Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.

SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading

One "his", two third persons: Horseherder 1998 on the owner prefix yi-, and a plural doer that breaks it (T58f, T58a)

Working note. Kept as written (URL, data and status labels unchanged). Filed under Possessors and object-first orders; the consolidated argument is the essay possessors. Rule IDs: rules index.

Verbs on this page → dictionary: jizloh ‘rope’ · dabiiłtsą́ ‘see’ · nizin ‘think; wish (with an optative clause)’

Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). Possessors are restated as the left specifier of the noun phrase, with the possessor prefix as agreement (as on a grammatical postposition). This page’s particular analysis has not yet been restated on the unified structure; light n stays OPEN. Light d, used below, is withdrawn (Grant, 2026-11-14); light n is an OPEN structural question. The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Flat-S and other pre-VPISH notation below is labelled contrast. Status on the spine: see unified structure, §2b, possessors. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.

2026-11-11 audit pass 2. Wording that used VPISH as the name of a spine, tree, skeleton or set of slots named a structure after the hypothesis. VPISH is a hypothesis name, never a node; the structure is a vP/TP spine with the subject first-merged in left Spec,vP. Only the wording changed.

The last two runs asked when Navajo lets the owner prefix on a noun ("his", "her") point back to someone in the sentence, and why W&J's 'all John'si children saw himi' is bad under bi- (T58a). This run read a source not used here before. Nicole Horseherder's 1998 UBC M.A. thesis is entirely about the owner prefix yi- on nouns, built on her own fieldwork with four Navajo speakers. In plain words: yi- 'his/her' on a noun works only when two singular third persons are around. One is the person it means, who may be named or may just be the person being talked about. The other is a different person who is the doer of the sentence. If the doer is 'I', 'you' or a plural ('the girls'), yi- fails, even though it would refer to someone else. The ranking (obviation) account used on the last two pages predicts the 'I'/'you' failures. It does not predict the plural one, and neither does the verb's own yi-, which is fine with plural doers. That matters for T58a: W&J's bad sentence also has a plural doer ('all John's children', with da-). So a plural doer is now a sourced suspect, alongside "the name is inside the doer's phrase". This is a lean, not a result.

On this page: 1 Question · 2 Source · 3 The data · 4 Her analysis, and its tree · 5 The same facts under ranking · 6 What this does to T58a · 7 A new deep-inverse test · 8 Rules · 9 Derivations · 10 Grant's ideas · 11 Bottom line · 12 Fidelity notes · 13 Open questions

Notation as on the possessor-gap page. Σ = the role schema. A = the word level (prefixal, left-headed; W = the verb word, N-W = a possessed noun word with possessor slot π). B = the clause level (right-headed). ρA/ρP = agent and patient slots; [prx]/[obv] = proximate/obviative. Merge vs Agree: Merge builds structure; it puts two pieces together, for example the slot π inside the noun word, or a noun phrase next to the verb word. Agree values features; it checks or copies person, number and index between bundles. This page is mostly about Agree: Horseherder's condition is a feature match (person and number) between the prefix and two other bundles. Move is Merge again of something already in the structure.

1. Question

T58f (merged with T57c): is the owner prefix bound like an operator (A′-binding), and does that matter for the yi-/bi- possessor facts? T58a: why is W&J (70b) bad under bi- when (30) is good? Candidates so far: the name inside the doer's phrase, 'all', or source. And for both questions: what does a first-hand, single-topic Navajo source say yi- on a noun needs?

2. Source

SOURCED Horseherder, Nicole 1998. A Binding-Theoretic Analysis of Navajo Possessor yi-. M.A. thesis, University of British Columbia. DOI 10.14288/1.0088584 (handle 2429/8149). Open-access PDF (69 pp., scanned with an OCR layer) fetched from UBC cIRcle's public bitstream. The OCR drops nasal hooks and most tone marks, so every Navajo form quoted below was read off the page images (110–600 dpi): pp. 31, 35, 38, 39, 42, 44, 45, 47, 48, 50, 54, 57, 60–61. Thesis page n = PDF page n + 6. See sources.

Her consultants (pp. 9–10) are four speakers from three generations. One, the youngest (b. 1982), "could not distinguish between yi- and bi-" (p. 7). Judgments are hers and her consultants'.

Carried over, not re-opened this run: Willie 1991:32 (9) dayiiłtsą́ (number & scope); W&J 2000 (70), (77) and Willie 1991 (28)–(29) (possessor-gap §5); Aissen 2000 (8), (26)/(33) (possessor-binding).

Not opened: the works she draws her minimal pairs and theory from, namely Young & Morgan 1987:9, Saxon 1984a/1986/1995 (Dogrib), Aoun 1985, Huang & Tang 1991. They are cited here only as she reports them.

3. The data SOURCED

Glosses are Leipzig-style restatements of hers. Her own gloss labels are given in the notes, and her translation and indices are kept. "Pf" = perfective. Her "3-3" / "3.3" on the verb = third-person object + third-person subject.

Horseherder 1998:31, (1a), (1b), (2a), (2b) (page image checked)
(1)*yi-łįį́ʼyayizloh
3POSS(yi)-horse3-for3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'hei roped hisk horse' (bad "if out of context")
(2)Joeyi-łįį́ʼyizloh
Joe3POSS(yi)-horse3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'hef roped Joe'sj horse'
(3a)haayitʼeegoFrankJoeyikaʼelwod
Q.in.what.wayFrankJoe3-for/after.run
'How did Frankf help Joej?'
(3b)yi-łįį́ʼyaayizloh
3POSS(yi)-horse3-for3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'hef roped hisj horse for himj' (a possible answer to (3a))

Her gloss labels: "yi-horse", "3.for", "3-3.Pf.rope". The postposition is printed ya in (1a) and yaa in (2b), and yá on pp. 44 and 47–48; all are transcribed as printed. Fn. 2: "the interpretation [Joei roped [hisi horse]] is possible for some speakers. However this reading is hard to get." Her conclusion (p. 31): yi- "cannot stand alone: it must be co-indexed with a nominal antecedent", and (p. 31) that antecedent "can be provided by the discourse context".

(2) has one reading only (pp. 35–37, (4a)–(4c)): 'he roped Joe's horse'. It cannot mean 'Joe roped his (own) horse'. With context (3a), (3b)'s yi- can be Joe, but not Frank, the doer (p. 34, (3a)–(3d)). A third reading, 'Frank roped Kody's horse for Joe', needs Kody to be named: "Kody yi-łįį́ʼ yaa yizloh" (p. 35).

Horseherder 1998:38, (5); 39, (7a, b) (page images checked)
(4)Paulyi-łįį́ʼyiyiiłtsąnizin
Paul3POSS(yi)-horse3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.see3.think/want
'Hei thinks Paulk saw his*i/*k/j horse.' Only: 'He thinks Paul saw someone's horse' (p. 39)
(5a)Haaʼíí biniinaDugiMelabichʼįʼbaháchiʼ
what reason.forDugiMela3(bi)-toward3.angry
'Why is Mela angry with Dugi?'
(5b)yi-łééchaaʼíyineezʼį́ʼ-igiibiniinabichʼįʼbaháchiʼ
3POSS(yi)-dog3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.steal-RELreason.for3(bi)-toward3.angry
'She is angry because he stole her dog.' Literally: 'He stole her dog, that is why she is angry with him.'

(4): yi- "must be disjoint from both the subject of the main clause and the subject of the subordinate clause" and still needs a topic in the discourse (p. 38). She concludes that yi- is "like an R-expression: it must be free everywhere" (p. 39). (5b): here yi- (Mela) corefers with the main-clause subject 'she', and she argues the reason clause is an adjunct, not c-commanded by it (pp. 39–41). Fn. 3: "the response with yi- in (7b) was induced by the OSV (bi-) pattern in the question in (7a)". Her gloss of the relative verb: "that.3-3.stole-clitic".

Horseherder 1998:42, (9a, b) (page image checked, 600 dpi)
(6a)HayitʼéégoJoehooghan-dinádzá
howJoehome-at3SBJ.PFV.return
'How did Joe get home?'
(6b)*yiłįį́ʼhooghan-dibiłnádzá
3POSS(yi)-horsehome-at3(bi)-with3SBJ.PFV.return
'He rode home' (literally 'His horse rode him home')

Bad although there is a discourse antecedent (Joe) and yi- is on the subject, so no subject c-commands it. Hence her third condition (p. 42): "yi- is a disjoint anaphor … it must have two antecedents: an A′-antecedent with which it corefers, and crucially an A-antecedent from which it is disjoint" (following Saxon on Dogrib).

Horseherder 1998:44, (2); 45–46, (3a, b), fn. 1; 47–48, (6), (7); 48, (8) (page images checked)
(7)shitsilíshicheiyiłįį́ʼyáyizloh
1SG.POSS-younger.brother1SG.POSS-grandfather3POSS(yi)-horse3-for3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'My younger brother roped my grandfather's horse for him' ✓ (two overt third persons)
(8a)HayitʼéégoJoebikaʼeshwod… *yiłįį́ʼ séloh
howJoe3-after.1SG.SBJ.PFV.run(=help)3POSS(yi)-horse 3OBJ.1SG.SBJ.PFV.rope
'How did I help Joe? … *I roped his horse' (Joe is available; the doer is 'I')
(9a)atʼeekéMelayiyiiłtsą́… *yiłįį́ʼ yá yizloh
girl.PLMela3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.see3POSS(yi)-horse 3-for 3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'The girls saw Mela … *They roped her horse for her'
(9b)MelaDugiyiyiiłtsą́…yiłįį́ʼ yá yizloh
MelaDugi3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.see3POSS(yi)-horse 3-for 3OBJ.3SBJ.PFV.rope
'Mela saw Dugi … she roped his horse for him' ✓
(10)*shí,yiłįį́ʼséloh/ Shí, shiłįį́ʼ séloh ✓
1SG3POSS(yi)-horse3OBJ.1SG.SBJ.PFV.rope/ 1SG 1SG.POSS-horse …
'*I, I roped his horse' / 'I, I roped my horse'. Same pattern with nihí 'we' (glossed 1.du.Pl; … siidloh) and ni 'you' (… siníloh)

Her gloss labels: "1.poss.brother", "3.poss.horse", "3.3.Pf.rope", "3-1.Pf.run.after(help)", "Pl.girl", "1.S.", "1.3.Pf.rope". (4a) 'How did you help Joe' (bikaʼiinilwod) patterns with (8a); its (4b) is printed *yiłįį́ʼ siniloh (p. 46). Example numbers (1)–(10) on this page are ours; hers are in each block header. Fn. 1 (p. 45): 'Mela helped me … *yiłįį́ʼ yizloh "she roped my horse"' is also out. Her summary (p. 48): "a first, second or plural antecedent cannot license yi-". In (9a) and (9b) neither verb carries plural da-; both are printed yiyiiłtsą́ / yizloh.

The verb's yi- has no such number limit (carried over, SOURCED): Willie 1991:32 (9) dayiiłtsą́ 'They saw him/them' (number & scope §2.1) has a plural doer and an object yi-. Horseherder herself (pp. 59–61) lists how the verb's yi- and the owner's yi- differ: the verb's yi- also needs a disjoint antecedent (the subject), but its coreferent antecedent is in an A-position (the object noun itself), while the owner's must be in an A′-position.

4. Her analysis, and its tree SOURCED (hers)

HYPOTHESIS Framework label. Her trees (pp. 33–35, 51–52) are Government-and-Binding IP trees: pro in Spec,IP, a VP with a PP adjoined, and "agr agr rope" under V. They are not flat-S trees, but they are pre-VPISH in the sense used on the framework audit: no vP, and the subject is not first-merged in Spec,v. They are used here for her judgments and her binding conditions, not as structural evidence. §9 restates them in the vP/TP spine. Her "A-position" claim survives the restatement only if a linked noun phrase counts at its slot's site (assumption A3 on the Hale derivation page), which is not settled.

5. The same facts under ranking (Aissen) HYPOTHESIS

Aissen 2000's reading (carried over): bi-/b- spells a proximate, yi- an obviative (POSS-1, POSS-3), and coreferent third persons in one span share [prx]/[obv]. Fact by fact:

Fact (Horseherder)Binding account (hers)Ranking account (Aissen)
(1) bare yi-łįį́ʼ is out without contextno A′-antecedent✓ also: an obviative needs a proximate in the span, and with only 'he' and an unidentified owner there is no contrast to read. Weaker: ranking says nothing about needing a discourse antecedent.
(2) 'Joe roped his own horse' outA-free (Condition C-like)✓: owner = doer → same span value → [prx] → b-, not yi-
(4) yi- disjoint from both clauses' subjectsA-free everywhere✓ if the span covers the complement clause; not checked
(6b) yi- on the subject outno disjoint A-antecedent✓: the owner must outrank its possessum (GEN > HEAD), so the owner Joe is [prx] → b-, not yi-
(8a), (10) doer = 'I'/'you' blocks yi-φ-mismatch with the disjoint antecedent✓: 1st/2nd are off the third-person tier; the owner is then the only third person, so it is [prx] → b-
(9a) plural doer blocks yi-φ-mismatch (number)✗: two third persons, 'the girls' [prx], Mela [obv] → yi- predicted good. Ranking (in Aissen 1997's Algonquian too) is not sensitive to number.
verb dayiiłtsą́ plural doer fineverbal yi- is a different case (pp. 59–61)✓

HYPOTHESIS So the two accounts agree on everything except number, and number is exactly where the ranking account fails. That is the same failure pattern as W&J (70b) on the possessor-gap page: ranking predicts ✓, speakers say *.

6. What this does to T58a HYPOTHESIS

SentenceOwner prefixDoerOwner's nameRanking predictsJudgment
(30) Hastiin Nééz beʼesdzáán bi-níłʼį́ (Y&M via Aissen 2000)b(i)-singular ('his wife')outside✓✓
W&J (70b) tʼáá ʼałtso Jáan ba-ʼáłchíní dabiiłtsą́, coreferentba-plural (+ da-, + 'all')inside✓*
Horseherder (9a) here = her p. 47 (6) … yiłįį́ʼ yá yizlohyi-plural (no da-)discourse (Mela)✓*
Horseherder (9b) here = her p. 48 (7)yi-singulardiscourse (Dugi)✓✓

7. A new deep-inverse test (D2) HYPOTHESIS

Horseherder's disjointness condition is stated over c-command: the disjoint A-antecedent is "the nearest c-commanding DP in an A-position" (p. 45), which is why yi- on the subject is out ((6b)). That gives a test the possessor-gap page lacked, because it does not run through ranking:

OPEN No such sentence has been opened (T59b). Fn. 3, the bi- question inducing a yi- answer (5a)/(5b), is suggestive, but there the bi- is on a postposition and the yi- owner is inside a reason clause, so it does not test this.

8. Rules

YI-1  An owner yi- on a noun needs a coreferent 3rd-person antecedent in an A′-position:      SOURCED (Horseherder pp. 31, 41, 44)
      a possessor name in its own phrase, or a discourse topic. (1) vs (2), (3).
YI-2  An owner yi- is disjoint from every c-commanding A-position subject, in its own        SOURCED (pp. 34–39; (4))
      clause and above it ("free everywhere").
YI-3  An owner yi- needs a disjoint 3rd-person A-antecedent, so yi- on the subject's phrase   SOURCED (p. 42, (6b); p. 57)
      fails even with a discourse antecedent.
YI-4  Both antecedents must be 3rd person singular: a 1st/2nd or plural doer blocks yi-     SOURCED (pp. 45–55; (8a), (9a), (10))
      even though it is not the owner. (Her: yi- is inherently 3sg, and dual φ/R indices.)
YI-5  Verbal yi- has no such number limit (dayiiłtsą́ 'they saw him').                     SOURCED (Willie 1991:32 (9), carried over)
YI-6  Ranking (POSS-1–3, GAP-1–2) derives YI-2, YI-3 and the 1st/2nd half of YI-4,         HYPOTHESIS
      but not the plural half.
YI-7  T58a: W&J (70b) and Horseherder (9a) share a plural doer and a ranking-predicts-✓/    HYPOTHESIS (lean)
      speakers-say-* profile. A plural-doer condition covers both; "name inside the doer's
      phrase" covers only (70b).
YI-8  Deep vs shallow bi- (D2) predict opposite judgments for [N_P] [yi-N_A] bi-V (YI-3);   HYPOTHESIS (test); data OPEN
      ranking (one proximate per span) predicts *, like shallow.

9. Derivations, step by step

Labels: Σ role schema, A word, B clause. VPISH throughout: ρA is first-merged in Spec,v and ρP as the complement of V. The possessed noun word (N-W) is built at A with its owner slot π. Noun phrases are Merged at B and linked to slots (nominal adjunction). Horseherder's Spec,IP pro is restated as ρA (first-merged in Spec,v). Her "A′-position" for the possessor is restated as the specifier of the possessed noun phrase at B, or as a Topic position for a discourse antecedent. Each bundle carries person, number and index.

Y-1. (2) Joe yi-łįį́ʼ yizloh 'hef roped Joe'sj horse' ✓

  1. Σ Σ = {ρA: 3sg, index f; ρP: 3, index h (the horse)}. In the possessed noun: π: 3sg, index j.
  2. A N-W (left-headed, prefixal): Merge π with the stem 'horse'. Spell-out of π as yi- is held until its conditions can be checked (YI-1–4 need material outside the word).
  3. A W: Merge V 'rope' with ρP, then v, then ρA in Spec,v. Agree: the object prefix reads ρP (3), the subject marking reads ρA (3) → yizloh.
  4. B Merge Joe in the possessed phrase's specifier (her A′-position), index j, giving [Joe yi-łįį́ʼ]. Link it to ρP and place it left of the verb word (right-headed clause).
  5. B Checks. Agree (feature matching) π ↔ Joe: 3sg = 3sg, same index → YI-1 ✓. π ↔ ρA: 3sg = 3sg, indices j ≠ f, and ρA c-commands ρP's site → YI-3 ✓, YI-2 ✓.
  6. Spell-out: π → yi-; Joe yi-łįį́ʼ yizloh ✓, read 'hef roped Joe'sj horse'. If f = j ('Joe roped his own horse'), YI-2 fails → * (her (4c); some speakers marginal, fn. 2).

Y-2. *(8a) '…*I roped his horse': the doer is 1st person

  1. Σ Σ = {ρA: 1sg; ρP: 3 (horse)}; π: 3sg, index j; discourse Topic: Joe, 3sg, j.
  2. A N-W: Merge π + 'horse'. W: Merge V, ρP, v, ρA. Agree: subject 1sg → séloh.
  3. B π's A′-antecedent = Topic Joe: φ match ✓ (YI-1). π's disjoint A-antecedent = ρA: Agree fails, 1sg ≠ 3sg → YI-4 ✗. Spelling π as yi- crashes: *yiłįį́ʼ séloh.
  4. Ranking route (YI-6): ρA is off the third-person tier; the only third person is Joe/π, so π = [prx] → b-, not yi-. Same result, different reason.

Y-3. *(9a) 'The girls saw Mela … *they roped her horse for her': the doer is plural

  1. Σ Σ = {ρA: 3pl (the girls), index g; ρP: 3 (horse); beneficiary inside yá: 3sg, index m}; π: 3sg, index m; Topic: Mela, 3sg, m.
  2. A N-W: Merge π + 'horse'. W: Merge V 'rope', ρP, v, ρA; Agree: 3/3 → yizloh (no da- printed). The postposition word yá 'for her' is built at A.
  3. B YI-1: π ↔ Topic Mela, 3sg = 3sg ✓. YI-3/4: π ↔ ρA: index m ≠ g ✓, but number 3sg ≠ 3pl → Agree fails → *.
  4. Ranking route: 'the girls' [prx], Mela [obv], π = Mela → [obv] → yi- predicted ✓. Mismatch: only a number-sensitive condition gives *.
  5. Contrast with Y-4: if number were simply copied onto the verb's yi-, dayiiłtsą́ would also be out. It is fine, so the number check is specific to the owner slot π in the noun word (YI-5). HYPOTHESIS: in the verb word, number on the subject is read by a separate probe, da- (number & scope). In the noun word there is no such probe, and π's disjointness check includes number.

Y-4. dayiiłtsą́ 'They saw him' (Willie 1991:32 (9), carried over) ✓

  1. Σ Σ = {ρA: 3pl; ρP: 3}.
  2. A W: Merge V, ρP, v, ρA. Agree: object prefix reads ρP → yi-; da- reads ρA's plural. Spell-out: da-yi-iłtsą́ ✓.
  3. No owner slot, so no YI-4 check. Horseherder's own comparison (pp. 59–61): the verbal yi-'s coreferent antecedent is the object in an A-position. No A′-antecedent is needed.

Y-5. The D2 test, schematic: [NP] [yi-NA] bi-V

  1. Σ Σ = {ρA: 3sg, the doer, owned by a third person k; ρP: 3sg, index p}; π (in the doer's phrase): 3sg, k; Topic for k.
  2. A W: Merge V, ρP, v, ρA. Inverse: Agree spells bi-. Deep: Move ρP to an outer Spec,v above ρA. Shallow: no Move.
  3. B Link [yi-NA] to ρA, and NP to ρP.
  4. YI-3 for π: deep → ρP (3sg, p ≠ k) c-commands ρA's site ✓ → predicted good. Shallow → nothing c-commands ρA's site → predicted * (like (6b)). Ranking → * (§7). OPEN: no data; this relies on assumption A3 (the linked noun phrase counts at its slot's site).

10. Grant's ideas

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Feature bundles (or proto-words) as arguments. Not contradicted, and this is the most bundle-like condition found so far. YI-4 is stated entirely over person and number on two bundles, and one of the two antecedents can be a discourse topic with no noun in the sentence at all ((3b), (8a), (9b)). The condition that blocks (9a) is about a bundle that is not the owner. That is a pure feature-matching (Agree) effect, not a fact about noun content. Horseherder's claim that 'his horse' is in an A-position counts against the strict adjunct view, not against bundles. A noun linked to a slot that already holds a bundle sits at that slot's site (if A3 holds).

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Strata (theta roles first, event structure next, lexical items later). OPEN, consistent. In Y-1 to Y-3, YI-2 to YI-4 are checked on bundles (Σ/A). Only YI-1 needs anything at B, and even that can be met by a discourse topic. Nothing in Horseherder requires the noun 'horse' to be present before the owner's features are fixed.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Merge/Agree sites inside the word (Merge/Agree in the word). π is a Merge site inside the noun word (A). Its spell-out as yi- waits on Agree with material at B (Y-1 step 2). So the word-level rule set builds the slot, while the clause level supplies the antecedents the slot is checked against. This is a word-internal Agree site whose check crosses the A/B changeover. HYPOTHESIS

HYPOTHESIS Update 2026-10-25 (~12:46pm PT): What comes first decides reads Platero 1978 first-hand. 'The boyi was seen by hisi father' is good with bi-, with the name outside 'his father', and the yi- form cannot mean it (SOURCED). His precede-and-command rule, plus bi- putting the unspoken patient first, predicts W&J (70b)'s star with no plural condition and no Move in his notation. Restated in VPISH, (70b) separates "patient above the doer's phrase" (deep bi- or a null topic) from shallow bi-, so D2 stays OPEN. His (3.18) also clashes with Young & Morgan on yi- (T60b). For this page: the plural-doer lean (YI-7) is not needed for (70b), which has a ba- owner. The plural block on owner yi- ((9a)) stands as its own sourced fact.

11. Bottom line

12. Fidelity notes

13. Open questions

IDQuestionWhat would settle it
T59aT58a narrowed: plural doer or name inside the doer's phrase? Is 'John'si son saw himi' (singular, bi-, name inside) good?A singular version of W&J (70b), or (9a) with a singular doer and the name inside the doer's phrase. OPEN
T59bD2 test (YI-8): is [NP] [yi-NA] bi-V possible with an owner distinct from both?Any sourced Navajo sentence with yi- on the doer's noun under bi-. OPEN
T59cIs Horseherder's plural block about plural or about dual (no da- in (9a))? Does it hold with da-?(9a) with da- on the verb; Horseherder's consultants or another source. OPEN
T59dDoes the plural block also hold for yi- on postpositions (her Ch. 6 leaves verbs and postpositions open)?Postposition yi- with a plural doer; the instrument-voice lists may contain one. OPEN
T59eYoung & Morgan 1987:9 minimal pairs (her (5), including an inanimate possessum) first-hand.Y&M 1987, not opened. OPEN
T59fDogrib ye- first-hand (Saxon 1986, 1995): no A′-antecedent needed. Does Dogrib show the plural block?Saxon 1986 thesis / 1995; not opened. OPEN

Sources: Horseherder 1998 (UBC M.A. thesis; page images pp. 31–61); carried over: Willie 1991:32 (9), W&J 2000 (70), Aissen 2000. See also possessor-gap, possessor-binding, deep or shallow inverse, number & scope, Hale derivation (A3), open questions, sources.