Hale's "general" b-: the workshop text behind "Hale 2000:70–71", and whether it is the subject-relative yi- (T62e)
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. Apostrophe fixes only. Navajo glottal stops typed as ' or ’ (for example in prefix names like ʼa- and ʼeʼe-, or words like Awééʼ) now print as ʼ (U+02BC), and a build step no longer turns the closing quote of an English translation inside a Navajo row into a glottal stop (‘…the girls.’, not ‘…the girls.ʼ). No form, gloss or translation wording changed.
Verbs on this page → dictionary: yoolóós ‘lead (one animate)’ · nímááz ‘rolled; with yaa/baa ‘to’: rolled to’
Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). Voice, causatives and events are restated with every theta role assigned inside vP: the classifier spells a value of v⁰ (H59, distribution NOT UNDERSTOOD), a causer is an external argument in Spec,vP, and the passive keeps a silent indefinite agent (H10b). This page’s causative analysis has not yet been restated on the unified structure (OPEN). Light d, used below, is withdrawn (Grant, 2026-11-14); light n is an OPEN structural question. The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Flat-S and other pre-VPISH notation below is labelled contrast. Status on the spine: see unified structure, §4, causatives and passive rows. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.
The last two pages repaired Aissen's account with R4/R5: yi- means "outranked by the subject", and bi- is the general form everywhere else. They kept quoting Hale's phrase "the general third person object prefix b-", but only second-hand through Saxon. T62e asked for Hale himself. Hale's 1997 Navajo workshop notes (hale023) have been on the box since 2026-10-15. This run shows they contain, word for word, the passages that Saxon 2003 quotes as "Hale 2000:70" and "Hale 2000:71, fn12". Read in full, Hale's rule is subject-relative. But his relation is structural ("in the c-command domain of a clausemate third person subject"), not a ranking.
In plain words: Hale says bi- is the ordinary "him/her/it" prefix. yi- is special: it shows up only when a real third-person doer sits above the object in the sentence's structure SOURCED. That matches the repair on the last two pages, provided "ranks higher" and "sits higher" turn out to be the same thing HYPOTHESIS. The prefix can't be read off the order of the nouns, though: two sources give the same noun order with opposite prefixes. So the "above" has to be between the hidden pronoun slots, not the spoken nouns HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data. Hale's causative sentences add a limit: one verb word has room for only one object-agreement prefix of this kind SOURCED.
On this page: 1 Question · 2 Sources · 3 What Hale says · 4 A correction: who is "removed" · 5 Hale's rule vs R4/R5 · 6 Does noun order decide? · 7 The causative: one slot per word · 8 Rulesets A and B · 9 Rules · 10 Derivations · 11 Grant's ideas · 12 Bottom line · 13 Fidelity notes · 14 Open questions
Notation as on one-proximate and ranked-obviatives. Σ = the role schema (Dowty's proto-roles as the baseline; the Navajo slots are extensions of it). A = the word level (prefixal, left-headed; W = a verb or postposition word). B = the clause level (right-headed). ρA/ρS/ρP = agent / sole / patient slots, ρwith/ρfor = the object of 'with'/'for'. [prx] > [obv1] > [obv2] = tier places. H = Hale's rule as stated in §3. Merge builds structure (it puts two pieces together). Agree values features (person, number, obviation) between pieces that are already built. Hale's EP/MP/VP labels are his: E is his "edge" head, where object agreement sits, and M is Mode.
1. Question
T62e (from one-proximate §14): "Hale 2000:70–71 first-hand: is the 'general third person object prefix b-' the subject-relative idea?" The printed Hale 2000 (Fernald & Hale, eds., Diné Bizaad Naalkaah, MITWPL ELL 3: 55–97, as listed in Saxon's bibliography) is not on the box, and no open copy was found. What is on the box is Hale's 1997 workshop text with the same title. If Saxon's quotations occur in it verbatim, it can stand in for those pages. They do (§2).
2. Sources
SOURCED Hale, Ken 1997. "Remarks on the syntax of the Navajo verb", Parts I–III, NLA workshop, Tsaile, July 1997 (MIT papers hale023.pdf, 61 PDF pages, born-digital; on the box since 2026-10-15). Read this run: PDF pp. 16–18 (the obviation passage, fn. 9–11, tree (5)), pp. 21–22 (trees (10)–(11)), p. 27 ((17)–(18), fn. 17), and pp. 54–59 (the causative, (40)–(54)). Page images checked for pp. 16, 17, 27 and 58. The other pages come from the text layer, which matched the images wherever both were checked.
HYPOTHESIS (strongly supported) hale023 = the text Saxon cites as Hale 2000. Saxon 2003 fn. 6 quotes "removing it from the domain in which obviation applies, forcing use of the general third person object prefix b-" (Hale 2000:70). That string occurs verbatim at hale023 PDF p. 17. Saxon p. 356 quotes "the DP appearing in the highest Spec or adjunct position in the inflectional portion of the extended projection" (Hale 2000:71, fn12). That string occurs verbatim in hale023 fn. 11, PDF p. 18. The order and spacing also fit: printed p. 70 ≈ PDF pp. 16–17, and p. 71 ≈ PDF p. 18. The footnote number differs (12 vs 11), so the printed version is not identical. It probably has one more note earlier (T64a).
SOURCED Re-checked on page images this run: Willie 1991 PDF p. 101 = printed p. 95, (85)/(86) at 300 dpi. Saxon 2003 notes page (PDF p. 363 of the WECOL volume): footnote markers 5 (Broadwell & Duncan) and 6 (Hale).
Carried over, not re-opened: Aissen 2000 (13a), (16); Saxon (38), (39), (32) (= Perkins 1978:55), Perkins (8a–c) via Saxon p. 343 (schematic); Creamer 1974 (c23). The forms and pages are on one-proximate, ranked-obviatives and two-osv.
Not opened: Hale 2000 as printed; Thompson 1989, 1994; Young 1996; Young & Morgan 1987 (cited by Hale for the indefinite ’-).
3. What Hale says SOURCED
- The rule (PDF p. 16, page image): "The prefix b- is in fact the general third person object agreement marker. The obviative y- is much more restricted, being limited strictly to situations in which a third person object is in the c-command domain of a clausemate third person subject. In all other situations, b- is the agreement marker which appears, where overt." y- is "glossed 3o by Young and Morgan, reflecting its obviative function which, like that of its parallel in Algonquian … regularly marks clausemate third persons as referentially distinct."
- Other subjects (fn. 9, p. 16): "If a third person object appears in the c-command domain of a first, second, or fourth person subject, … If the third person object morphology appears in E, then it is realized as Ø; otherwise, it is realized as b-."
- The fourth person (fn. 17, p. 27, page image): "The fourth person shares zero-AGRs with the third person. It does not behave like a third person in obviation, however—only the 'true' third person (that realized pronominally as bí, for example) requires that a clausemate object in its c-command domain show obviative (y-) agreement."
- 3-on-3 clauses (p. 16): "the object cannot remain in the c-command domain of the subject if the object agreement is b-."
- Order and height (p. 17, page image): "We have seen that, in general, if some element X is to the left of Y, it is higher than Y." Tree (5): the object DP tsídii in Spec,EP, the subject DP mósí inside VP, and b- under AGRo in E, "in accordance with the above mentioned Navajo principle of obviative agreement, which restricts the obviative y- to objects c-commanded by a clausemate third person subject."
- Direct clauses (pp. 21–22): the object raises to Spec,MP to agree with E, "the closest c-governor". Then: "Since the third person obviative agreement morphology y- appears in E, we can at the same time satisfy the requirement that the subject c-command the object in the obviative by raising the subject into Spec of EP" ((10) → (11)). So in Hale's direct clause the raised object is above the unraised subject, and only the subject's further raise to Spec,EP makes y- possible.
- Cause or result? (p. 18): "Is b- really the cause of the movement, or is it instead just a by-product of it? If the latter is true, then the appearance of b- would be a result, not the cause … This seems more reasonable". The motive he gives for moving the object is topic: speakers at the 1974 workshop said the Inverse puts the object in the position of topic, and Platero's relative tsídii mósí biní¬ʼínígíí 'the bird that the cat is looking at' (as printed, cf. Hale, Jeanne & Platero 1977). Fn. 11 defines "clausal topic" as "the DP appearing in the highest Spec or adjunct position in the inflectional portion of the extended projection of V (i.e., in Navajo, the position dominated by EP or a segment of EP)".
Hale's own pair (PDF pp. 14–15; (2) cited from Y&M 1987G:65), printed with glosses on inverse-agree §2: (2) Mósí tsídii yiní¬ʼ²í 'The cat is looking at the bird' and (3) Tsídii mósí biní¬ʼ²í 'The cat is looking at the bird' / 'The bird is being looked at by the cat' (inverse; both translations Hale's). These are as printed: ¬ and ² are font substitutions and are not decoded here.
Answer to T62e SOURCED + HYPOTHESIS: Yes, in shape. In Hale's rule, b- is the elsewhere form, and y- requires a clausemate "true" third-person subject standing in a relation to that particular object. That makes it subject-relative and assigned object by object, which is exactly what R4/R5 say (SOURCED that Hale says this). The difference is the relation. In R4/R5 it is tier rank; in H it is c-command, i.e. height in the tree. §5 shows that the two agree if rank and height line up (HYPOTHESIS).
4. A correction: who is "removed" SOURCED
Read in its source, the "removing it" passage (p. 17) runs: "Or it might be, to follow suggestions by Margaret Speas and Eloise Jelinek, that the Inverse involves topicalization of the object, removing it from the domain in which obviation applies, forcing use of the general third person object prefix b-." Three things follow:
- "it" is the object. One-proximate §6 paraphrased this (following the wording of Saxon's fn. 6) as "inverting the subject removes it". That is the wrong referent, and the page now carries a correction note.
- It is one of two options Hale gives, and he credits the idea to Speas and Jelinek. On p. 18 he leans toward "b- as a result", with topic as the motive.
- The obviation footnote in Saxon is fn. 6 (page image), not fn. 7 as one-proximate had it.
5. Hale's rule vs R4/R5 HYPOTHESIS
- H (from §3): for a 3rd-person object β, y- iff β is in the c-command domain of a clausemate "true" 3rd-person subject. Otherwise b-, or Ø in E under a 1st/2nd/4th-person subject (fn. 9).
- R5 (ranked-obviatives §5): YI on W iff an on-tier 3rd-person subject outranks W's 3rd-person object. BI elsewhere.
- Points where they already agree (SOURCED in each source): 1st/2nd-person subjects never give y- (H: fn. 9; R5: off the 3rd-only tier, Aissen 2000 fn. 7). 4th-person subjects never give y- (H: fn. 17; R5: 4th persons are off the tier, Aissen 2000 §6). In both, b- is the general form.
- Bridge BR (HYPOTHESIS): "α outranks β on the tier" ⇔ "α c-commands β at the point where β's prefix is valued". In Hale's terms, the proximate is the "clausal topic" (fn. 11: highest Spec or adjunct of EP), and rank is read off height. With BR, R5 and H are the same rule stated in two vocabularies.
- What H adds: a structural reason for the thing-subject bi-s. In Hale's direct derivation the object first raises to Spec,MP, above the subject in VP (pp. 21–22). A subject that does not go on to Spec,EP therefore stays below the object, and H gives b-. Saxon's SX-4 says thing-subjects stay in VP (two-osv). Together these give bi- on a verb's object under a thing-subject (Perkins p. 136 via Saxon; Aissen 2000 (16a) dibé tó ʼabííł ʼéél), and they give both bi-s in Y&M (38)/(39) with no ranking among three 3rd persons. In the R5 vocabulary, this is the OP-9 residue (how two things are ranked) recast as "did the subject raise?" (HYPOTHESIS).
- And a prediction: if a thing-subject can raise to Spec,EP, H allows yi- with it. Saxon's footnote pair from Y&M 1987:225 ('Rainbows surround the mountains', printed both with yi- and with bi-; T61c) has that shape. The forms stay schematic here because the page image is faint (T64b).
6. Does noun order decide? HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data
Hale's "if X is to the left of Y, it is higher than Y" is stated "in general". Take it literally for the overt nouns and combine it with H. The sourced sentences then come out like this:
| (1) | ʼashkii | ʼatʼééd | łį́į́ʼ | yá | yoolóós |
| boy | girl | horse | 3.for | 3.3.lead [sing. +animate] | |
| boy | girl | horse | 3OBJ(yi)-for | 3OBJ(yi).3SBJ-lead | |
| 'The boy is leading the horse for the girl.' (85) | |||||
| (2) | ʼashkii | ʼatʼééd | łį́į́ʼ | bá | yoolóós |
| boy | girl | horse | 3.for | 3.3.lead [sing. +animate] | |
| boy | girl | horse | 3OBJ(bi)-for | 3OBJ(yi).3SBJ-lead | |
| 'The girl is leading the horse for the boy.' (86) | |||||
Willie p. 95: "Here the Inverse gives the agent role to the internal argument, and the Benefactive role to the external argument. Note that the theme argument does not take part in the inversion process." The second gloss line is ours (Leipzig style). Willie's own gloss is the first.
| Sentence | Noun order (left = higher) | H predicts | Printed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hale (2) / (3) | cat > bird / bird > cat | y- / b- | ✓ / ✓ |
| Aissen 2000 (13a) diné dził yooį́ | man > mountain | y- | ✓ |
| Aissen (16a) dibé tó ʼabííł ʼéél 'the water swept the sheep off' | sheep (object) > water | b- | ✓ |
| Aissen (16b) *tó dibé ʼayííł ʼéél | water > sheep | y- (the form printed) | form ✓, but the star is not from H: it needs a separate animacy filter (Hale 1973 via Aissen (14)) that bans this structure |
| Willie (1) = (85) | boy (subj) > girl (for) > horse | yá, y-verb | ✓ |
| Willie (2) = (86) | boy (for) > girl (subj) > horse | bá, y-verb | ✓ (one clause, two values) |
| Perkins (8a) / (8b) via Saxon (schematic) | boy > girl > bike | (8a) yił, y-verb; (8b) bił, y-verb | ✓ / ✓ |
| Perkins (8c)* (schematic) | boy (with) > girl (subj) > bike | verb y- (bike is below girl), so b-verb out | ✓ (the star follows from order alone) |
| Creamer (c23) Tsé tʼiis yikʼi chʼínímááz 'The rock rolled upon the tree' | rock > tree | yikʼi | ✓ |
| Saxon (32) = Perkins 1978:55 Jooł tsin báhátis yiltsʼid … 'The ball rolled over the log' | ball > log | yi- on 'over' | ✗ bá- |
| Y&M (38) Bił bináʼeeł | no nouns | — | H over nouns is silent |
Result. H over overt nouns fits everything except one pair. (c23) and (32) have the same order (thing subject, then thing object of a postposition) and opposite prefixes. Two sources with one order and two outcomes are contradicting data for "H applied to the spoken nouns, with left = higher". Two readings survive (HYPOTHESIS):
- H over slots. H holds between the pronominal slots (ρ bundles). Overt nouns are linked later, at B, as on nominal adjunction, so their order is not the slots' height. In (32) the subject slot stays low in VP (SX-4) and the 'over' PP is attached above it, giving bá-. In (c23) either the rock's slot raised or the PP is low, giving yikʼi. Under this reading the (c23)/(32) clash becomes a question of attachment or raising, i.e. speaker or construction variation (T62c, T64c). It is no longer a clash of rules.
- "True third person". Fn. 17 makes only a "true" third person a y-trigger. If Perkins's speakers treat a thing-subject as not "true" in this sense, (32) follows. Nothing in Hale says things fall outside "true" third persons (his example is bí), so this reading is OPEN and unsupported.
Under "H over slots", (8c)'s star no longer follows from order alone. It needs Saxon's SX-4 the other way round: a human 3rd-person subject must raise to Spec,EP, so it c-commands the bike's slot and the verb must be y-. The order-only account and the slots account make different predictions for a reordered (8c) with the bike before the girl (T64d).
7. The causative: one agreement slot per word SOURCED data, HYPOTHESIS reading
T63c asked whether any clause forces the verb's prefix and a postposition's prefix to share one value. Hale's causative section (PDF pp. 54–59) shows a different kind of limit. Here the postposition is inside the verb word. Hale's analysis (p. 57): the causee 'boy' is the object of a causative postposition -y, and its "agreement needs … are met locally, internal to the PP". Then "the causative P intrudes into the upper and left-most structure of verb word (i.e., that portion projected by E)". His forms (page image p. 58) are printed as printed: ² and ¬ are font substitutions and are not decoded. The morpheme breakdowns are his.
| (3) | Shí | ashkii | biʼiiss²á. |
| 1SG | boy | b-ʼ-y-Ø-sh-¬-y²á | |
| 1SG | boy | 3OBJ(bi).AGRc-INDF.OBJ-CAUS.P-M-1SG.SBJ-CLF-eat | |
| 'I am feeding the boy (lit., making make the boy eat).' (50a) | |||
| (4) | Hastiin | ashkii | yiʼiis²á. |
| man | boy | y-ʼ-y-Ø-Ø-¬-y²á | |
| man | boy | 3OBJ(yi).AGRc-INDF.OBJ-CAUS.P-M-3SBJ-CLF-eat | |
| 'The man is feeding the boy (i.e., making the boy eat).' (50b) | |||
| (5) | *Hastiin | ashkii | bááh yiyiis²á. |
| man | boy | bread yAGRc-yAGRo-y-ØM-ØAGRs-¬-y²á | |
| 'The man makes the boy eat bread.' (49b), Hale's star; (51b), with one agreement prefix left out, is also starred. | |||
Hale p. 58: "the AGRc agreement morphology associated with the causative usurps the function of AGRo … In effect, only one agreement morpheme of the relevant sort can appear in E." (49)/(51) are his "hypothetical" forms with his stars. (50) is good because the indefinite ’- "does not 'compete' with AGRc for the standard object agreement position in E" (p. 59). The Leipzig line is ours, built from Hale's segmentation and labels. CAUS.P = his causative postposition -y, INDF.OBJ = his indefinite object ’-, M = Mode.
- The causee prefix follows H (HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data): y- under the 3rd-person subject 'man' (4), b- under 'I' (3). This is a postposition's agreement obeying the same subject-relative rule, even though it sits inside the verb word.
- But not fn. 9's Ø (HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data): fn. 9 says a 3rd-person object prefix in E under a 1st-person subject is Ø. In (3) AGRc is in E under 'I' and comes out b-, not Ø. It keeps the postposition's "otherwise b-". So the Ø/b- choice follows where the agreement came from (the P, valued inside the PP), not where it ends up. The y-/b- choice follows the subject (H). Hale does not comment on this. The reading is ours. [Correction 2026-10-27 ~4:46am PT: Hale & Platero 1996 (paragraph after their (10)) do state it. Causee markers are overt bi- under a 1st/2nd-person subject, "as if attached to an incorporated postposition". See causee-bi, which tests it on 10 forms (T64f).]
- T63c, partly (HYPOTHESIS): no case of a forced shared value was found. (5) is a limit on number instead: one verb word holds one referential object agreement in E, and the causative P's agreement takes that one slot. Separate words (Willie (2): bá + yoolóós) keep their own values. The word, not the clause, is the domain of the limit. This fits RO-8 (one comparison per word) and gives it a second, independent kind of evidence.
8. Rulesets A and B HYPOTHESIS
- B (clause, right-headed): everything H looks at is clausal. This covers Merge of the subject in VP, the object's raise to Spec,MP, the EPP raise to Spec,EP (subject or object), and where a PP attaches. Hale's heads are on the right (VP before M, MP before E: trees (5), (10), (11)). So this is right-headed structure, and c-command is computed here.
- A (word, left-headed prefixal): the prefix itself. Head Movement takes V to M to E, and a P's agreement "intrudes" into E. This turns the right-hand clausal heads into a word whose prefixes stand to the left of the stem. Agree on AGRo (or on a P's AGR) reads the B-level fact "is my object below a 3rd-person subject?" and spells out y- or b-.
- Where the changeover happens: at Head Movement into E. The relation is computed at B and stored in the word at A. Each word with its own agreement (V or P) makes the comparison once (RO-8). A P that intrudes into E keeps the result it already had (§7). This refines RO-9 (tier at B, spell-out at A) by naming the step that does the handover.
9. Rules
HG-1 b- = general 3rd-person object agreement; y- only if the 3rd object is in the c-command SOURCED (Hale 1997 PDF p. 16)
domain of a clausemate 3rd-person subject.
HG-2 Under 1st/2nd/4th subjects: Ø if the object morphology is in E, else b-. SOURCED (fn. 9, p. 16)
HG-3 Only a "true" 3rd person (pronoun bí) triggers y-; 4th persons do not. SOURCED (fn. 17, p. 27)
HG-4 Direct: object → Spec,MP (Agree with E); subject → Spec,EP to c-command it. SOURCED (pp. 21–22, (10)–(11))
Inverse: object → Spec,EP ("clausal topic", fn. 11); b- a result, not a cause (p. 18).
HG-5 "removing it" (p. 17) = topicalized OBJECT; Speas & Jelinek's suggestion, one of two. SOURCED (correction to one-proximate)
HG-6 hale023 = the text Saxon cites as Hale 2000:70–71 (verbatim matches; fn. 11 vs 12). HYPOTHESIS (strong)
HG-7 BR: on-tier rank = c-command height at valuation; then R5 ≡ HG-1. HYPOTHESIS
HG-8 HG-1 over overt nouns with "left = higher" is contradicted by Creamer (c23) vs Perkins (32); HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data
HG-1 over pronominal slots (nouns linked at B) survives.
HG-9 One referential object agreement per verb word: a causative P's AGRc takes it. SOURCED (Hale (49)–(51), p. 58)
HG-10 AGRc's y-/b- follows HG-1 ((50a)/(50b)); its b- under 'I' ignores HG-2's Ø HYPOTHESIS on SOURCED data
→ spell-out keyed to the P origin.
HG-11 Changeover B→A at Head Movement into E; one comparison per agreeing word. HYPOTHESIS (refines RO-8, RO-9)
10. Derivations, step by step
Labels: Σ role schema, B clause, A word. Restating Hale's trees: his trees are not flat-S trees. They already put the subject DP inside VP (tree (5), (10)), which is VPISH. What is older is the transitional notation (d-/s-structure, Move Alpha, government, "c-governor"). Below, MP and EP are kept as his labels for the two heads above VP. Movement is written as internal Merge, and agreement as Agree. Overt nouns are linked at B (nominal adjunction), so in the derivations the slots move, not the nouns.
HD-1. (2) = Willie (86) 'The girl is leading the horse for the boy'
| Σ | Σ = {ρA: 3sg human (girl); ρP: 3sg animate (horse); ρfor: 3sg human (boy)}. Proto-Agent / Proto-Patient as in Dowty; ρfor is a Navajo P-slot (an extension). |
| B | Merge V 'lead' with ρP. Merge ρA in Spec,VP. Merge M, then E. (Merge builds the structure.) |
| B | Internal Merge ρP → Spec,MP. Agree with E (AGRo). ρA → Spec,EP (EPP). ρA now c-commands ρP. |
| B | PP [ρfor P] Agrees inside itself (p. 57 "locally"). The PP adjoins to EP as the clausal topic (fn. 11 "adjunct"), above ρA. |
| A | Word 'for': is ρfor c-commanded by a 3rd-person subject? No → bá ✓. Word V: is ρP below ρA? Yes → yoolóós ✓. |
| B | Link nouns: 'ashkii → ρfor, ʼatʼééd → ρA, łį́į́ʼ → ρP. Order boy > girl > horse ✓. The theme does not invert (Willie), since ρP never leaves Spec,MP. |
HD-2. (4) = Hale (50b) 'The man is feeding the boy'
| Σ | Σ = {ρA: 3sg human (causer); ρcausee: 3sg human, object of CAUS.P; Proto-Patient of 'eat' = the indefinite ’-, non-referential}. |
| B | Merge V2 'eat' with ’-. Merge PP [ρcausee -y]. Merge V1 ł-causative, then ρA, M, E (Hale (47)/(48)). |
| B | Agree inside PP: ρcausee with P (AGRc). ’- raises to Spec,MP and incorporates (p. 59), so it takes no agreement slot. ρA → Spec,EP and c-commands the PP. |
| A | Head Movement V2→V1→M→E. CAUS.P and AGRc intrude into E (the changeover into the word). AGRc: a 3rd-person subject is above → y- → yiʼiis²á ✓. With 'I' as subject (50a): not 3rd → b- (P origin, not fn. 9's Ø) ✓. |
| — | Add a referential 'bread' (49b): it would also need AGRo in E, but AGRc already holds the one slot → * ✓ (HG-9). |
HD-3. Saxon (32) = Perkins 1978:55 'The ball rolled over the log' (the HG-8 case)
| Σ | Σ = {ρS: 3, ball, inanimate; ρG: 3, log, object of 'over'}. |
| B | Merge V 'roll' with ρS. ρS stays in VP (SX-4, a thing-subject). The PP ['over' ρG] adjoins above VP. |
| A | Word 'over': is ρG below a 3rd-person subject? No (the subject slot is lower) → bá- ✓. |
| B | Link nouns: Jooł 'ball' first, tsin 'log' second (topic order, not slot height) ✓. |
| — | Creamer (c23) needs the same B steps with the subject slot raised or the PP low → yikʼi. Which one, and why the speakers differ, is OPEN (T62c, T64c). |
11. Grant's ideas
GRANT'S CONJECTURE Feature bundles / proto-words as arguments. Consistent, with support from new data. The one contradicting pair in §6 is contradicting only if H holds between the spoken nouns. Stated between the role-bearing slots, it fits. That is the bundles view (HYPOTHESIS). Hale's indefinite ’- is "utterly non-referential", has "all the syntactic and semantic characteristics of an incorporated element", "essentially removes a referential DP object from the argument roster", and in (53)/(54) stands for "the 'prototypical patient' of the event denoted by the verb" (SOURCED, pp. 58–59). An argument position filled by a role-only element that is not a word is close to Grant's "proto-word". Hale frames ordinary arguments as DPs ("canonical DP arguments must enter into the agreement relation", p. 58). That is his framework, not a datum against bundles, so it is not counted.
GRANT'S CONJECTURE Strata. Consistent. Hale's derivation has the same layers in the same order. Argument structure comes first, in VP (roles). Agreement comes next (object to Spec,MP, Agree with E). Topic comes after that (EPP/Spec,EP, "clausal topic"). The prefix is "a result, not the cause" of the topic layer (p. 18), so it is read late. Noun choice is not needed until linking (HD-3).
GRANT'S CONJECTURE Merge/Agree sites inside the word. Supported, as a HYPOTHESIS. The causative gives a clear intra-word case. A postposition's Agree is completed inside its own phrase, the P is then merged into the verb word (Head Movement), and it keeps its own value and its own spell-out rule (§7). It also uses up the word's single object-agreement place (HG-9). So within one word there are two Agree sites, one of them carried in from a smaller word.
Chemistry: SPECULATIVE, flag only. A marker that depends on whether a site lies within the reach of a particular neighbour (a geometric domain), rather than on a global ranking, plus a host with only one place for such a marker. No chemical correlate is identified or claimed.
12. Bottom line
SOURCED Hale's workshop text (hale023, PDF pp. 16–18, 21–22, 27) states that b- is the "general" 3rd-person object marker and y- needs a 3rd-person object "in the c-command domain of a clausemate third person subject". It excludes 1st/2nd/4th-person subjects (fn. 9, fn. 17), and treats the inverse's b- as a result of the object's rise to "clausal topic". The "removing it" passage concerns the object and is credited to Speas and Jelinek. A causative P's agreement takes the verb word's only object-agreement slot ((49)–(51)).
HYPOTHESIS hale023 is the text Saxon cites as Hale 2000:70–71. T62e answered: Hale's rule is subject-relative and assigned object by object, like R4/R5. It differs in using c-command where they use rank, and the two coincide under BR. Applied to spoken-noun order, H is contradicted by Creamer (c23) vs Perkins (32); applied to pronominal slots, it survives. The B→A changeover is Head Movement into E.
OPEN The printed Hale 2000 pages (T64a). Whether thing-subjects can raise (the rainbow pair, T64b). PP attachment in (c23) vs (32) (T64c). The reordered (8c) test (T64d).
13. Fidelity notes
- Hale quotations on PDF pp. 16, 17, 27 and 58 were checked against page images, and the others come from the text layer. Navajo forms from hale023 are printed as printed: ¬ and ² are font substitutions in the PDF itself, the same on the page image, and are not decoded. The morpheme breakdowns in (3)–(5) are Hale's. The Leipzig lines are ours.
- The PDF page numbers are hale023's. Its printed folios and the printed Hale 2000 pagination were not checked (T64a).
- Willie (85)/(86) were read at 300 dpi: the verb is printed yoolóós with a plain l. Several site pages (pp-by-verb, postposition-units, procliticized-p) print yoołóós. Not yet corrected there; flagged as T64e.
- Saxon's footnote markers were read from the page image (PDF p. 363): Hale's remark is fn. 6. The rainbow note follows fn. 7 (Potter) and so is likely fn. 8 rather than the "fn. 9" used on earlier pages; the marker itself is faint (T64b).
- Perkins (8a–c) stay schematic, as on two-osv. The noun-order column in §6 is Saxon's printed order.
- H, BR, the slot reading, and all slot positions in HD-1 to HD-3 are this site's, not Hale's. Hale did not discuss (32), (c23) or Willie (85)/(86).
14. Open questions
| ID | Question | What would settle it |
|---|---|---|
| T64a | Is the printed Hale 2000 (MITWPL ELL 3: 55–97) pp. 70–71 the same text as hale023 PDF pp. 16–18? Which footnote is added (11 → 12)? | The printed volume first-hand. OPEN |
| T64b | Can a thing-subject raise to Spec,EP and so license yi-? Saxon's rainbow pair (Y&M 1987:225, yi- and bi- both printed) is the H-shaped test (= T61c). | Young & Morgan 1987 p. 225 first-hand (page image), plus any context that separates the two. OPEN |
| T64c | (c23) yikʼi vs (32) báhátis under HG-8: is the difference the subject's height or the PP's attachment? Does the 'over'/'upon' phrase behave like a topic (e.g. in relatives, as in Platero's p. 18 example)? | Perkins 1978 pp. 55, 136 first-hand; Creamer 1974 group 7 context. OPEN |
| T64d | Order-only vs slots: a version of Perkins (8c) with 'bike' before 'girl' (bił + b-verb). The order reading predicts it is good, and the slots reading with SX-4 predicts it is bad. | Perkins 1978 p. 116 first-hand, or a native-speaker judgment. OPEN |
| T64e | Willie (85)/(86) verb: yoolóós (page image) vs yoołóós (printed on pp-by-verb, postposition-units, procliticized-p). Correct site-wide after one more check. | Willie pp. 95–96 and (29) page images; a dictionary entry for 'lead (animate)'. OPEN |
| T64f | HG-10: is a causative or other incorporated P's agreement under a 1st/2nd-person subject always b- and never Ø? Is the Ø of fn. 9 limited to E's own AGRo? | Young & Morgan causative paradigms; Hale 1997 pp. 54–59 against other P-incorporations. OPEN [Update 2026-10-27: answered for causatives on causee-bi (10/10 b-, 0 Ø; see T65a–e).] |
Sources: Hale 1997 workshop notes (hale023) PDF pp. 14–15 (via inverse-agree), 16–18, 21–22, 27, 54–59 (page images pp. 16, 17, 27, 58); Willie 1991 p. 95 (page image, (85)/(86)); Saxon 2003 notes page (image) and pp. 343, 352, 354, 356. Carried over: Aissen 2000 (13a), (16); Creamer 1974 (c23); Perkins (8a–c), (32) via Saxon. See also ranked-obviatives, one-proximate, two-osv, inverse-agree, open questions, sources.
