Authority caveat. Nobody on this site claims to know Navajo authoritatively. Every Navajo form is copied from a named published source with its example number; none is invented. Formal rules are hypotheses to be tested against Grant's texts.
SOURCED stated in a published source we opened HYPOTHESIS our formalization or inference GRANT'S CONJECTURE Grant's own claim OPEN needs data or reading
2026-11-11 audit pass 2. The badge on our event-type and entailment assignments read “OURS”, which is not in the site’s label set; it now reads HYPOTHESIS. Navajo spellings printed with an ASCII apostrophe (for example in example sentences) now show the glottal stop as ʼ (U+02BC). No form, gloss or judgment changed.
Arguments: the theta frame
Existential + comitative postposition
Σ(√EXIST) = {ρ₁} + PP[-í ‘with’]
Event typestateHYPOTHESIS Ours, from the source's English translation.
Looks forρ₁ what exists (the possessed)indep?; no P-A entailmentsObl possessorsent (ours)
Slot
Proto-role entailments (Dowty 1991 (27)/(28))
First-Merge site
Valued by (prefix / position)
Overt nominal links?
ρ₁ what exists (the possessed)
indep?; no P-A entailmentsHYPOTHESIS
Spec,V
3 (NLA glosses exist.NI and 3-exist.NI)
Yes: dibé ‘sheep’.
Obl possessor
sent (ours)HYPOTHESIS
Obl(P): object of -í ‘with’
2 in nee ‘2-with’
Not printed with a lexical DP.
Forms (as printed)
Form
Source's gloss / translation
Source
hólǫ́
exist.NI / 3-exist.NI
NLA Navajo Questions, yes/no (1), (15)
Causative · inverse · fourth person
Clause level
SOURCED
Da’ must be clause-initial; -ísh attaches to the first word; ya’ follows the clause (NLA (2)–(4), (15)). →
‘Have’
OPEN
‘Have’ is the postposition + verb pairing (nee hólǫ́ ‘you have’). Chee 2025 also prints hólǫ́ ‘it exists’ beside shee hólǫ́ ‘I have’ (prior-run note, not re-checked). →
Examples
(1)
✓
Dibé
nee
hólǫ́.
sheep
2-with
exist.NI
‘You have sheep.’
NLA, Navajo Questions, yes/no (1)
Roles
ρ₁ DibéObl neeverb hólǫ́.
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(2)
✓
Daʼ
dibé
nee
hólǫ́?
Q
sheep
2-with
exist.NI
‘Do you have sheep?’
NLA, Navajo Questions, yes/no (2)
Roles
ρ₁ dibéObl neeverb hólǫ́?
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.
(3)
*
Dibé
daʼ
nee
hólǫ́?
(da’ in second position)
NLA, Navajo Questions, yes/no (3a)
(4)
✓
Dibé
nee
hólǫ́,
yaʼ?
sheep
2-with
3-exist.NI
right
‘You have sheep, don’t you?’
NLA, Navajo Questions, yes/no (15)
Roles
ρ₁ DibéObl neeverb hólǫ́,
Linking read off the source's translation (ours); “verb” marks the word whose prefixes value the slots.