak thesis. Every probe on this page Agrees with a bundle ρ in D1, before any noun arrives (B). Chomsky's own formulation needs goals with features, not nouns. The expletive case (MA7′) is a slot with features and no role, and the noun ʼawééʼ cannot link to it. That supports the weak thesis (roles live on slots, nouns link later) and says nothing about the strong one.

HYPOTHESIS Dowty and theta vs event structure. Nothing in this check changes anyone's role in the action. Proto-Agent ρA starts in Spec,v(*), and a change-of-state Proto-Patient ρ1 starts low. INCH adds an onset to the event and moves no role. The event-structure layer and the theta roles stay compatible descriptions of the same participants.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE STRATA (theta roles first, then event-structure roles, then noun selection). Chomsky (p. 140) pairs EM with “generalized argument structure (θ-roles …)” and IM with “discourse-related properties”. On this page the role layer is all EM (Σ slots at their positions), and so is the event layer (INCH, its placeholder, the bumped PP). The only possible IM (MA-3b, the deictic) is discourse-related, and noun linking comes last in D2. The STRATA order fits that pairing. It does not separate STRATA from the adjunct view or the inside-the-clause view, because none of them predicts a different string here.

HYPOTHESIS The changeover from rule set A to rule set B. If Qual is the phase head of D1 (C-like, with M/S = T, Hale 2003 p. 10), then the word is a CP-like phase. In Chomsky's terms (p. 143), Transfer at the word's phase boundary is the point where rule set A's output is handed on. Rule set B then sees only the word's edge and exponents (“output, not derivation”, Merge/Agree page §11.2). That is a fit, not a test: where the word stops is still unsolved (Hale 2003 n. 12).

9. Tasks T41a–h

TaskWhat it needs
T41aSH-4 vs MA-3′ selection: a printed form with a DETR and a separate qualifier above M/S and a deictic (4th/indefinite/areal) subject. SH-4 predicts δ ⌢ DETR ⌢ Qual; MA-3′ predicts DETR ⌢ δ ⌢ Qual (schematic). Kibrik 2005, Young & Morgan
T41bMA-3a vs MA-3b (Agree vs EF-movement of the deictic): any A′-property of the top-edge deictic (e.g. scope or discourse effects that do not come from its person value), or a deictic of something other than the Spec,v slot appearing at the top
T41cMA-5a vs MA-5b (PP as phase vs inactive object): a word with an active goal below a PP that M/S could otherwise reach
T41dGrewendorf 2001 full text (abstract only so far): his diagnostics for cluster formation, to test MA6′'s fusion reading
T41eChomsky 2000, 2001 (the EPP-feature definitions behind the wording in Grant's note, and Match/Agree as Hiraiwa cites them)
T41fRudin's clitic test, refined from T40a: a legible form with two or more disjunct prefixes and the polar enclitic, plus a statement of whether that enclitic attaches to the first constituent (Hale 2003 n. 12, Platero p.c.; Young & Morgan)
T41gda-: is there any form where da- counts a plural that M/S does not spell (which would favour e2 over e4)? (joins T30, T10f)
T41hIs ‘go’ (W&J (50b)) built with a phasal v*? Chomsky ties v* to transitive and experiencer verbs (p. 143). For IA-1* this decides whose EF would move the topic slot

Update 2026-10-20, 4:46am. T41e answered and T41h partly answered on the 2000/2001 page (‘go’ is not v* by either definition). T41c is sharpened (EP-5 vs MA-5a; → T42c). New tasks T42a–h are there.

T40 statuses after this page: T40b answered (this page). T40c conditionally answered (§5, selection condition) → T41a. T40d narrowed (MA3′). T40e OPEN, with a second theory-internal ground for U-2. T40g partly answered: in Chomsky's model v*P is a phase and unaccusative vP is not, and every site fact fits. T40a refined as T41f. T40f, T40h, T40i, T40j are unchanged.

Changes made elsewhere

Update notes on Merge and Agree inside the word (lede, rules, §6, tasks). There is a new row on open questions (T41a–h), a sources section (added 2026-10-19, 8:46pm), and a home-page entry. No verb-dictionary entries changed and no new Navajo forms were added.