Where Young & Morgan put the indefinite ʼa-: in the listed prefix string of the base, not in the subject's person cell, at least for the ʼeʼe- verbs and the gas/wool pair on *Øjooł (T85e)
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. Apostrophe fixes only. Navajo glottal stops typed as ' or ’ (for example in prefix names like ʼa- and ʼeʼe-, or words like Awééʼ) now print as ʼ (U+02BC), and a build step no longer turns the closing quote of an English translation inside a Navajo row into a glottal stop (‘…the girls.’, not ‘…the girls.ʼ). No form, gloss or translation wording changed.
Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). Prefix order is restated as Grant’s hypothesis that headedness is fixed locally by Merge site, so the sublexical domain is linearized opposite to the phrasal domain and the prefixes are successive word-internal Merge and Agree sites (GRANT’S HYPOTHESIS, tested on the sourced template in §3.2; fit/misfit OPEN). A possible sublexical V-to-T is a separate, untested GRANT’S HYPOTHESIS (§3.3). Light d, used below, is withdrawn (Grant, 2026-11-14); light n is an OPEN structural question. The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Position-class template statements below describe the order of prefixes; they are not the derivation (§3). Status on the spine: see unified structure, §3. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.
2026-11-11 audit pass 3. A derivation step annotated “(VPISH)” now reads “(VPISH hyp.)”: VPISH names the hypothesis that the subject starts in Spec,vP; it is not a node. dP (the light-d phrase) on this page is a HYPOTHESIS label, not an established category. See the pass 3 report.
Local box file paths were removed from this page; files inside the repository are given by repo-relative path, and the source citation next to each removed path stays as the reference.
T85e asked whether the choice between the 3i ʼa- and the plain third person (Ø) belongs to Y&M's verb entries. If it does, the light determiner of Grant's proposal is selected by the base, and we can ask where that selection is checked. In Y&M's own model paradigm for the ʼeʼe- prefix class (p. 364), a 3i subject has its own perfective row, ʼoʼoo-. Eleven Ø-classifier ʼeʼe- verbs have no first- or second-person subject: gas, the sun, unspecified vehicles, a household move, a vine, a splinter. In Y&M's example sentences, every one of them has its perfective in ʼiʼíí-, which is the plain third-person row, and none uses ʼoʼoo-. Y&M still say that the ʼa- of ʼeʼejooł "represent[s] the substance functioning as the subject" (p. 362 def 8). So the 3i of these verbs is the single ʼa- already inside the listed prefix ʼeʼe-, and the subject's person cell is the plain third person. SOURCED (forms) / HYPOTHESIS (analysis). Under analysis D of Light determiners, this listing can be checked at the step where the verb merges with its argument. Under analysis C it cannot.
Correction 2026-11-03: LD-3's inference is withdrawn and LD-9 is downgraded for the intransitive bases. Y&M's ʼa-((1)) table (p. 478) gives the same forms as its 3i row, and Y&M cite p. 364 only for the transitive ʼeʼe- bases. See two-tables (T88b).
On this page: 1 Question · 2 Sources · 3 Rules first · 4 The data · 5 Examples · 6 Answer to T85e (and part of T85d) · 7 Rulesets A and B · 8 Derivations · 9 Locality: D, C and A · 10 Fidelity notes · 11 Open questions
Notation is the same as on hang-subject. A = the word level (prefixal, left-headed). B = the clause level (right-headed). 3i = Y&M's indefinite ʼa-. Ø = the ordinary third person. d = Grant's light determiner (GRANT'S CONJECTURE, assessed here as HYPOTHESIS). [sort] is the class of thing a base takes. NC = non-compact or gaseous matter (Y&M's stem gloss for *Øjooł). No Syntax · Semantics · Interface conventions file is in the repo or the context folder.
1. Question
The essay Light determiners lists T85e: "Is the 3i/Ø choice part of Y&M's theme entries?" Earlier pages found that the marker goes with the verb base (RW-13 on rain-fire-subject, HN-9 on hang-subject). That was a conclusion from distribution: one base, one marker. It did not show that Y&M's lexicon records the marker as part of the base. There are two ways the lexicon could treat it, and they come apart. (i) The 3i is a person value, one row of a paradigm like 1sg or 3a, available to any base that has the row. (ii) The 3i is part of the base's listed prefix string. T85e decides which, at least for the bases opened. That matters for the light-determiner proposal because it says where d is chosen (§9).
2. Sources
SOURCED Young, Robert W. & William Morgan, Sr. 1987. The Navajo Language: A Grammar and Colloquial Dictionary, revised edition. Albuquerque: UNM Press. Read through the free University of Colorado searchable edition (verbs.colorado.edu/~mahu0110/ym/). Opened in this run:
- the model paradigm for the ʼeʼe- class, p. 364 (paradigm view reached from ʼeʼejooł);
- the model paradigm for na-((3)), p. 591 (reached from naʼanish, p. 549 def 24);
- all 65 entries that match
'e'e, including the prefix entry ʼeʼe-, p. 362 def 2; - the prefix entries ʼadi- (p. 21 def 6) and naʼa- (p. 548 def 6);
- the entries ʼadijooł (p. 16 def 15), naʼajooł (p. 548 def 11), naajooł (p. 576 def 6), yijooł (p. 760 def 11), ʼíjooł (p. 466 def 9), naʼanish (p. 549 def 24), bíníshchééh (p. 239 def 4) and ʼídlį́ (p. 465 def 21);
- definition searches for "optional", "omitted", "with or without" and "3i subj".
Saved on the box in [local working copy, not in the repository].
Already on the site and not re-opened: RW-13, HN-9, HN-13, GM-6, PX-11 and PX-11′. The four analyses A–D come from the essay.
3. Rules first
LD-1 PERSON ROWS. Y&M's model paradigms list the 3i as a person row next to 1, SOURCED (p. 364; p. 591)
2, 3, 3a. In the 'e'e- class (p. 364) the 3 and 3i rows have the same
form in every column but one. In the Ø/Ł-classifier perfective, row 3 is
'i'íí- and row 3i is 'o'oo-. In the D/L-classifier perfective, both rows
are 'o'oo-. In na-((3)) (p. 591) the rows are 3 naa-, 3o nei-, 3a nji-,
3i na'a-, 3s naha-.
LD-2 THE 'e'e- LEMMA. Y&M p. 362 def 2: "'e- = 'a-, Pos. Ib, away out of sight SOURCED (quote)
+ 'e- = 'a-, Pos. IV-V, 3i obj.-subj. pron., someone, something." So the
prefix lemma itself contains one 3i, in a position labelled IV-V (object
or subject).
LD-3 THE TEST CELL. The only cell of p. 364 that tells 3 from 3i is the SOURCED (p. 364; 11 entries, Table 1;
Ø/Ł perfective. Eleven Ø-classifier 'e'e- bases have no 1st- or 2nd- forms from Y&M's example sentences,
person subject (Table 1). In all 11 the perfective form in Y&M's example not the interface's guessed paradigms)
sentences begins 'i'íí- (row 3). None begins 'o'oo- (row 3i).
LD-4 Y&M CALL THAT 'a- THE SUBJECT. 'e'ejooł, p. 362 def 8: "'a-, Pos. IV-V is SOURCED (quotes)
the 3i pronoun ... Here it does represent the substance functioning as
the subject of the verb." 'e'enééh, p. 363 def 6: "Lit. someone indefinite
moves away with one." há'e'e'eeł, p. 405 def 16: "Lit.
something floats away after it with him." 'e'e'aah, p. 362 def 9: "something
roundish -- the sun -- moves away out of sight."
LD-5 SAME SLOT, OBJECT. In transitive 'e'e- bases, the same IV-V 'a- is the SOURCED (p. 364 def 3; p. 364 row 1)
object: 'e'eshjááh 'to plant, to put things (seeds) in the ground', 1sg
perfective 'i'ííjaa' (row 1, Ø/Ł column, also 'i'íí-).
LD-6 SEPARATE HEADWORDS ON ONE STEM. On *Øjooł, Y&M give the Ø and 3i bases as SOURCED (p. 548 defs 6, 11; p. 576 def 6;
separate headwords with separate prefix lemmas and disjoint item lists: p. 760 def 11; p. 466 def 9; p. 16 def 15;
naajooł, na-((2)), 'tuft of wool, tumbleweed', vs na'ajooł, na'a-((1)), p. 21 def 6)
'cloud, smoke, gas, fog'. The lemma na'a- (p. 548 def 6) is "na-, Pos. Ib
... + 'a-, Pos.IV-V, 3i obj.-subj.pron., someone, something". Likewise
yijooł (Ø, wool) vs 'íjooł ('a-((2)), rainstorm), and 'adijooł under the
lemma 'adi- = "'a-, Pos. V, 3i subj.pron., something + di-". For the 3i
bases, paradigm view says "A separate paradigm for this verb cannot be
found" (nid 458, 9107, 10161). Y&M state the condition in the entry
(p. 16 def 15): "when the subject is one of those entities listed above, it
is represented in the verb by a 3i subject pronoun 'a-".
LD-7 THE 'SOMEONE' 3i AS A CELL. Elsewhere the 'someone' 3i is a row of an SOURCED (p. 549 def 24; p. 239 def 4;
ordinary person paradigm, cross-referenced to the base: na'anish "(3i p. 465 def 21)
subject 'a-, someone. See naashnish, to work ...)"; bíníshchééh lists
"(bí'nílcheeh - 3i subject.)"; 'ídlį́ "(3i subject, someone. See nishłį́,
to be.)".
LD-8 NO OPTIONAL 3i. Y&M mark optional classifiers ("Ø or d- classifier SOURCED (searches, §2) / evidence from
optional", p. 232 defs 1, 2, 4) and optional modes, but no entry found silence only
marks a 3i as optional or omissible.
LD-9 T85e ANSWER. Yes, for the bases opened. In the 'e'e- class, the 3i that HYPOTHESIS (from LD-1–LD-6)
Y&M read as subject is the IV-V 'a- of the listed prefix 'e'e-, and the
subject's person cell is the plain row 3 (LD-3). On *Øjooł the 3i/Ø
choice is a choice between two headwords (LD-6). In both, the 3i is part
of what is listed, not a person value picked from a row.
LD-10 THE LINE IS NOT 'something' vs 'someone'. 'Someone' readings also use the HYPOTHESIS (LD-4, LD-7)
listed 'a- in the 'e'e- class (há'e'ebąąs 'a trip was made after water
by someone', 'e'enééh). In other classes the same reading is a paradigm
row (LD-7). Whether a 3i is listed or a cell depends on the prefix class
and the base, not on its meaning.
LD-11 ENTRY FORMAT under D. A base is ⟨stem, prefix string, c-selection⟩. For HYPOTHESIS (formal restatement)
'e'ejooł: ⟨*Øjooł, 'a(Ib)+'a(IV-V), [__ dP[d:'a, sort:NC]]⟩. For naajooł:
⟨*Øjooł, na-((2)), [__ dP[d:Ø, sort:tuft]]⟩. The listed d is the IV-V 'a-
of the prefix string. The marker is a function of base and sort together
(HN-9), and both are visible on the label of one sister, dP (§9).
LD-12 T85d, PART. No base opened takes both 3i and Ø with one noun. The *Øjooł SOURCED (LD-6, HN-6) / OPEN beyond
pairs have disjoint item lists. HN-6's same noun with both markers was these bases
across different bases.
LD-13 FOCUS 1. Under D, d is the one item that is merged by B (inside dP, head- HYPOTHESIS (D1–D4)
final) and spelled out by A (in prefix position IV-V). The noun is merged
and spelled out by B. The listing is stored in a word-level entry, but it
is checked at a clause-level Merge (V + dP). This refines HN-13 ("the word
is where the choice is made"): the word is where d is pronounced and where
the listing is stored. Under D the check happens one step earlier, at B.
LD-14 COST FOR D. One surface slot (IV-V) hosts the listed 'a- whether it is the HYPOTHESIS (LD-5)
subject (D1) or the object (D4). If d reaches the word by head movement,
the slot is not determined by where d starts. It is fixed by A's template.
This is the essay's §5(b) problem (prefix order) seen in one class.
4. The data
Table 1. Ø-classifier ʼeʼe- bases (prefix lemma ʼeʼe- or háʼeʼe-) with no first- or second-person subject. The perfective column gives the form as it appears in Y&M's example sentence for the entry.
| Base (p., def) | Y&M gloss (item) | Perfective in the example | p. 364 row it matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| ʼeʼejooł (362/8) | drift away (fog, smoke, cloud, gas, stench) | ʼiʼííjool | 3 (not 3i ʼoʼoo-) |
| ʼeʼeʼaah (362/10) | set (the sun), become evening | ʼiʼííʼą́ągo | 3 |
| ʼeʼebąąs (362/6) | bił --, ride away (unspecified wheeled vehicle) | ʼiʼííbą́ą́z | 3 |
| ʼeʼeʼeeł (362/14) | float away (an unspecified vehicle) | ʼiʼííʼéél | 3 |
| ʼeʼeghááh (362/7) | bił --, ride away (slow conveyance) | ʼiʼííyáá | 3 |
| ʼeʼemáás (363/5) | bił --, roll away (inside a globular object) | ʼiʼíímááz (printed without the initial ʼ) | 3 |
| ʼeʼenééh (363/6) | bił --, move away with household; "someone indefinite moves away with one" | ʼiʼíínáá, ʼiʼííná | 3 |
| ʼeʼetłʼóóh (365/8) | grow away (a vine) | ʼiʼíítłʼǫ́ | 3 |
| ʼeʼezhóósh (365/9) | baa --, get a splinter in one | ʼiʼíízhoozh | 3 |
| háʼeʼebąąs (405/15) | bił --, go away after (wheeled conveyance); "by someone" | háʼiʼííbą́ą́z | 3 |
| háʼeʼeʼeeł (405/16) | bił --, go away after it by boat | háʼiʼííʼééł | 3 |
Count: 11 of 11 match row 3, and 0 match row 3i. Not diagnostic, so left out: the D/L-classifier bases (ʼeʼelyeed → ʼoʼoolwod, 363/4; ʼeʼeʼnééh → ʼoʼooʼnaʼ, 362/15; háʼeʼeldlóósh, háʼeʼelyeed, háʼeʼetʼááh), because there rows 3 and 3i are both ʼoʼoo-. Also left out are the transitive bases with a first-person row (for example ʼeʼeshjááh, LD-5).
Table 2. The *Øjooł pairs (LD-6).
| Marker | Headword (p., def) | Prefix lemma | Items | Own paradigm page? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3i | naʼajooł (548/11) | naʼa-((1)) = na- + ʼa- 3i (548/6) | cloud, smoke, gas, fog | no ("cannot be found") |
| Ø | naajooł (576/6) | na-((2)) | tuft of wool, tumbleweed | "View paradigm" offered |
| 3i | ʼíjooł (466/9) | 'a-((2)) | rainstorm (níłtsą́) | no |
| Ø | yijooł (760/11) | Ø | wool | — |
| 3i | ʼadijooł (16/15) | ʼadi- = ʼa- Pos. V 3i subj. + di- (21/6) | gas, cloud, smoke, rain … | no |
5. Examples
The Leipzig lines segment only as far as Y&M's entries and the p. 364 table do. AWAY = Pos. Ib ʼa- 'away out of sight'. 'a = the IV-V 3i of the lemma. PFV.R3 = the perfective of p. 364 row 3. NC = non-compact matter. Glosses for words other than the verb come from Y&M's translations; they are ours.
| (L1) p. 362 def 8 | Kʼos jóhonaaʼeí yichʼą́ą́h ʼiʼííjool |
| cloud sun 3.in.front.of AWAY-'a-PFV.R3-move.NC | |
| 'a cloud moved in front of the sun, a cloud moved in blotting out the sun.' | |
| (L2) p. 405 def 15 | ʼAhbínídą́ą́ʼ shizhéʼé chizh bił háʼiʼííbą́ą́z |
| this.morning 1SG.POSS-father wood 3.with FOR-AWAY-'a-PFV.R3-move.wheeled | |
| 'my father went away after wood this morning (in a wagon).' | |
| (L3) p. 364 def 3 | Kóhootʼéédą́ą́ʼ kohgo shidáʼákʼehgi ʼałtso ʼiʼííjaaʼ |
| this.time.last.year thus 1SG.POSS-field.at all AWAY-'a-PFV.1SG-handle.PL | |
| 'by this time last year I had finished planting on my farm.' | |
| (L4) p. 548 def 11 | Sigháala bilid tʼahdii kóneʼé naʼajooł |
| cigar 3.POSS-smoke still in.here ABOUT-'a-move.NC(CI) | |
| 'some cigar smoke is still floating around in here.' | |
| (L5) p. 576 def 6 | Háíshąʼ beʼaghaaʼgo ʼakǫ́ǫ́ honibąąhgóó naajooł |
| who.Q 3.POSS-wool-SUB [near.the.fire] ABOUT-3-move.NC | |
| 'whose wool is it that's drifting (tumbling) about near the fire?' | |
In L1, L2 and L3 the verb has the same ʼiʼíí- shape. Y&M read its ʼa- as the subject in L1 and L2 and as the object 'things' in L3. The segmentation of bilid as possessed łid is ours, from the translation. In L5, ʼakǫ́ǫ́ honibąąhgóó is glossed as one unit from the translation.
6. Answer to T85e (and part of T85d)
HYPOTHESIS (data SOURCED). T85e: yes. For the bases opened, the 3i is part of what Y&M list. It is not a person value chosen from a paradigm row. The clearest case is the ʼeʼe- class. Y&M's own model paradigm gives a 3i subject a distinct perfective, ʼoʼoo-. Yet every Ø-classifier base whose subject Y&M describe as "something", "an unspecified vehicle" or "someone indefinite" has the row-3 perfective ʼiʼíí- (LD-3, Table 1). Y&M nonetheless say the ʼa- stands for the subject (LD-4). The only way to fit both statements is that the subject 3i of these verbs is the one ʼa- in the lemma ʼeʼe-, and the person cell is the plain third person (LD-9). On *Øjooł, the 3i and Ø versions are separate headwords with separate prefix lemmas and separate item lists (LD-6). The "listed" half of HN-9 is therefore a fact about Y&M's lexicon, not only about distribution.
HYPOTHESIS One refinement (LD-10). Listing does not separate the nature 3i ('something') from the human 3i ('someone'). In the ʼeʼe- class, both are the listed ʼa-. In other classes (naʼanish, ʼídlį́), 'someone' is a row of an ordinary paradigm. So there are two ways to get a 3i, a listed d and a d from a person cell, and the prefix class decides which one a base uses.
OPEN T85d, in part. No base opened takes both markers with the same noun (LD-12), and Y&M never mark a 3i as optional (LD-8). That is evidence from silence in a dictionary. It is not a judgment that the other combination is ungrammatical.
7. Rulesets A and B
| Step | Under D (kʼos … ʼiʼííjool, L1) | Under C (same sentence) |
|---|---|---|
| Noun + d | Merge [dP k'os d] B | d is not merged with the noun B (k'os at clause level) |
| Sort on d | Agree d ← k'os, [sort: NC], inside dP B | not yet available (no noun in the word) A |
| Base meets argument | V(*Øjooł, ʼeʼe-) + dP, c-selection checked on the sister's label B | V + d on the spine; the sort is unvalued A |
| d into the word | head movement (or post-syntactic attachment) to IV-V A | already there A |
| Person cell | row 3 (no 1/2 person) A | row 3 A |
| Spell-out | 'a(Ib) + 'a(IV-V) + PFV → ʼiʼíí- + jool A | the same A |
| Listing check | done at step 3 B | needs a later step: upward Agree or a spell-out filter B→A |
Focus 1 (LD-13). Under D, the line between A and B runs through the argument. d is built by B and pronounced by A. The noun is built and pronounced by B. Under C, d never belongs to B, and B's noun has to be matched to it later.
8. Derivations
D1 K'os jóhonaa'eí yich'ą́ą́h 'i'ííjool (L1), analysis D
Assumes the moving cloud is an internal argument (VPISH; unaccusativity not tested, T87a).
1 Merge [dP [NP k'os] d] ; d = 'a, [sort: _] B (head-final: noun left of d)
2 Agree d probes its complement: [sort: NC] from k'os B (inside dP; local)
3 Merge [VP dP V] ; V = *Øjooł in base ⟨'e'e-, __ dP[d:'a, sort:NC]⟩
c-selection is checked on the label of the sister: d:'a ✓ sort:NC ✓
B (head-final VP)
4 Merge v (Ø classifier, no agent) A (verb word begins)
5 Move d head-moves V → v (or attaches after syntax). It leaves k'os in dP.
This is movement out of a complement, as in incorporation, so the
essay's §5(a) problem (head movement out of a specifier) does not arise
here IF step 3 is right (T87a). B → A (the crossing)
6 Agree subject person cell: no 1/2 → row 3 (Ø) A
7 Spell 'a(Ib) + 'a(IV-V, = d) + PFV(Ø/Ł) → 'i'íí- ; + jool → 'i'ííjool
(p. 364 row 3, not row 3i 'o'oo-) A
8 Merge [PP jóhonaa'eí yich'ą́ą́h] left of the verb B
9 Move the remnant [dP k'os t_d] reaches clause-initial position
(how and where is OPEN, T87d) B
The noun is spelled out in B. d is spelled out in A. The listing was checked at step 3.
D2 The same sentence, analysis C (d is a Voice-like head on the spine)
1 Merge V = *Øjooł A
2 Merge d = 'a on the spine, [sort: _]; no noun in the derivation yet
A
3 Merge v (Ø) A
4 Spell 'i'ííjool (as D1 steps 6–7) A
5 Merge k'os at clause level; PP left of the verb B
6 ??? The base's [sort: NC] must now be checked against k'os. Two options:
(i) d Agrees upward/outward with k'os (non-local; the probe is in A and
the goal in B); or (ii) a filter at the interface pairs ⟨base, noun⟩ (= LINK,
PX-11′, plus a sort check). B → A (late)
C can state LD-11, but only as a look-back filter, not at Merge.
D3 L4 vs L5, analysis D: one stem, two listed bases
1 Merge [dP [NP sigháala bilid] d:'a] | [dP [NP be'aghaa'] d:Ø] B
2 Agree [sort: gas] | [sort: tuft] B
3 Merge V in ⟨na'a-((1)), __ dP['a, gas]⟩ ✓ | V in ⟨na-((2)), __ dP[Ø, tuft]⟩ ✓ B
4 Merge v Ø | v Ø A
5 Move d → word | d (null) → word B → A
7 Spell na + 'a + jooł → na'ajooł | na + jooł → naajooł A
D predicts that [dP 'aghaa' 'a] fails at step 3 with na'a-((1)). Y&M list no
such sentence. This is silence (LD-8), not a judgment.
D4 L3 'ałtso 'i'ííjaa', analysis D: the same IV-V 'a as the object
1 Merge [dP pro d:'a] ('things', no overt noun; Y&M's gloss "things (seeds)") B
2 Agree [sort] from pro (what values it is OPEN, T87e) B
3 Merge [VP dP V] ; V = *Øjááh in base 'e'e- B
4 Merge v; agent 1sg in Spec,vP A/B (VPISH hyp.)
5 Move d → word B → A
6 Agree subject cell 1sg A
7 Spell 'a(Ib) + 'a(IV-V) + PFV.1SG → 'i'íí- ; + jaa' → 'i'ííjaa' (p. 364 row 1) A
D1 and D4 put their d in one slot, IV-V, though one is a subject and one an
object. The slot comes from A's template, not from where d started (LD-14).
Merge builds dP, VP, v and the clause. Agree only values features on heads that already exist. Move is head movement of d, or its post-syntactic equivalent, plus the clause-level movement of the remnant. The listed choice of d is a lexical fact about the base, and under D it is enforced at Merge (step 3).
9. Locality: D, C and A
HYPOTHESIS LD-9 says that what is listed is a pair: the base takes a d of a given kind together with a noun of a given sort (LD-11). Under D, d and the noun form one constituent before the base sees them. The pair is visible on one label at the moment the base merges, so the listing is ordinary local c-selection (D1 step 3). Under C, d is on the verbal spine and the noun is not yet in the derivation when d merges. The sort part of the listing has to be checked later, by non-local Agree or by an interface filter (D2 step 6). Under A (the prefix is the pronominal argument), the base can s-select a pronoun with a sort, which is local. The noun still has to match the pronoun afterwards through LINK. On locality, then, D and A both do better than C, and D does slightly better than A because its match happens inside one constituent (Agree in dP) rather than through LINK.
HYPOTHESIS Against D (LD-14), the ʼeʼe- class puts the listed ʼa- in a single slot whatever its role. If d really moves from its argument position, A's template has to override that position. This is the essay's §5(b) problem. It counts equally against C, which needs two spine heads spelled out in one slot.
OPEN The locality argument presupposes that the ʼeʼe- gas and vehicle argument is merged as the sister of V (D1 step 3). If it is an external argument, the local selector is v, and D's head movement comes out of a specifier, which is the essay's §5(a) problem. Unaccusativity diagnostics for these bases have not been opened (T87a).
10. Fidelity notes
All forms were copied from the interface HTML saved on the box ([local working copy, not in the repository], [local working copy, not in the repository]). The interface was not checked against the print edition. (1) The F/I/O/P/R lists in many entries are labelled "[Guess a paradigm]", which may mean the interface generated them. Table 1 therefore uses only perfectives that occur in Y&M's example sentences. (2) The p. 364 table was read from the interface's paradigm view. Its column heads ("PERFECTIVE Ø - Ł", "PERFECTIVE D - L") are taken as printed. (3) The ʼeʼe- paradigm also has a "PASS. A" row with ʼoʼoo- (Ø/Ł perfective). None of the Table 1 bases uses it. (4) The p. 591 table is the na-((3)) paradigm. naʼajooł belongs to na'a-((1)), and its own paradigm page could not be found, so naʼajooł's perfective naʼazhjool was not compared with a row (T87c). (5) No Navajo form here was supplied or checked by a speaker.
11. Open questions
| ID | Question | What would settle it |
|---|---|---|
| T87a | Is the single argument of the ʼeʼe- gas, sun and vehicle bases internal (unaccusative)? D's local check (D1 step 3) and its escape from §5(a) depend on it. | A published Navajo unaccusativity diagnostic (e.g. in Hale & Platero, Willie 1991, or Speas 1990) applied to these bases |
| T87b | Which verbs actually use p. 364's 3i row ʼoʼoo- (Ø/Ł perfective)? A 3i subject on a transitive ʼeʼe- base? | A search for Ø/Ł-classifier entries with a perfective in ʼoʼoo- and an example sentence |
| T87c | In the na- classes, does the listed 3i of naʼajooł (P naʼazhjool) match a 3i row or a row 3 (naazhjool of naajooł)? Do other prefix classes behave like ʼeʼe-? | The na'a-((1)) prefix entries (pp. 544, 548, 554, 642) and any paradigm that covers them |
| T87d | Under D, how does the stranded noun reach clause-initial position (D1 step 9)? Remnant movement of [dP NP t_d], or base position? | Sources on Navajo subject position and word order (Speas 1990; Willie 1991); T86b connectivity tests |
| T87e | When d has no overt noun (L3 'things', the sun), what values its sort? A pro with a sort feature, or the base alone? | Entries where the same 3i base occurs with and without an overt noun (cf. NF set on sun-subject) |
T85e answered (LD-9, HYPOTHESIS; data LD-1–LD-8 SOURCED). T85d partly answered (LD-12; same-noun alternation not found in the bases opened). Still open: T85a, b, c, f; T86a–g. New: T87a–e.
