Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.

SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading

Why did Hale move da- up? His reasons, and a causative test for high vs low (T55d, T55a)

Working note. Kept as written (URL, data and status labels unchanged). Filed under Deep or shallow inverse; da-; the consolidated argument is the essay deep-or-shallow. Rule IDs: rules index.

Restated on the unified structure (2026-11-15). The plural da- is restated as Dist⁰ just above vP, agreeing with the closest argument it c-commands, with the inverse patient counted from the outer Spec,vP (H21a/b). Its place inside the verb word is one of the misfits recorded for the Merge-site account of prefix order (OPEN). The head-direction mismatch argued below as rule sets A/B or a changeover is now stated as Grant’s Merge-site hypothesis and tested in §3.1–3.2. Position-class template statements below describe the order of prefixes; they are not the derivation (§3). Status on the spine: see unified structure, §4, distributive row and §3.2. The data, judgments, translations and citations below are unchanged; the analysis below is kept as the record of what was argued then.

2026-11-11 audit pass 3. A rule block written with Hale 2003’s M/S head was not marked as older notation; it is now labeled as a historical record. See the pass 3 report.

Local box file paths were removed from this page; files inside the repository are given by repo-relative path, and the source citation next to each removed path stays as the reference.

The pl-height page found that Ken Hale put the plural prefix da- low (inside the verb phrase) in 2001 but high (at the top of the word) in his 2003 manuscript, and asked whether he ever says why (T55d). It also asked for a test that tells "high" from "low" once the doer sits inside the verb phrase (T55a). This page re-reads both Hale works from the page images. In plain words: Hale never gives a reason that is about da- itself. He argues for the high position using preverbs (words like ‘to safety’), then applies the result to all the elements of the front part of the verb, da- included. He also says that the order of the pieces in the word is the same whichever height they sit at, so the order of the prefixes cannot settle the question. His causative examples suggest a test that can: in a "make someone do X" verb there are two doers, and a low da- could count only the one who is made to act. Navajo data with da- in such a verb was not on the box, so that test has not been run yet.

On this page: 1 Question · 2 Sources · 3 Data · 4 What Hale says, 2001 vs 2003 · 5 T55d answered · 6 A scope tension in the 2003 tree · 7 Toward T55a: Hale's height tests carried over to Pl · 8 Rules · 9 Derivations · 10 Grant's ideas · 11 Bottom line · 12 Open

Notation (the site's own; no Syntax · Semantics · Interface bot conventions file has arrived, so the provisional notation is kept). Σ = role-schema step; A = word level (rule set A: the prefixal, left-headed spine, spelled out as one word W); B = clause level (rule set B: right-headed clause syntax, noun linking). W is where A hands over to B. ρA = agent slot (labels ours); in a causative, ρA1 = causer, ρA2 = causee. Pl = the adjunct spelled out da- (template position III). Pl(H) = Pl adjoined to the top projection (QualP, else M/SP); Pl(L) = Pl adjoined to vP; in a causative with two v's, Pl(L1) = adjoined to vP1 (causer's vP), Pl(L2) = adjoined to vP2 (causee's vP). Pl(VP) = Pl inside VP below v (Hale 2001). PL-2H, DIST-1…6: da-reach; PL-H0–H4: pl-height §6.

Reminder: Merge builds structure; attaching da- or a preverb is Merge (adjunction), and moving something already built is internal Merge (Move). Agree values features such as person and number between a head and an argument without moving anything. This page is about where Merge attaches Pl, which decides what Pl's Agree probes can see (Agree looks only down the tree).

1. The question

2. Sources opened this run (2026-10-24, ~4:46am PT run)

  • Hale, Ken 2003 ms. "On the significance of Eloise Jelinek's Pronominal Argument Hypothesis" (box copy [local working copy, not in the repository]; PDF page = printed page). Page images at 130–150 dpi: pp. 15, 16, 19, 23, 24, 25, 30, 38, 42, 43, 70. Text layer: all 72 pages searched for Pl, da, plural, quantif, adjunct, dimension, flat, equidistant; pp. 14–30 and 41–44 read in full.
  • Hale, Ken 2001. "Navajo verb stem position and the bipartite structure of the Navajo conjunct sector." Linguistic Inquiry 32: 678–693 (box copy hale2001.pdf). Page images at 130 dpi: pp. 686, 689 (PDF pp. 9, 12). Page image also rendered for p. 688. Text layer: pp. 678–680, 686–689, 691–692.

Nothing else was opened. Rice 2000 and Young & Morgan 1987 (the source of Hale's causative examples) are not on the box.

3. The data SOURCED

All forms were transcribed from the page images (the text layer garbles ł, tone marks and ’). Hale gives no interlinear gloss lines. His own segmentation line is quoted as printed, and the category line below it is taken from his tree for the same example; it is labelled as his. Ø is his.

Hale 2003 (18a), p. 24 (Hale cites Young and Morgan 1987:373); tree (18c), p. 24
(1)habiishyeed
ha#b-y-sh-ł-l-gheed  (Hale's segmentation, as printed)
habyshłlgheed
Pv ‘up out’Obj (obl)QualM/Sv1v2V
‘I run him/her/it up out.’ (idiomatically) ‘I start it (car).’

Category line from Hale's tree (18c): Qual y > M/S sh > v1 ł > [vP2 Pv ha [vP2 Obj(obl) b [v2 l V yeed]]]. The tree prints the stem as yeed; the segmentation line as gheed (p. 24: "y = fronted gamma"). The gloss ‘up out’ for ha is Hale's (p. 43).

Hale 2003 (19), p. 25
(2)nabiishłá
na#b-y-sh-ł-Ø-á  (Hale's segmentation, as printed)
nabyshłØá
Pv ‘round and about’(no tree given; the category line of (1) would apply by analogy, which is ours)
‘I walk him/her (baby) about.’
Hale 2003 (31a), p. 38; tree (31b), p. 38
(3)Yisdánídashidoołtééł. (~ Yisdáádashidoołtééł.)
yisdánídashdwłtééł
PvRevPlObjQualM/SvV
‘They will get me back to safety.’

Category line from Hale's (31b)/(32). Tree (31b), top down: Pv yisdá, then Rev ní, then Pl da, each adjoined to QualP, above Qual d > M/S w > v ł > [Obj sh V tééł]. Already used on pl-height (1); re-checked against the p. 38 image this run.

Hale 2001 (15a, b), p. 686
(4)daacha
daØØCVCchaC
Plural (adjunct plane)Mode/SubjVoiceV
‘They cry.’

Tree (15b): Mode/Subj > Voice > [VP da Plural [VP V]]. Already used on pl-height (2); re-checked against the p. 686 image.

4. What Hale says, 2001 vs 2003 SOURCED

PointHale 2001 (LI 32)Hale 2003 ms.
Where the adjuncts (Pv, It/Rev, Pl) attachVP, below Voice and Mode/Subj ((15b), (16b), (21))"variable": high (the maximal projection of the highest functional head, Qual or M/S) or low (vP) (pp. 16–17); fn. 14: "maximal projection of v or Qual … proposed for Navajo"
What "attach" means geometricallyThe adjunct substructure "is a flat structure, properly speaking and despite appearances" (p. 688). "While the adjuncts, as a group and individually, asymmetrically c-command the verb, there are no asymmetric c-command relations among the adjuncts themselves." "One cannot speak of relative distance from the verb here because adjuncts and arguments belong to distinct dimensions" (p. 689)No such statement. The words dimension, flat and equidistant do not occur in the text layer. Fn. 13, p. 70: "Heretorfore [sic], however, I have regarded the planes as expositional devices only."
Why the preverb attaches where it doesPreverb and verb stem "form a unit in the lexicon, a fact well argued in Rice 2000" (p. 678); the preverb is a sister-like adjunct of V (as Hale 2003:15 summarizes it)p. 15: "In Hale (2001), I adopted this view for all preverbs … However, Sharon Hargus and Siri Tuttle (p.c.) question the correctness of this for preverbs in general, relegating this sister-like relation to Preverb-Verb combinations which are in some sense "truly lexical," unique combinations and idioms." p. 16: "I believe now that productive preverbs are variable, in keeping with their generally adverbial nature. In (9), the most prominent interpretation of the preverb has both the subject (in M/S) and the object in its semantic scope … I take this to mean that the preverb is adjoined to one or another of the phrasal projections defined by the functional heads Qualifier and M/S." "Since there is no evidence for one of these over the other, I will assume that the high adjunction site is the projection defined by the highest functional head present"
Pl specifically"the (distributive) plural [da]" is one of "two additional adjunct categories" (p. 686). Plural "is relevant to argument structure", Iterative "to event structure", and the two "do not ‘‘interact’’ in relation to semantic scope" (p. 689, after Rice)"The adjuncts — i.e., the preverbs and the quantifier elements (the event quantifiers It/Rev and the argument quantifier (Pl) — correspond to the disjunct sector … In (11), their high position corresponds straightforwardly to their leftward position in the template" (p. 17). No separate argument for Pl
MovementNo head movement; surface order by spell-out (pp. 680–688)p. 30: "there is no motivation at all for movement of adjuncts (the elements of the disjunct sector) — these must be alternatively base generated in the high or low position in any event."
Does height show in the word?Order among adjuncts is set by "scope alone", right to left (p. 689)p. 43: "Notice that the surface position of adjuncts does not vary according to whether they are attached high (above the subject) or low (below the subject). In either case, adjuncts precede the overt nuclear elements in the verbal projection"
Tests for low attachment (preverbs)—(a) subject outside the preverb's scope, (12)–(14), p. 19: "It is the coat alone that "comes to be in safety""; (b) idiomatic/"lexical" Pv+V, (15)–(16), with "thin ice" caveat (p. 21); (c) causatives, (17)–(18): "the preverb … must be lower than the surface subject (sh) within the derived causative configuration" (p. 23); but (19) has "both the agent (grammatical subject) and the "causee" (derived Obj) within the scope of the preverb" (p. 25); (d) labile transitives, (20)–(21), p. 26

5. T55d answered

SOURCED Hale gives no reason specific to Pl. The 2003 argument for the high site is made for preverbs: the preverb in (9) = (3) has the subject in its scope (p. 16), and Hargus and Tuttle's objection means the 2001 "sister of V" analysis holds only for lexical Pv+V units (pp. 15–16). On p. 17 the result is stated for "the adjuncts" as a class, which includes "the argument quantifier (Pl)". The only Pl-specific statements in the manuscript are that label (p. 17), the trees (11) and (31b), the planar display (32), and fn. 14 (Pl and It may also adjoin at VP in other Athabaskan languages). This is a text-layer search plus page images of the key pages; a garbled passage could in principle have been missed.

HYPOTHESIS Why Pl moved anyway: three ingredients, all Hale's, put together by us.

  1. Class membership. Pl belongs to the disjunct sector with the preverbs (2001:686; 2003:17). Once Hale makes the attachment of "the adjuncts" variable, Pl moves with the class.
  2. Height became a real claim. In 2001 the VP-adjoined position was inside a separate "adjunction structure" dimension, in which distance between adjuncts and arguments is not defined (p. 689). So "Pl below Mode/Subj" in (15b) made no scope claim about the subject. The 2003 manuscript drops the dimensions (none mentioned) and reasons from ordinary c-command and scope ("a projection which properly includes the subject", p. 16). Under that reading, a VP-internal Pl would be a real claim, and a false one for da- counting the subject, as in (4) and (3).
  3. No movement. Adjuncts are "base generated in the high or low position" (p. 30), and spell-out puts them in front whatever their height (p. 43). So the leftward surface position neither requires nor rules out high attachment, and the height has to be chosen at Merge on interpretive grounds.

Ingredient 2 is the step that turns the pl-height page's own motivation (Pl counts the subject) into a likely reason. It is still ours: Hale does not connect the dropped dimensions to Pl.

6. A scope tension in the 2003 tree

SOURCED Hale 2001 p. 689 (after Rice): "semantic scope is to the left, so that the iterative [ná ~ ní] and the plural (her distributive plural) [da] have the preverb within their scope"; "an element with wide scope is to the right of elements appearing within its scope." Hale 2003 p. 17 keeps this: the order among the adjuncts, "a side issue here, is determined by Rice's principles of semantic scope (Rice 2000; cf. Hale 2001)." But in trees (11) and (31b) the preverb yisdá is adjoined outermost, with Rev ní below it and Pl da closest to Qual.

HYPOTHESIS If (31b) is read as one ordinary tree, the way Hale reads it on p. 16 for the preverb and the subject, then Pv c-commands Pl and should take Pl in its scope. That is the reverse of the Rice scope statement Hale still cites. The two can be reconciled only if the height of the adjunct group relative to the nuclear heads and the argument slots is real, while the order inside the group is a scope-driven linearization that is not read off c-command. That is the 2001 flat structure surviving inside the 2003 tree. We state this as rule PL-R2. Hale does not flag the tension; this is our reading.

HYPOTHESIS PL-R2 does not hurt PL-2H. PL-2H needs only Pl's c-command over ρA and the inverse landing site, which is the group's height, not its internal order.

7. Toward T55a: Hale's height tests carried over to Pl

SOURCED Template position III is not evidence for Pl's height, because adjunct surface position "does not vary according to whether they are attached high … or low" (p. 43). Only meaning-based tests can decide. This sets aside the linear reading in pl-height PL-H4 as evidence about height (PL-H4 was already marked weak).

HYPOTHESIS A VPISH caveat on Hale's low sites, and a correction to the record. Hale's low site is vP, and it counts as "below the subject" only because his subject is in M/S ((14), (21)). Under VPISH ρA is first-merged in Spec,v, inside vP. Then a vP-adjoined preverb c-commands the subject's first position, yet (13) has the subject outside the preverb's scope. Two repairs: (i) the subject raises to Spec,M/SP (where Hale's M/S agreement sits) and scope is read from that copy; or (ii) the low site is below Spec,v (v′ or VP). Hale himself gives the subject an underlying Spec,v position and says it ordinarily enters "the usual portmanteau relation with Mode" (p. 42, SOURCED), which is closer to (i), but he does not say where scope is read. The pl-height page said the scope test cannot separate Pl(H) from Pl(L) under VPISH (its §5). That holds only if the subject stays in Spec,v. Under repair (i) the test separates them again: Pl(L) would be below the raised subject. This is T56b.

HYPOTHESIS The causative test. Hale's causatives contain two agent-like slots: the causer (his M/S sh; VPISH Spec,v1) and the causee (his Obj(obl) b in Spec,v2, (18c)). He says the causee "cannot fuse with Mode" and is "trapped within the v-projection" (p. 43), so it stays low under either repair. Hale shows that a preverb can attach inside vP2 ((18), scope over the causee only) or high ((19), scope over both). Carry this over to Pl with PL-2H probe (i) (Agree, downward, with the slot bearing the most Proto-Agent entailments):

Pl attached atSlots Pl c-commandsProbe (i) values # onPredicted reading of a da- causative
Pl(H): QualPρA1, ρA2, objectρA1 (causer: more Proto-Agent entailments)causers plural
Pl(L1): vP1ρA1 (first position), ρA2ρA1causers plural
Pl(L2): vP2 (Hale's site for ha in (18c))ρA2 onlyρA2causees plural, causer free
Pl(VP): inside VP2 (Hale 2001's site)no agent slotnothing (DIST-1 fails)no reading via probe (i)

HYPOTHESIS So the causative test separates Pl(L2) from {Pl(H), Pl(L1)}. It is the only test found so far that a da- verb can be put through without speaker judgments of scope over a Mode meaning: it asks who must be more than one, which grammars and dictionaries often record. It does not separate Pl(H) from Pl(L1); that still needs a Qual or Mode scope contrast (T55a's original suggestion) or repair (i) above.

OPEN No Navajo causative with da- was opened. Hale gives none, and Young & Morgan 1987 (his source for (17)–(19)) is not on the box. No form is supplied here (T56a).

8. Rules

OPEN Older notation: the block below uses Hale 2003’s M/S (Mode/Subject) head, which is not a node in our current trees. It is kept as a historical record, not as one of our analyses.

PL-R0  Hale 2003 argues for high adjunction on preverbs (subject scope, (9), p. 16; Hargus &  SOURCED
       Tuttle p.c., pp. 15–16) and states the result for "the adjuncts", Pl included (p. 17).
       There is no Pl-specific argument in the manuscript.
PL-R1  Adjuncts are base-generated high or low, never moved (p. 30); their surface position   SOURCED
       is the same at either height (p. 43).
       ⇒ template position III is no evidence for Pl's height.                              HYPOTHESIS (corollary)
PL-R2  The adjunct group's height is a real c-command relation to nuclear heads and slots;    HYPOTHESIS
       the order inside the group is scope-ordered linearization (Rice; Hale 2001:689), not
       c-command.  (Reconciles (11)/(31b) with Hale 2003:17.)
PL-R3  In a causative [Qual [M/S [vP1 ρA1 v1 [vP2 ρA2 v2 VP]]]], Pl(L2) values # on ρA2    HYPOTHESIS
       only; Pl(L1) and Pl(H) value # on ρA1 (PL-2H (i), downward).
PL-R4  Under VPISH, Hale's narrow-scope low adjuncts ((13), (20b)) need either subject        HYPOTHESIS
       raising to Spec,M/SP with scope read there, or a low site below Spec,v.
       With raising, subject scope separates Pl(H) from Pl(L) again (correction to
       pl-height §5 OPEN note).

9. Derivations, step by step

Labels: Σ role schema, A word (W), B clause. VPISH throughout: each agent-like slot is first-merged in its own Spec,v. Hale's subject sits in M/S; we put it in Spec,v1 and let M/S Agree with it. Only Hale's segmentations are used; the spell-out steps for (1) are his (p. 43), as printed.

Q-1. Hale (18a) habiishyeed ‘I run him/her/it up out’: low preverb in a causative

  1. Σ Σ(CAUS + ha#√RUN) = {ρA1 (causer), ρA2 (runner, causee)}. The embedded verb is unergative (Hale p. 23: "the complete (unergative) verbal projection (vP2, headed by v2 l, the inner classifier)").
  2. A Merge V yeed with v2 l. Merge ρA2 in Spec,v2 (Hale's Obj(obl) b is already there in (18c); p. 42: "The basic or underlying position of the subject of a v-projection is Specifier in that projection").
  3. A Merge (adjoin) Pv ha to vP2 (Hale (18c)). Its scope is vP2: "it is the car … which produces the "crying out"" (p. 23, said of (17); "the same argument is applicable" to (18)).
  4. A Merge v1 ł (the causative light verb). Merge ρA1 (1sg) in Spec,v1 (VPISH).
  5. A Merge M/S. Agree M/S ⟶ ρA1: person 1sg, spelled sh. ρA2 gets no Mode agreement and is oblique (Hale p. 42: "the subject of v will not enter into the usual portmanteau relation with Mode"; p. 43: it "cannot fuse with Mode"). Merge Qual y (the causative qualifier, p. 22).
  6. A Spell-out, nuclear plane (p. 43): after the inner and outer classifiers and M/S are placed in the skeleton (p. 42), "there is just the causative qualifier y in the nuclear plane; hypothetically this assumes the onset position, giving now the intermediate sequence *yishyeed".
  7. A Spell-out, nonnuclear plane: "prefixation of Obj(obl) gives hypothetical *biyishyeed which, by intervocalic glide deletion, surfaces as actual biishyeed. To this is prefixed the preverb ha" → habiishyeed. Seal W.
  8. B No overt nouns; the clause is W alone.

Ruleset A does steps 2–7; ruleset B has nothing to do. Step 7 shows PL-R1 at work: ha is attached in vP2, below the causer, yet it comes out leftmost.

Q-2. Hale (19) nabiishłá ‘I walk him/her (baby) about’: high preverb in a causative

  1. Σ Σ(CAUS + na#√WALK) = {ρA1 (causer), ρA2 (walker, causee)}.
  2. A As Q-1 steps 2, 4, 5, with inner v2 Ø and stem á (Hale's segmentation), and no adjunction inside vP2.
  3. A Merge (adjoin) Pv na to QualP. Hale: "both the agent (grammatical subject) and the "causee" (derived Obj) within the scope of the preverb. The agent manipulates the causee at every step and thus "moves round and about"" (p. 25).
  4. A Spell-out and Seal → nabiishłá (surface form as printed; Hale gives no step-by-step for (19)). Same linear slot for na as for ha in Q-1.

Q-1 and Q-2 together are Hale's evidence that one adjunct category can attach at either height in the same causative frame, with only the meaning to tell them apart.

Q-3. Schematic: a causative with Pl at three heights (no Navajo form)

Schematic word: [PL + CAUS + V], written DA-CAUS-V. No such Navajo word was opened, and none is supplied.

  1. Σ {ρA1 causer, ρA2 causee}.
  2. A Build vP2 (ρA2 in Spec,v2), then vP1 (ρA1 in Spec,v1), then M/S (Agree with ρA1), then Qual, as in Q-1.
  3. A Fork on where Pl is Merged: (L2) adjoined to vP2, right after step 2's vP2; (L1) adjoined to vP1; (H) adjoined to QualP.
  4. A Agree, PL-2H probe (i), looking down from Pl: (L2) the only agent slot in reach is ρA2 → causee plural; (L1), (H) ρA1 and ρA2 are both in reach, and ρA1 has more Proto-Agent entailments (it causes) → causer plural.
  5. A Spell-out: da- in position III in all three (PL-R1). Seal W.
  6. B Any nouns link to the slots after W is sealed. The plural reading comes from the slot, so a noun's own number cannot decide among the forks; the reading of who must be several can.

10. Grant's ideas

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Verbs take feature bundles, not nouns. Nothing here contradicts it. In Q-1 the causee is a pronominal element that "cannot fuse with Mode" (Hale p. 43), so its case depends on which head its bundle can combine with, not on any noun. In Q-3 Pl reads the slots' role entailments, never a noun. This is compatible with the conjecture; a pronominal-argument analysis predicts the same, so it is not proof.

GRANT'S CONJECTURE Strata (theta roles first, then event structure, then noun selection). Q-3 needs the role schema (Σ) fixed before Pl is merged, because probe (i) reads Proto-Agent entailments, and nouns enter only at B. That order fits the conjecture. The middle stratum gets no test: Hale 2001:689 (after Rice) says It/Rev (event structure) and Pl (argument structure) "do not ‘‘interact’’ in relation to semantic scope", so their relative order says nothing about which layer comes first. Neutral, not contradicting.

HYPOTHESIS The word as the A/B changeover. PL-R1 says rule set A linearizes adjuncts the same way at any height: nuclear heads fill the skeleton first, then nonnuclear material is prefixed (pp. 30, 43). Height matters for meaning (Agree, scope) but not for order inside W. On the site's terms, A's word-internal order is plane-driven, while B's clause order is not computed from the word's structure at all.

OPEN Intra-word Merge/Agree sites: vP2 adjunction in causatives (Q-1, Q-3 (L2)) is a candidate Merge site below an agent slot inside W. If da- can use it, it would be a word-internal Agree site that counts the causee alone. Chemistry: no correlate is claimed.

11. Bottom line

Hale never says why da- in particular moved up; he moved the whole class of front-of-verb elements on the evidence of preverbs (SOURCED). The likely reason it had to go with them is that his 2003 trees treat height as real scope, which his 2001 flat "adjunct dimension" did not (HYPOTHESIS). Prefix order cannot tell high from low (SOURCED, p. 43). A causative with da- could, by showing whether the causer or only the causee has to be plural (HYPOTHESIS; data not yet found).

12. Open

IDQuestionWhat would settle it
T55dHale's reason for moving Pl from VP (2001) to QualP (2003).Answered 2026-10-24 ~4:46am PT (§5): no Pl-specific reason (SOURCED); inherited from the preverb argument and the dropped dimensions (HYPOTHESIS). SOURCED
T55aPl(H) or Pl(L)?Narrowed (§7): prefix order ruled out (PL-R1); the causative test separates Pl(L2) from {Pl(H), Pl(L1)} (PL-R3); Pl(H) vs Pl(L1) still needs a Qual/Mode scope contrast or T56b. OPEN
T56aA Navajo causative with da-: must the causer be plural, or can the causees alone be plural?Young & Morgan 1987 causative entries (not on the box); Willie or Hale examples with da- + causative; speakers. OPEN
T56bUnder VPISH, do Hale's narrow-scope low adjuncts ((13), (20b)) require subject raising to Spec,M/SP (PL-R4 (i)) or a site below Spec,v (ii)?A Navajo test of the subject's height (binding, T53a), or Hale's own discussion of where scope is read. OPEN
T56cDoes Hale (or Rice) address the clash between (31b)'s Pv-outermost tree and leftward scope (PL-R2)?Rice 2000 (not on the box); other Hale manuscripts. OPEN

Sources: Hale 2003 ms. pp. 15–30, 38, 41–44, 70 (page images pp. 15, 16, 19, 23, 24, 25, 30, 38, 42, 43, 70); Hale 2001 pp. 678–689 (page images pp. 686, 689). Cross-links: how high is da-?, can da- count the patient?, plain ł-causer, spell-out rules, headedness, open questions, sources.