Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.
SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. The badge on our event-type and entailment assignments read “OURS”, which is not in the site’s label set; it now reads HYPOTHESIS. Navajo spellings printed with an ASCII apostrophe (for example in example sentences) now show the glottal stop as ʼ (U+02BC). No form, gloss or judgment changed.
Arguments: the theta frame
Transitive
Σ(√KILL.SG, v) = {ρA, ρP}
Event typeaccomplishment · caused change of state (death) HYPOTHESIS Ours, from the source's English translation.
Looks forρA killercaus, indep (vol not entailed: the printed agent is lightning)ρP the one killedchg, aff
Slot
Proto-role entailments (Dowty 1991 (27)/(28))
First-Merge site
Valued by (prefix / position)
Overt nominal links?
ρA killer
caus, indep (vol not entailed: the printed agent is lightning)HYPOTHESIS
Spec,v (direct) / internal under bi-
3rd: no separate exponent printed; the sources gloss the whole word (3ACC-3NOM, 3.3) and it is not segmented here.
Yes, as a linked adjunct (theta page C3): word order follows the topic rule (set B), not the slot's first-Merge site.
ρP the one killed
chg, affHYPOTHESIS
Comp,V
3rd: Object exponent yi- (direct) / bi- (inverse) when both slots are 3rd person (Willie 1991 §3.3; W&J 2000). ‘sg.’ in Willie's gloss; whether it concerns the object's number is not stated on the site (OPEN).
Yes, as a linked adjunct (theta page C3): word order follows the topic rule (set B), not the slot's first-Merge site.
Forms (as printed)
Form
Source's gloss / translation
Source
yiyiisxį́
3.3.killed sg.
Willie 1991:90 (73a)
biisxį́
(inverse; no gloss line printed)
Willie 1991:90–92 (73b)–(76)
biisxį́
(it-it-killed)
Witherspoon 1977:65 (9)
yiyiisxį
‘killed’; printed with hook but no tone mark (compare Willie's yiyiisxį́)
Hale & Platero 1974:13 (13)
Causative · inverse · fourth person
Inverse
SOURCED
yiyiisxį́ / biisxį́. Speaker variation: (74a) ii’ni’ łį́į́ʼ biisxį́ ‘The lightning killed the horse’ with the agent fronted under bi-; a fronted element cannot host the question clitic (76a) *ii’ni’ish łííʼ biisxį́. →
Fourth person
OPEN
Not yet sourced.
Causative
OPEN
Not yet sourced.
Control (Witherspoon)
SOURCED
Girl and water: Atʼééd tó biisxį́ ‘the girl can be drowned (killed) by the water’ (‘the girl can let the water kill her’), but *Tó atʼééd yiyiisxį́: “the water cannot drown (kill) the girl”, since it “does not possess intent or will” (Witherspoon 1977:65–66, 69). Same pattern as Willie's lightning/horse (73). →
Examples
(1)
✓
ʼiiʼni
łį́į́ʼ
yiyiisxį́
lightning
horse
3.3.killed sg.
‘The lightning killed the horse.’
Willie 1991:90, (73a)
Roles
ρA ’ii’niρP łį́į́ʼverb yiyiisxį́
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(2)
✓
łį́į́ʼ
ʼiiʼniʼ
biisxį́
(horse)
(lightning)
(no gloss line)
‘The horse was killed by lightning.’
Willie 1991:90, (73b)
Only (73a) has a gloss line in the source; word glosses here are carried over from (73a). ‘Lightning’ is spelled ’ii’ni (73a) and ’ii’ni’ (73b) as printed.
Roles
ρP łį́į́ʼρA ’ii’ni’verb biisxį́
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.