Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.
SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading
Headword · Navajo verb dictionary
sidá‘sits; with yii’/bii’ ‘in’: sits in’
StatusSOURCEDClassverb + postposition unitgrammatical vs lexical postposition by animacy
Stem / theme as printed not yet sourced (Willie glosses “3.sits”, “3.lies”, “DUAL.sitting”)
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. The badge on our event-type and entailment assignments read “OURS”, which is not in the site’s label set; it now reads HYPOTHESIS. Navajo spellings printed with an ASCII apostrophe (for example in example sentences) now show the glottal stop as ʼ (U+02BC). No form, gloss or judgment changed.
Arguments: the theta frame
Verb + -ii’
Σ(√SIT/LIE, with P ‘in’) = {ρ₁, Obl (object of -ii’)}
Event typenot assignedHYPOTHESIS Ours; Willie states no event type.
Looks forρ₁ what sits or liesnot assignedObl the containernot assigned
Slot
Proto-role entailments (Dowty 1991 (27)/(28))
First-Merge site
Valued by (prefix / position)
Overt nominal links?
ρ₁ what sits or lies
not assignedHYPOTHESIS
Spec,V (stative)
3
Yes: jooł (89), ʼasdzą́ą́ (90).
Obl the container
not assignedHYPOTHESIS
Comp,P (object of -ii’)
3 on the postposition: bi- (89a), yi- (90)
Yes: chidí.
Forms (as printed)
Form
Source's gloss / translation
Source
biiʼ siʼą́
3.in 3.lies ‘The ball is in the car.’ (with jooł chidí)
Willie 1991:97 (89a)
*yiiʼ siʼą́
(‘The ball is in the car.’) marked *
Willie 1991:97 (89b)
yiiʼ sidá
3.in 3.sits ‘The woman is sitting in the car.’ (with ʼasdzą́ą́ chidí)
Willie 1991:98 (90)
??? biiʼ sidá
INV3.in 3.sits ‘[The car is sitting in the woman]’ (with ʼasdzą́ą́ chidí)
Willie 1991:98 (91)
biiʼ séké
3.in DUAL.sitting ‘I sit with my mother in the car.’ (with shimá bił chidí)
Willie 1991:98 (92)
Causative · inverse · fourth person
Grammatical vs lexical
SOURCED
With an inanimate subject the -ii’ phrase is lexical with bi- (89a, *89b); with an animate subject yiiʼ “must be interpreted as a grammatical postposition, and the Inverse alternation applies” (Willie p. 98). →
Local person
SOURCED
“Recall that Inverse cannot apply when there is a first or second person argument in the clause”: (92) has biiʼ with a first-person subject (Willie p. 98). →
Examples
(1)
✓
jooł
chidí
biiʼ
siʼą́
ball
car
3.in
3.lies
‘The ball is in the car.’
Willie 1991:97 (89a)
(2)
*
jooł
chidí
yiiʼ
siʼą́
ball
car
(‘The ball is in the car.’)
Willie 1991:97 (89b)
(3)
✓
ʼasdzą́ą́
chidí
yiiʼ
sidá
woman
3.in
3.sits
‘The woman is sitting in the car.’
Willie 1991:98 (90)
Willie’s page prints the first word with underlined vowels; shown here without them. Check the scan before quoting the spelling.
Notes
Willie p. 97 also states: “In intransitive sentences, there are no Inverse forms, and no grammatical postpositional phrases, only lexical ones.” Her (79)–(80) (yáłtiʼ, p. 94) show an inverse with an intransitive verb and a PP, so the two statements need reconciling (T32e).