Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.
SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. The badge on our event-type and entailment assignments read “OURS”, which is not in the site’s label set; it now reads HYPOTHESIS. Navajo spellings printed with an ASCII apostrophe (for example in example sentences) now show the glottal stop as ʼ (U+02BC). No form, gloss or judgment changed.
Arguments: the theta frame
Transitive
Σ(√BITE, v) = {ρA, ρP}
Event typeachievement · punctual contact; affectedness of the bitten one not decided HYPOTHESIS Ours, from the source's English translation.
Looks forρA bitervol, sent, caus, mov, indepρP the one bittenaff, stat
Slot
Proto-role entailments (Dowty 1991 (27)/(28))
First-Merge site
Valued by (prefix / position)
Overt nominal links?
ρA biter
vol, sent, caus, mov, indepHYPOTHESIS
Spec,v (direct) / internal under bi-
3rd: no separate exponent printed; the sources gloss the whole word (3ACC-3NOM, 3.3) and it is not segmented here. 4th: jishxash (Willie: 3.4.bit, ‘That person bit it’).
Yes, as a linked adjunct (theta page C3): word order follows the topic rule (set B), not the slot's first-Merge site.
ρP the one bitten
aff, statHYPOTHESIS
Comp,V
3rd: Object exponent yi- (direct) / bi- (inverse) when both slots are 3rd person (Willie 1991 §3.3; W&J 2000). 1st: shishxash (1.3.bit). 4th: hashxash (4.3.bit). Both 4th: hojishxash (31f).
Yes, as a linked adjunct (theta page C3): word order follows the topic rule (set B), not the slot's first-Merge site. Printed examples with this value have no overt nominal for the slot.
Forms (as printed)
Form
Source's gloss / translation
Source
yishxash
3.3.bit
Willie 1991:87, 122
bishxash
INV3.3.bit
Willie 1991:87, 122
shishxash
1.3.bit
Willie 1991:123 (21)
hashxash
4.3.bit
Willie 1991:123 (22), 124 (23a)
jishxash
3.4.bit
Willie 1991:124 (23b)
hojishxash
‘That person bit that person.’
Willie 1991:129 (31f)
deishxash
PL-3-3-bit
Willie 1991:84 (67a)
dabishxash
INV3-3-bit (67b); INV3.3.bit (69)
Willie 1991:84–85 (67b), (69)
daʼashxash
PL.bit (with yitah ‘3.among’)
Willie 1991:85 (68)
bishxash-ę́ę
bit-REL (inverse)
Hale & Platero 1974:19–22 (38), (41), (46)
bishxash
‘was bitten by’
Hale & Platero 1974:22 (47)
Causative · inverse · fourth person
Inverse
SOURCED
With two 3rd persons and a lower-ranked agent, the inverse is required: *łééchąąʼí ’ashkii yishxash vs ’ashkii łééchąąʼí bishxash (Willie (20)). With no nominals, Willie ranks the readings: yishxash *‘it bit him’, bishxash *‘it was bitten by him’ ((72a.4), (72b.4)). →
Fourth person
SOURCED
A 4th-person patient takes the participant off the animacy scale, so the direct holds: łééchąąʼí hashxash ‘The dog bit that person’ (Willie (22)). Fourth person is ‘not involved in the animacy hierarchy’ (p. 122). →
Number (da-)
SOURCED
mąʼii tłʼízí deishxash ‘The coyotes bit the goat(s)’: the agent must be plural (67a). tłʼízí mąʼii dabishxash ‘The goats were bitten by the coyotes’: both plural (67b). ʼéidí tłʼízí mąʼii dabishxash ‘That goat there was bitten by the coyotes’ (69). For a singular biter: mąʼii tłʼízí yitahdaʼashxash (68). →
Causative
OPEN
Not yet sourced.
Examples
(1)
✓
ʼashkii
łééʼchąąʼí
yishxash
boy
dog
3.3.bit
‘The boy bit the dog.’
Willie 1991:122, (20a)
Roles
ρA ’ashkiiρP łééʼchąąʼíverb yishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(2)
*
łééʼchąąʼí
ʼashkii
yishxash
dog
boy
(The dog bit the boy.)
Willie 1991:122, (20b)
Roles
ρA łééʼchąąʼíρP ’ashkii
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(3)
✓
ʼashkii
łééʼchąąʼí
bishxash
boy
dog
INV3.3.bit
‘The boy was bitten by the dog.’
Willie 1991:122, (20c)
Roles
ρP ’ashkiiρA łééʼchąąʼíverb bishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(4)
✓
łééʼchąąʼí
shishxash
dog
1.3.bit
‘The dog bit me.’
Willie 1991:123, (21)
Roles
ρA łééʼchąąʼíverb shishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(5)
✓
łééʼchąąʼí
hashxash
dog
4.3.bit
‘The dog bit that person.’
Willie 1991:123, (22)
Roles
ρA łééʼchąąʼíverb hashxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(67a)
✓
mąʼii
tłʼízí
deishxash
coyote
goat
PL-3-3-bit
‘The coyotes bit the goat(s).’
Willie 1991:84, (67a)
Roles
ρA mąʼiiρP tłʼízíverb deishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(67b)
✓
tłʼízí
mąʼii
dabishxash
INV3-3-bit
‘The goats were bitten by the coyotes.’
Willie 1991:84, (67b)
Gloss as printed (no PL in the gloss line).
Roles
ρP tłʼízíρA mąʼiiverb dabishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(68)
✓
mąʼii
tłʼízí
yitah
daʼashxash
coyote
goat
3.among
PL.bit
‘The coyote (went among and) bit the goats.’
Willie 1991:85, (68)
Goats as object of the postposition yitah: our reading of the gloss line.
Roles
ρA mąʼiiObl tłʼízíObl yitahverb da’ashxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(69)
✓
ʼéidí
tłʼízí
mąʼii
dabishxash
DEM.
goat
coyote
INV3.3.bit
‘That goat there was bitten by the coyotes.’
Willie 1991:85, (69)
Roles
ρP tłʼízíρA mąʼiiverb dabishxash
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
Notes
Spelling as printed varies: łééʼchąąʼí (earlier pages) and łééchąąʼí (hi-res re-read of p. 122). Neither is repaired.